subscribe: Posts | Comments

Criminalise paying for sex in Scotland, say campaigners

1 comment

Scottish campaign sparked by increasing concern over Edinburgh’s sauna businesses.

Labour MSP Rhoda Grant is pushing for paying for sex in Scotland to be criminalised.

In the UK, although solicitation in a public place, brothels and ‘kerb crawling’ are all illegal, the act of paying for sex itself is not a criminal offence.

But 2012 has seen campaigns in both Scotland and Northern Ireland to change the law.

Rhoda Grant introduced a private members bill to Holyrood this month – the ‘Criminalisation of the Purchase of Sex (Scotland) Bill’ – and it is now open for consultation.

The bill would criminalise the purchaser of sex, rather than the prostitutes themselves.

The Scottish campaign has been sparked by increasing concern over the Edinburgh sauna trade.

Edinburgh began granting licences to saunas in 1986, and currently has 15 licensed saunas.

The saunas are used to sell sex, and are accused of trafficking women – yet are tolerated by local officials and councillors.

In 2007, a police investigation found seven victims of trafficking in Edinburgh – with women brought from Eastern Europe, as well as East Asia.

However, although Scotland has a disproportionate amount of human trafficking in comparison with the rest of the UK – the police have failed to convict anyone on these charges.

Could this change in the law make it easier for Scottish police?

The Glasgow-based Trafficking Awareness Raising Alliance (TARA) has supported ‘at least two women’ who were exploited by saunas in Scotland’s capital.

The organisation disputes claims by some that saunas make sex work safer, saying: “TARA believes the majority of women involved in off-street prostitution are harmed and there is no way to make an inherently unsafe activity safer by regulation.”

Those who disagree suggest the city should formally recognise its sex trade by legalising brothels.

For them, the legalisation of brothels would allow increased support for women involved in the sex trade.

Included in this group are some sex workers – one told the Daily Record that criminalisation would not work, saying: “It will be much more dangerous for girls and their clients. It makes everyone much more vulnerable to attack or robbery.”

Proponents of this argument believe that the saunas take prostitution off the streets and therefore remove some of the danger from the sex trade.

The reality is that with women trafficked far from home, to be sold for as little as £80, this is far from a safe industry – legal or illegal.

For many, the legality of these acts are impossible to justify.

For Rhoda Grant, a fierce campaigner on women’s issues, it is simple: “No human being should be reduced down to a commodity, to be bought and sold.”

A quick internet search for Edinburgh saunas reveals that the commodification of women is exactly what the Scottish sex trade promotes.

Online reviews rate prostitutes as if they were any other product. One review of an Edinburgh-based sauna reads: “Any one else wasted money on this moody romanian? Pisspoor attitude, limited english, zero skill base… Ok looking, good figure, but avoid…”

If Grant’s proposal is accepted it could go some way to fighting such damaging attitudes towards women.

A report cited in Grant’s proposal – Challenging Men’s Demand for Prostitution in Scotland – found that of 110 men who had paid for sex, ’32 per cent stated that rape happens because men get sexually carried away.’

In the same survey, 12 per cent said that the rape of a prostitute or call girl was ‘not possible’.

To add to this, Grant justifies her proposal with a broad range of evidence.

To those who argue that sex work is a matter of choice for women, she cites evidence that ’75 per cent of sex workers in the UK became involved as children.’

Therefore, participants are more often than not, unwilling.

Most importantly for her campaign, the proposal claims that those who visit prostitutes believe that legal and financial penalties could deter their behaviour.

Though the proposal is persuasive, Edinburgh Council – which gets more than £11,000 in yearly licensing fees from sauna owners – has a vested interest in these businesses.

In Glasgow – a city once billed as having the most sex workers outside of London – the local council supports Grant’s campaign.

Again, however, sex workers themselves have become vocal opponents of the bill.

Laura Lee, an escort from Glasgow, suggests that criminalising the purchase of sex will push prostitutes into more secluded areas – away from the help of police.

She also believes that in the current system those who pay for sex are able to report incidences of abuse within the sex industry, whereas after criminalisation they would be unable to.

It remains to be seen if the proposal will make it through the Scottish Parliament in 2013.

If you would like to have your say, download the Criminalisation of the Purchase of Sex (Scotland) Bill here.

Public consultation on Rhoda Grant’s bill ends on 14 December.

  1. sue tapply says:

    And according to BBC News Scotland today a single strategy on prostitution has been drawn up for dealing with the sex trade ahead of the merger of Scotland’s eight forces in April.
    It includes minimising harm, disrupting organised crime and reducing demand.
    Much of the debate around the sex trade has contrasted Edinburgh saunas – believed to be tolerated as part of a “pragmatic” approach by authorities – with an approach in Glasgow which is closer to zero tolerance.
    “We will aim to disrupt and dismantle organised crime groups engaged in sexual exploitation, identify offenders and bring them to justice, while supporting work to reduce demand through enforcement, education and prevention.”
    http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-20559838

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *