subscribe: Posts | Comments

Analysis of domestic violence attacked

3 comments

Heather Harvey from the women’s charity Eaves discusses a new think tank paper which challenges domestic violence as a gendered crime.

The paper, “Beyond Violence” was published this summer by the leading Conservative think tank the Centre for Social Justice (CSJ).

The CSJ was established by Conservative MP and secretary for the department of work and pensions, Iain Duncan Smith.

In the paper, the CSJ endorses the suggestion that 89 per cent of DV is what can be termed “situational couple violence”, which occurs between two mutually abusive partners within a dysfunctional relationship.

It states only 7 per cent of DV is “coercive and controlling”.

By suggesting that only 7 per cent of DV is “real DV” as we understand it, the position taken by the CSJ is reminiscent of the notion of “real rape” and “less-than real rape” promoted recently, most notably by Republican politician Todd Akin and by people commenting on the rape cases of Roman Polanski and Julian Assange.

The CSJ suggests a new crime should be framed to deal with the 7 per cent of “real DV”.

The remaining 89 per cent of “situational couple violence”, which they describe as a being driven by “hot, emotional issues”, can, according to the CSJ, be dealt with by relationship counselling.

Eaves work closely with women who have suffered domestic violence. We believe this paper represents a cynical, ideological attempt to degender DV and to reduce the government’s obligations to respect and protect women’s human rights.

The CSJ paper seeks to provide the rationale for a further reduction in funding for DV services.

But language which recasts DV into an issue of relationship and behaviour management attempts to reduce police responsibility for what accounts currently for a quarter of violent crime.

By minimising the seriousness of DV, the CSJ tries to reduce women’s right to refuge and their recognition as a priority group for accommodation.

If the analysis and the recommendations of this paper are accepted, we risk returning to a time where DV was regarded as a private matter between individuals rather than a matter for which the state has a responsibility to address adequately.

Here are some of the worrying excerpts from the paper:

“We do not address forms of domestic abuse specific to ethnic, sexual orientation, age, immigrant or other groups.”

“This report looks at the root causes of domestic abuse and provides solutions grounded in evidence rather than ideology. We avoid overly simplistic narratives that ascribe all the blame for domestic abuse to male desire to control and subjugate women.”

“While power, control and patriarchy are explanatory factors in many contexts of domestic abuse, there are many others that are also significant, including poverty, substance misuse, psychological vulnerabilities rooted in people’s past experience and the dynamics that play out between two people in a relationship.”

“A woman’s level of depression can also have some bearing on men’s violent behaviour.”

“In many areas of social policy people are treated as individuals and the importance of interpersonal connections is lost. Domestic abuse is a problem with a relationship and solutions lie within this and other relationships.”

“Current policy and practice is dominated by the important but insufficient goals of punishing perpetrators and ensuring safety for victims.”

Here are some quotes from the list of recommendations made by the paper:

“The Home Office and/or the Ministry of Justice should pilot a number of restorative justice programmes specific to domestic abuse.”

“We recommend that local authorities and other commissioners of domestic abuse services do not neglect any particular group of victim in their commissioning….In practice this could mean giving priority to universal services rather than to those which, for example, work only with a particular minority ethnic community. This may involve ….mergers. (One criterion for evaluating refuges could be how well they meet the needs of diverse victims).”

“Perpetrators’ programs should have at least two streams – one for perpetrators involved in strategic, controlling abuse and the other for those with more “hot emotional” reasons behind their behaviour. Funding should be redirected from “traditional” approaches”.

Click here to read a full copy of the “Beyond Violence” paper.

This was based on a special edition of Eaves’ women’s weekly news. To subscribe to this weekly newsletter please go to: http://www.eavesforwomen.org.uk/newsletter/womens-weekly

  1. vicki wharton says:

    I am so angry at this I can barely type. My last two partners have both used violence to try to force me to accept being lied to or stolen from. Most men use pornography which describes women as bitches and whores at best. If we can understand that calling a black person a nigger or wog will lead to interpersonal violence, why can’t we make the same correlation as to male attitudes towards women that most men buy in to. Rudeness,pushing, shoving, systematic lying to your partner to cheat them out of being treated with respect and equality … 2 out of 3 girls at school are assaulted by boys and yet this can be rebranded by the conservatives as non gendered violence. I guess Jimmy Saviles attacks were also non gendered and Rochdale victims assaults also had nothing to do with gender. WTF?

  2. Posted on behalf Dr Elly Farmer, a Clinical Psychologist and co-author of a Centre for Social Justice report on domestic abuse.

    I am the lead author of the paper ‘Beyond Violence’ analysed in this article. Some critical comments:

    1) This article very much misrepresents the report, it states and implies that we say things that we categorically do not say. I make a plea for all readers to not form an opinion on our report until they have read it (or at least the executive summary) rather than on the basis of what is a disingenuous analysis of it.
    2) A specific example: Never do we use (or even imply) the term ‘real DV’. Never do we say that only 7% of DV is coercive and controlling. Never do we say that 89% is situational couple violence with two mutually abusive partners. Throughout we treat all DV as extremely serious. We do draw (research-based and uncontroversial) distinctions between forms, dynamics and situations of DV, but this is not to minimise some types, but rather so that the policy and practice response can be nuanced to account for all its forms, not just the form that is currently the dominant focus of attention. For example, not all victims want to leave their perpetrators – do we ignore this group of victim (as is current policy) or do we engage with their complex feelings or ambivalence and/or their hope that their partner might change?
    An analogy: Does talking about the different forms of child abuse (e.g. physical, sexual, emotional) mean that we are suddenly saying some forms are ‘real abuse’ and others aren’t? Even if we went so far as to say that some forms of abuse, say parental inflicted, was particularly harmful, does that mean that we are saying the other forms are not real or serious? Of course not! The author of this article has taken our attention on nuances within domestic abuse and then imagined that we took a further, extremely problematic step, to say some forms aren’t real or serious. Rather, by drawing attention to the different dynamics and manifestations of the problem, we are in fact hoping to inspire a much more comprehensive approach to prevention and intervention – yes one that does unapologetically move beyond physical safety for victims, punishment for perpetrators and challenging sexist attitudes in society. Because this limited menu of responses is not enough to stop the problem.
    3) BUT we are not saying that any of these interventions are wrong, and I am a passionate believer in all of them. Of course sexism plays a major part in domestic abuse and must be challenged. (I am a passionate advocate for women’s rights and that is why the charities I choose to support are Eaves, Object, ECPAT and Marie Stops).
    4) We recommend a new law to tackle domestic abuse that involves a partner systematically controlling and subjugating his victim. Very manipulative perpetrators will often plan their abuse so as to be beyond the reach of the law (for example, individualising their abuse to their victim’s vulnerabilities and avoiding serious physical violence whilst still exerting maximum pain and humiliation). This new law (focussed on patterns of control) would complement existing law (focussed on discrete incidents of physical violence) to increase the criminal justice response, so that more perpetrators can be convicted for serious crimes, in line with their serious wrongdoing. Interestingly, I was invited to blog about this on the Conservative Home website (see: http://conservativehome.blogs.com/platform/2012/07/dr-elly-farmer-the-law-must-be-updated-to-recognise-the-worst-form-of-domestic-abuse.html), and many of the comments in response were hostile as they saw this proposal as interfering in people’s private lives (so this report is doing the opposite of ‘taking us back to a time when DV is seen as a private matter between individuals’).
    5) By mentioning male victims (surely it would never be right to ignore a person’s victimization because of their gender, however much of a minority they are in?), we are not challenging the gendered nature of domestic abuse (even though many others do, whom we do not concur with!); our report makes many comments about the gender biases in DV and influences on them, for example:
    ‘Women are more likely to be victims of domestic abuse, but male victims are not infrequent’ and:
    ‘When female victims are seen as deserving of abuse, taught to accept violence and not given the support to escape it, domestic abuse escalates.’
    6) Many of the excerpts from our report are taken completely out of context to give a misleading impression of our meaning; just one example – the comment about different groups actually reads:
    ‘Neither does the report cover in any depth specific forms of domestic abuse which require specialist solutions, for example, forced marriage, or domestic abuse in specific ethnic, sexuality, age or immigrant status groups. Our recommendations aim to reduce the prevalence and impact of all forms of abuse, and we pay particular attention to services providing equal and accessible support. However specific groups require further attention beyond the scope of this report.’ (italics added).
    7) Our report argues for a more holistic refuge response, the converse of ‘seek[ing] to provide a rationale for a further reduction in funding for DV services’. The report argues for a huge amount more to be done to tackle DV and so I am of course totally opposed to funding cuts for DV services!!
    8) It is true that our report does seek to move beyond the analysis of DV that says that it is all about power, control and patriarchy. We argue that these are central elements but there are other aspects that need to be recognised and addressed, e.g. perpetrator insecurity, victim low self-esteem, poverty and substance misuse. Crucially we argue for a ‘Both/And’ approach – both psychosocial factors play an important role and ending DV will necessitate tackling these elements, and DV is a serious crime for which the perpetrator is fully responsible for, and must be held by society to account for (and our recommendations aim to do both).
    9) ‘As movements move from the margins to the mainstream, they need to adapt to the complexities of the problem they are aiming to address’. This may feel messy, and there may be a fear that a more complex message will eclipse clear messages about responsibility, blame and sexism. But our report shows that this need not be the case, but rather, a simplistic account of the problem hampers an effective response, leaving more victims and their children suffering and potentially blamed.
    10) I hope that Eaves and the CSJ can continue a productive debate and discussion about DV, and that a some meeting of minds can take place to help us achieve our same end goal.

    • vicki wharton says:

      Considering the Government plays footsie with media houses that sell sexist propoganda that portrays DV as cool to boys and men, think we need to keep very focused on the institutional sexism going on here and who is making money from portraying females as generic whores.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *