subscribe: Posts | Comments

Sterilisation hell for Indian women

0 comments

Over 100 Indian women were left to recover in a field after sterilisation surgery.

The treatment of over 100 women at a sterilisation camp in the district of Malda, West Bengal, has caused an outcry from human rights and health activist groups.

The women had gone to Manikchak hospital for ligation surgery, but were left in unsanitary conditions in a field to recover, many unconscious and in pain, when the hospital was ‘unable to provide sufficient aftercare’.

Most of the women who came to the camp were reportedly from poor minority communities, and they had to endure hours of indignity and suffering.

It’s an appalling story in which women were treated little better than cattle, and the details are wretched.

Although the number of doctors involved in the sterilisation drive is disputed, apparently just two performed over 100 sterilisation procedures when guidelines state that a maximum of twenty five such procedures should be carried out per day.

The two doctors operated from 10am until half past seven in the evening, and neither of them were specialist gynaecologists.

Over 100 women were permitted to undergo the surgery when the hospital itself has only seventy beds, thirty-five of which are designated for male patients.

Hospital helpers carried the women, many unconscious and in pain, into an adjacent field and left them there without medical supervision or after care.

Some were sent home on crude rickshaws when there is supposed to be a mandatory safe observation period of at least three hours.

Local health officials have acknowledged that the treatment of the women was unacceptable, and have promised an inquiry.

Keya Dutta, a local district health campaigner, said, ‘Patients expect minimum medical care from their doctors. But in this case that aspect is completely ignored.

They [the women who underwent the programme] were treated in an inhumane manner [like animals] without [anyone] paying any attention towards their pain.’

The narrative of how these women were treated is horrific but there is another serious issue attached to this story and it runs far deeper and says much about how Indian women are viewed and treated as citizens, particularly those from poor backgrounds.

It concerns the sterilisation process itself.

While it is a far easier and less risky procedure for a man to undergo sterilisation, it is still predominantly women who have the surgery.

Depressingly predictable maybe, but the reasons for doing so in the first place are somewhat sinister.

The population in India is somewhere in excess of one billion.  In 1976, the Indian Government launched a programme of initiative for sterilisation, whereby couples were offered benefits such as loans, cars or land.

As a result, thousands of people opted to undergo the procedure, but with the majority of couples, it was the woman who had the surgery.

There have also been reports from health rights campaigners that women are being coerced into sterilisation to meet population reduction targets, and that health workers are placed under extreme duress to meet these targets.

According to Human Rights Watch, as well as coercive female sterilisation practices, women are also not given consistent and comprehensive information on the risks involved or the alternative contraception choices available to them.

In a report last year, Human Rights Watch said ‘In much of the country, authorities aggressively pursue targets, especially for female sterilization, by threatening health workers with salary cuts or dismissals.

‘As a result, some health workers pressure women to undergo sterilization without providing sufficient information, either about possible complications, its irreversibility, or safer sex practices after the procedure.’

While the Indian government has now adopted a ‘target free’ approach and has stopped setting centralised sterilisation targets, the reality is that individual states and districts continue to do so, often aggressively.

The report went on to say, ‘India’s family planning program focuses predominantly on women, with little interaction and engagement with men.

‘At the same time, it is men who often decide when to have sex and how many children to produce.

‘For India to be successful in its renewed efforts at family planning, it should engage effectively with men too.’

None of this is good news for India, particularly in light of the recent publication of the ‘World Report 2013’, also by Human Rights Watch.

The report notes a serious decline in human rights protections with respect to, in particular, violence against women, with increased reports of sexual assaults and rape.

More evidence, if any were needed, that women in India have a pitifully long way to go before they achieve anything like gender equality.

As long as the Indian government continues to fail in protecting and promoting the human rights of their women, the media will continue to aim its hard glare their way.

Tragic, isn’t it, that it could be  media attention, rather than a genuine concern for the welfare of millions of women in India, that instigates change.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *