The hot topic of childcare
Must be elections coming up; politicians make big promises on free childcare.
In an effort to reach out to working mothers, childcare has been brought to the forefront of the 2015 election – with the three main parties promising increased free provision for three to four-year-olds.
The Conservatives have pledged 30 free hours, with Labour and the Liberal Democrats in close pursuit.
With many women taking lower paid part-time jobs while their children are young, and families struggling with the high cost of childcare nationwide, are these measures a good thing?
Under the current system all three and four-year-olds in England are entitled to free childcare for 570 hours per year.
This usually equates to fifteen hours per week, for 38 weeks.
In recent years this has also been extended to include the most deprived two year-olds.
In Scotland the provision is for 600 hours per year and in Wales three and four year-olds are eligible for ten hours per week, for 52 weeks. In most cases, until the age of three, all childcare costs must be borne by the child’s family.
The problem is the current system isn’t actually working.
The National Day Nurseries Association (NDNA) has warned that increasing free childcare without adequate investment could seriously damage the nursery sector.
The NDNA reports that 85 per cent of nurseries are making a loss as a result of the scheme.
What this means in real terms is that the government cannot afford to pay nurseries the true cost of the current ‘free’ childcare for 3-4 year-olds. The scheme is essentially being propped up by parents of younger children attending the same nursery, and the nurseries themselves.
If the scheme doubles, where will the additional money required come from?
Purnima Tanuku, chief executive of NDNA, said: “While we welcome this commitment to provide more support to families with the cost of childcare, we warn that doubling the number of hours will just double the problem, resulting in significant cost increases for parents of children under three and also nursery closures.
“With the current 15 free hours, there is already a chronic underfunding issue, so any extension of this provision must be thoroughly costed and properly funded so that it can be delivered sustainably and without a reduction in quality.”
This costing funding issue was raised earlier this year by the House of Lords Committee on Affordable Childcare.
In the report they released in February, the Committee made it clear they did not think an extension of the free early education entitlement to 25 hours per week would be sustainable.
It is not only the case that nurseries are being underfunded and subsidised by fee-paying parents of younger children, there are also issues of quality.
The House of Lords report highlighted that the inadequate quality of many childcare providers could in fact be detrimental to the development of the children in their care; 28 per cent of two year-olds attend nurseries not rated ‘good’ or ‘outstanding’.
The report said “Since the quality of provision is critical in delivering improved child outcomes, this does not appear to be a good investment for the 40 per cent most disadvantaged children.”
With this focus on childcare for working families, all parties are acknowledging that raising your children while you are working has become the norm not the exception.
This is good news for women.
In 2015, 68 per cent of mothers with dependant children work. Clearly, childcare provision is an important issue and it is right that the political parties are finally giving it the attention it deserves.
But it is not just about cost.
Quality is just as important, as is flexibility.
Many women choose to return to work only part-time because they wish to spend more time with their children.
The House of Lords Report did acknowledge that cost of childcare is not the only factor which determines whether or not a mother returns to work, saying ‘The availability of high quality part-time and flexible employment opportunities can be as important in enabling parents to work, and to progress in their careers, as the cost of childcare.’
With these proposals the parties have failed to recognise that what many working mothers seek is a greater life balance – to work and to also spend time with their children.
Their current proposals are designed on the basis that all women want to put their children into childcare and return to work full time.
In reality, what many women want is the opportunity for flexible working. In roles that do not require a full-time presence in an office and yet where their skills and experience are duly recognised.
But too often part-time equals low pay and low skilled.
Given the major concerns outlined by industry leaders and the House of Lords Report, it is clear that extending the provision without serious investment will not be workable.
The introduction of 30 hours universal ‘free’ childcare for three and four-year olds should not be to the detriment of fee-paying parents of younger children.
Further information must be provided about exactly how any future government will pay for these suggested improvements to childcare provision.
Women want to work, but women also want quality, affordable childcare options.
Sadly it seems that even though childcare has been given ‘high priority’ status, it is not been given the consideration it deserves.
As Neil Leitch, of the Pre-School Learning Alliance, said: “It is important to remember that childcare is about more than enabling parents to return to work.
“The first five years of a child’s life are crucial to their long-term development – as such, it is vital that whoever is in government after May 7 is willing and able to provide the investment that providers need to be able to deliver affordable, sustainable and, crucially, high-quality early education and care.”
Let’s hope whoever wins on 7 May listens to him.
















The impact of additional free hours on community childcare providers is not properly assessed. Whist welcoming additional provision, we need to know who will be the designated providers and how they will be paid.