subscribe: Posts | Comments

Government abandons abortion counselling consultation

1 comment

A government health minister has announced that plans to force women to endure independent counselling before undergoing an abortion have been scrapped.

At a Westminster Hall debate on Wednesday, health minister Anna Soubry announced that since the government had no plans to change the current law on abortion counselling, a consultation on the issue would be “an otiose exercise”.

“I have carefully considered how we move forward on abortion counselling. I believe that the best way forward is about contraception, how we reduce the repeat abortion rate, how we empower young men and women and how we improve abortion counselling services for women generally,” she said.

The cross-party consultation, set up by the former health minister Anne Milton, had been established in spite of the comprehensive defeat of a similar proposal, raised by Nadine Dorries, in a parliamentary debate last year. The cross-party group, which included Dorries, Fiona Bruce, and Louise Mensch in its pro-life ranks, were understood to be investigating how the “spirit” of such proposals could be incorporated into new regulation.

They had been examining a number of options for abortion counselling including restricting in-house counselling services, like those offered by BPAS and Marie Stopes, as well as creating a register of counsellors – which would have included anti-abortion outfits, as well as GPs and pro-choice organisations.

The initial proposals laid out by the consultation had been met with hostility among abortion campaigners. Tracey McNeill, director of UK and Europe at Marie Stopes, said: ‘We simply don’t believe that organisations whose own publications describe abortion as a ‘most grievous sin’ can provide impartial pregnancy counselling to women.’

In like manner, shadow health minister Diane Abbott, who resigned from the cross-part group earlier this year, claimed that it was simply a vehicle for the government to drive an anti-abortion agenda without suitable debate in parliament.

Following Soubry’s cancellation of the consultation, Abbott described it as, ‘A victory for women, families and pro-choice campaigners’ and urged the government to desist from further using the issue as a ‘political football‘.

Dorries, however, has accused the government of reneging on an “absolute commitment to consult“, calling Soubry’s decision “bizarre“.

“Jeremy Hunt believes in a 12-week limit but he is not trying to push his agenda on women because he acknowledges it is his personal belief. Anna Soubry has a personal belief. What she has done is try to impose her personal belief on her role and that is out of order.”

Nonetheless, the announcement has been welcomed by pro-choice campaigners; Abortion Rights, who said in a statement: “From the start we have been clear that the proposals were misguided, unnecessary and not in the best interest of women’s health.

“Politicians should be on notice that the UK’s pro-choice majority will not accept any further restriction on our right to choose, whether it’s through counselling, reducing the abortion time limit or any other measure.”

Further restriction remains high on Nadine Dorries’ agenda and abortion may face further threats next year. At the same Westminster Hall debate that Soubry announced her decision, Dorries renewed her intention to raise the issue for further debate in May 2013.

“My campaign” she recently said in an interview with Mehdi Hassan, “is for a 24 to 20 [week abortion limit]. It has been since the day I got here.”

Those personal pronouns seem to tell of Dorries’ own very “personal belief”, the imposition of which, in her own words, really is “out of order” to the pro-choice majority.

  1. Good riddance.
    If the consultation was stopped because there was no intention to amend the law, why did they start it in the first place?
    Is there something they’re not telling us??

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *