subscribe: Posts | Comments

Sex for the disabled: a charitable service?

1 comment

disability_zps015847ebIs access to sexual services part of holistic care and denying this violating the Human Rights Act?

When former Madam Becky Adams announced she would be opening the UK’s first brothel reserved for disabled clients, it caused quite the media stir.

Cue tittering tabloid articles and online jokers asking whether disabled clients would be “using a different entrance”.

But when it emerged that a care home in Sussex was being investigated for facilitating sex workers to visit their disabled residents, tittering turned to outrage as the public demanded to know whether taxpayers’ money was being spent on prostitution.

Many people have come out in defence of Becky Adams and the Sussex care home, insisting that access to sexual services is part of holistic care and to deny this would be a violation of the Human Rights Act.

One strong defender was David Ainsworth, of flagship charity publication Third Sector, who argued sexual services could and should be viewed as just another charitable service for disabled people.

He said that: “If that’s what disabled people need, then the [charity] sector should help meet that need, with the same tact, dignity and support offered in other areas, ensuring that those who are disadvantaged do not suffer more than they need to for the sake of saving other peoples’ blushes.”

Does Ainsworth really imagine that the difficult questions thrown open by this story are simply a case of “other people’s blushes”?

Nothing more than Victorian prudery to be cast aside along with full length bathing suits and the covering of table legs?

His blog makes a plea for disabled people’s human rights and their “ancient and primeval need” to have sex.

Yet the human rights of the sex workers in question, a group who have routinely had their rights ignored, go unmentioned.

Feminists have for a long time debated whether or not sex work can in theory be a free, empowered choice for the sex worker.

But one thing most feminists agree on is that in reality too many sex workers face exploitation, abuse and an emphatic lack of choice.

Never in his article does Ainsworth enquire after the treatment or working rights of the sex workers being hired.

He uses the phrase “people in a pretty desperate situation”.

But who is in the more desperate situation, the disabled person desperate for sex or the sex worker desperate to make a living?

It’s a difficult one.

The trouble with defining sex as a human ‘need’ is it tends to involves two people, so immediately you’re confronted with another, often opposing set of needs.

Women and men have different reasons for entering sex work, but one recurring motivation has always been financial desperation and a lack of employment options.

And now, as living costs rise, benefits and wages plummet and suitable jobs become increasingly scarce, more people than ever find themselves in this situation.

Of course we must recognise that when seeking a sexual partner, disabled people find themselves up against social and physical barriers that abled bodied people would struggle to comprehend.

And the force of body fascism which dictates who is sexy and who is allowed to have sex saves particular contempt for the physically disabled.

But by ordering in sex workers to service mostly male clients are we really flinging back the cloak of shame and secrecy which covers our social attitudes to sex and disability?

Let’s be honest, we’ve hardly rattled the status quo off its perch.

Writing for Disability Now, researcher Kirsty Liddiard gives a far more nuanced response to the issue of sex workers in care homes.

She writes: ‘As a disabled woman who has researched heterosexual disabled men’s experiences with female sex workers, I feel that sex work should be a legitimate form of sexual access, but crucially, not the only form of sexual access for disabled people.

‘But this doesn’t mean I don’t have reservations; particularly around the ways in which paying for sex is often clumsily positioned as the answer to a much bigger social and cultural issue for disabled people.

‘Patriarchy…and capitalism…work together to ensure that commercial sex work markets will always cater more to men than women, disabled or otherwise.’

Even supporters of Becky Adams and the Sussex care home find the obvious gender divide in the use of sex workers a difficult one to square.

Sarah Ismail wrote in the Independent: ‘As a disabled woman and a feminist – although I don’t think I’d use it myself – I hope Adams’ planned centre will be open to disabled women as well as men.’

Despite Ismail’s hope that these services will be open to women as well as men, she’s quick to state she wouldn’t use them.

And it’s clear that Becky Adam’s brothel will cater mostly to a male clientele.

This gender divide suggests the ‘need’ for sex is more complex than just the universal biological need for food or shelter.

It suggests sexuality is something far more complex, shaped by socialisation and structures of power.

And are we to believe buying sex is a disabled person’s only route to expressing their sexuality?

I’d guess that most disabled people, like other people, would rather their desires for sex, intimacy and love weren’t reduced to a “primeval need”, to be met via an economic transaction, portioned out by local care providers alongside your new wheelchair and weekly prescription of painkillers.

Because whatever you think about sex work, buying sex in an economic exchange and entering into a mutual sexual relationship is not the same thing.

The disabled men interviewed by Kirsty Liddiard were certainly mindful of the difference; ‘For most of them, paying for sex could be sexy, fun and exhilarating, but was also a source of great sadness which highlighted their social and sexual isolation and affirmed their feelings of undesirability.’

The debate about care homes facilitating sex workers is one we should be having, but we shouldn’t stop there.

We should be asking how taboos and stigma around sex and disability can be challenged and disabled people can be enabled to explore their sexualities in fulfilling ways.

Because how many people, disabled or otherwise, really want their experience of sex and intimacy to be reduced to a ‘biological need’ like eating or going to the toilet?

  1. Very good Heather. A sex worker is not a commodity to be provided, like a new hearing aid. FFS.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *