subscribe: Posts | Comments

Women and Politics: Real ‘Girl Power’

3 comments

Women in the UK are just as angry as those in the US and they’ll show it, too.

Following Barack Obama’s recent re-election for a second term as US President, many commentators in the UK are talking about lessons UK politicians could learn from his victory.

Could I suggest that the biggest lesson would be to have an opponent who forgets that women can vote?

Because Republican nominee Romney certainly appeared to, and he wasn’t alone. Ridiculous numbers of Republican politicians suffered from this collective amnesia.

From Todd Akin who believed that pregnancy resulting from a ‘legitimate rape’ was a biological impossibility, to Richard Mourdock who believed it was not only possible but positively ‘intended by God’ (fight it out between yourselves, boys; the Almighty will be your referee).

Via all the other stuff various Republicans felt we needed to know about all kinds of rape.

All the way through to Rick Santorum, who wanted individual US states to have the power to make birth control illegal, because, you know, it allows women to have (shh!) sex outside marriage without being punished with pregnancy, it was clear that the fact that women actually had a vote – one whole one each! – had entirely slipped their minds.

Bless.

Thankfully, women themselves didn’t forget, turning out to vote for Obama in huge numbers. A small number of women, obviously confused, voted for Romney, but they were mostly married and we know what that can do to a woman’s brain. It makes them more likely to vote Conservative.

Is this why David Cameron is so ‘pro-family’? And so supportive of gay marriage?

Whatever the reasons, Obama’s victory and the decisive role women played in it, should give the Prime Minister pause for thought when it comes to his own party’s relationship with women.

Because Cameron doesn’t like women.

Oh, he likes some women, sure. His wife and Rebekah Brooks, for example. He’s probably also – although this is pure speculation – found a little bit of love for Nadine Dorries now she’s 10,000 miles away. I know I have.

But collectively? As an entire, seething mass?

Not so much.

He started well when he won the Conservative leadership election, declaring up front that the party needed ‘to change the scandalous under-representation of women in the Conservative party…’, and introducing the party’s ‘A-list‘, his big idea for increasing not only the number of female Tory MPs, but also the number of ethnic minority MPs.

However, the A-list has recently been dropped, officially on the basis that it has ‘done its job‘.

Apparently an increase in ethnic minority MPs from 2 to 11 is job done. As is having a huge 47 female MPs out of a total of 304.

Last time I looked, 47 was some way off being half of 304. In the same election in 2012, Labour lost 90 MPs, but of the 251 it kept, 84 were female, which is still not within shouting distance of half, but at least looks as if it’s trying.

But maybe I’m just being picky. Cameron can make efforts to increase female candidates, but he can’t ensure they all get elected, can he?

But he can decide what happens to them when they do.

And for all his talk, Cameron’s cabinet initially included just five female members, a truly pathetic number for a man who professes to want to ‘change [women’s] scandalous under-representation’.

Even better, after being told his party had a ‘woman problem‘ and was shedding female voters faster than an alopecic cat sheds hair, his next Cabinet re-shuffle kicked two of them out and made a third, Baroness Warsi ‘(female, Asian and, my God, working class) even more the Tory token that she is by keeping her in the Cabinet but without a proper job.’

And let’s not even talk about his ‘Calm down, dear‘ type-gaffes. Or the fact that, earlier this month, Dame Helen Ghosh, the former Home Office permanent secretary, launched a withering attack on Cameron and his dude-centric clique, made up of friends from Eton and the Bullingdon Club. Dame Helen made the point that the clique was not exactly filled with, nor welcoming to, women.

But maybe all this doesn’t matter. Maybe there are simply not enough women in the UK who care about female representation enough to make it matter.

The Conservative party is not, after all, the Republican party.

Conservative MPs, even the worst of them, know better than to stray into discussions about rape (for which we can thank Ken Clarke), and the thought that any of them would wade in on the morality of – or NHS provision of – birth control seems, well, bizarre. Recent pronouncements by various MPs about abortion time limits are worrying, but these can potentially be written off as ‘personal’ statements by those involved.

Even without the outright war on women fought by the Republicans that ‘woman problem we were talking about before? It’s still there.

And it isn’t still here because of anything as esoteric as a lack of female MPs.

Women, especially single women, supported Obama in droves not because they voted with their ‘lady parts‘, but because they found themselves being disproportionately affected by the downturn in the US economy. And in a time of such economic hardship, threats to take away women’s rights to vital stuff like Planned Parenthood and affordable healthcare mattered, ultimately, more than Republican idiocies on rape because these were things that were enabling many, many women to keep their heads above water.

Women just couldn’t afford to have them taken away.

And this is where Cameron really does need to take notice.

Because women in the UK find themselves in a very similar position to those in the US.

Following its 2012 budget announcing swathes of cuts, Cameron’s government was subject to a legal challenge by the Fawcett Society for its failure to conduct a gender equality impact assessment on the effect of those cuts, which it was legally required to do. Fawcett asserted that of the £8bn of savings outlined in the budget, £5.8bn would come from women.

Fawcett’s challenge was unsuccessful, on the basis – reading between the lines – that the judge found the whole thing a bit silly.

But for women now living through the brunt of government cuts, the outcome of the challenge is academic, and it’s no surprise that women started turning say from the Conservative party from early 2011, as the reality of the cuts started to hit home.

And women are not taking this lightly.

Pollster Deborah Mattinson noted as much:

‘I have rarely experienced such anger . . . These women were all working very hard. Several were juggling family and more than one job. They all feared losing those jobs in the coming months.

‘Most had endured pay freezes while simultaneously coping with rising bills, especially on essentials like gas, electricity and food.

‘Those with younger kids felt that their ambitions for university had been dashed. Those with older kids wondered if they would ever get a job.

‘While the men were more tolerant of the government’s economic strategy the women were personally affronted.’

As well they might be. When a government refuses to recognise that its cuts have a massively disproportionate impact on women, it is personal.

So the next election in the UK will not be decided on ‘women’s issues’. It will be all about ‘the economy, stupid’  – how could it be otherwise? But until the Tories realise that the economy is, increasingly, the women’s issue, they’ll continue to personally affront women.

And that’s a bad idea. Because women can vote. Remember?

  1. clap clap 🙂

    • vicki wharton says:

      Trouble is, who do you vote for when both leading parties treat women as a minority vote and systematic violent discrimination against us as a joke? That’s the question …

  2. India Thorogood says:

    Well said!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *