subscribe: Posts | Comments

Backward, primitive and sexist attitudes

1 comment

Actually Mum “held the fort” while Daddy was away – and she probably “holds the fort” all the time.

Guest post by Heather Harvey, research and development manager with Eaves.

At Eaves we do a weekly newsletter about violence against women around the world.

I  can reliably find the most detailed and violent stories at a couple of media outlets to which, in many other ways, I might feel personally hostile.

In one such media outline I recently noticed a story, for once, not about violence against women, with the headline:“Little boy who held the fort while Daddy went to war: the diary of how Kieran, 6, held his family together until that special homecoming.”

I am not usually very drawn to armed forces stories, but I wanted to read this one because I couldn’t imagine what a 6 year-old child – or specifically in this case, boy –  had done to merit this headline.

I thought maybe he’d deterred an intruder or called the hospital when someone fell sick or sold all his toys to raise money for the family.

Maybe he’d cooked dinner, put the rubbish out, mopped up, done the washing, looked after his siblings and his grandmother, remembered everyone’s birthdays.

I wouldn’t expect any 6 year-old child to do that, no reason why they should, but I assumed it was something of that order given this headline.

But funnily enough, as we might expect, of course he didn’t do any of that.

She did.

You know, the wife/mother person.

It is clear from her really quite poignant diary what a struggle it has been, particularly to keep cheerful and get through all the significant dates of the year and not let her own sadness and frustrations impact on her son and daughter.

There is a daughter too in the story, though you wouldn’t immediately know that.

Apparently, on the phone to his Dad the little boy said something like, “I’m looking after the family” – as they do of course.

No doubt Daddy said something like, “now you’re the man of the house and you need to look after the girls, your mum and your sister”.

It’s a very common, if in my mind irritating and sexist, turn of phrase in such a scenario and it has its role in motivating kids, or in this case the boy, to get through a difficult time.

If that is all it is then I can let it pass – but when the Mail seeks to literally enforce it, I get annoyed.

It is clearly too agonisingly painful to the Mail to give any credit to a woman – even the Daily Mail ideal, white, middle-class, stay-at-home, army wife Mum, doing exactly what the Mail requires of women – but still the credit has to go to something male, even if he’s only 6!

It’s a reminder that for those women and girls who still foolishly strive to jump through the ever more hurdles that society sets for us, we will never succeed – we are women we will always fall short in their eyes – let’s just stop trying and start fighting on our own terms.

In some parts of the world, if the male “head of the family” figure dies then either the woman is inherited by a brother of her husband or the “head of the family” role and the power and decision making is passed to the nearest surviving male family member – even if that is the woman’s own 6 year old son.

The Mail would condemn such cultures as backward, primitive, sexist and barbaric.

The Mail might like to look in a mirror.

 

Author Heather Harvey is research and development manager with Eaves, a London-based registered charity providing support and associated services for women who have experienced violence to enable them to recover and regain independence.

Eaves aims to give women their lives back; to make them independent, and give them the skills they need to take their rightful places back in society, contribute to the economy and the communities around them, and live happy, fulfilled lives.

Eaves also carries out extensive research which provides crucial evidence of the nature and scale of violence against women.

  1. Very good point: a series that I really like – The Walking Dead – is portraying exactly this scenario – the young lad is pUt into this role and expected to ‘protect’ the women. Very frustrating in an otherwise excellent series – not least because it is so easily addressed by recognising that women have agency. We can but hope that things will change.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *