subscribe: Posts | Comments

The Leveson Inquiry: we were there

1 comment

How women’s groups forced themselves on the Leveson agenda and to what effect.

Guest post by Heather Harvey, research and development manager with Eaves.

Many of you will be aware that End Violence Against Women, Equality Now,  Object jointly with Turn your back on p3 and Eaves gave evidence to the Leveson Inquiry in January 2012.

And equally, you probably know we recently released our own media monitoring report, “Just the Women”, the title for which was taken from the words of Peter Rippon explaining that they dropped the Savile Newsnight programme as the evidence they had was from “just the women”.

We thought we’d share with you some of this experience.

Lord Justice Leveson was appointed to head the inquiry ‘into the culture, practices and ethics of the press’ by PM David Cameron with broad terms of reference and was to take evidence from January 2012 onwards.

In about November last year, we women’s groups were meeting on quite a different issue. While chatting, we raised the idea of maybe sending something in to Leveson about the representation of women in the media.

After all, from the UN CEDAW convention to “Page 3 girls” and the use of headlines like “Midnight Orgy in the Park” to describe gang rape of 12 year old girls or “Lolitas”, women have been raising concern about the media sexism for many years – indeed that’s what WVoN is all about.

So we sent in submissions.

And we were both surprised and terrified to be formally invited to give evidence in January.

Our presentations attracted some media attention and this tweet from journalist Deborah Orr: ‘It’s cheering, in a limited way, just to hear critiques of the press’s portrayal of women without them [women] being sighed or sneered at.’

For us, this tweet sums up exactly why we wanted to give evidence.

When women speak out on issues of public policy, and particularly issues about women or violence against women and girls, they are attacked online and in print – not just with dismissive carping but with misogynistic, gendered, sexualised attacks.

While all of our organisations believe in the freedom of the press and the public interest exemption, we feel there is a serious “democratic deficit” where women are concerned.

We are silenced, humiliated and rendered invisible – unless we are “pretty” and preferably naked when we are used as objects for decoration or entertainment.

The way in which violence against women is reported, usually as trivial or titillating, and often demonstrating perpetrator empathy and victim blaming, and through constant reinforcement of myths and stereotypes, can directly impact on access to justice.

This is clearly acknowledged at official level with Alison Saunders, head of the Crown Prosecution Service in London, highlighting in this an article earlier this year saying that jurors have preconceptions about rape and victims often fear to report for fear of these preconceptions.

In an attempt to keep women on the agenda once Leveson reported back, we undertook a two-week media monitoring project and produced a short report of our own on 25 November.

“Just the Women” covered all the above issues, and we have been pleased with the media coverage it has attracted to date.

But more importantly, we were pleased to see that Leveson’s report acknowledged our concerns and provided useful material to support some of our recommendations on p664.

Bold mine.

‘The evidence as a whole suggested that there is force in the trenchant views expressed… that the Page 3 tabloid press often failed to show consistent respect for the dignity and equality of women generally, and that there was a tendency to sexualise and demean women…

‘…The impact of discriminatory or prejudicial representations of women in the Page 3 tabloids is difficult to judge.

‘There is credible evidence that it has a broader impact on the perception and role of women in society, and the sexualisation of society generally’.

‘What is clearly required is that any such regulator has the power to take complaints from representative women’s groups.

‘Consideration should also be given to Code amendments which, while protecting freedom of speech and the freedom of the press, would equip that body with the power to intervene in cases of allegedly discriminatory reporting and in so doing reflect the spirit of equalities legislation’.

With reports that editors are close to an agreement as to how they intend to respond to Leveson, we await with interest to see whether they too are prepared to acknowledge and act against media sexism.

In the meantime, we urge you all to support our campaign against media sexism – and you can start by uploading your own examples at everyday media sexism.

 

Author Heather Harvey is research and development manager with Eaves, a London-based registered charity providing support and associated services for women who have experienced violence to enable them to recover and regain independence.

Eaves aims to give women their lives back; to make them independent, and give them the skills they need to take their rightful places back in society, contribute to the economy and the communities around them, and live happy, fulfilled lives.

Eaves also carries out extensive research which provides crucial evidence of the nature and scale of violence against women.

  1. vicki wharton says:

    Freedom of the press shouldn’t be the freedom to incite violence against a group of people by partial reporting around issues of rape etc. This is sexist propoganda designed to present a skewed picture of women and promote male supremacy via subliminal messaging in the press in much the same way the press promote hatred of immigrants, disabled people, young people, old people and virtually anyone that isn’t white and male.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *