subscribe: Posts | Comments

New York, pay equity and you

0 comments

statue_of_liberty_800croppedNine out of 10 New Yorkers want the gender pay gap eradicated in 2013 and their governor is keen to oblige.

New York’s governor Andrew Cuomo has renewed his commitment to women voters, and ending the gender discrimination they face, by announcing his plan to progress a 10 -point Women’s Equality Act.

The Act, of which equal pay is a key component, has received widespread support from over 280 groups, including reproductive rights organisation Planned Parenthood and working family advocacy group A Better Balance.

The proposed legislation is also proving popular with the electorate.

A recent poll found that nearly 9 out of 10 New Yorkers want to see equal pay for women become a reality in 2013.

All this is unsurprising when you consider that the most recent data from the Bureau of Labor Statistics shows that a full-time salaried woman earns on average only 82 per cent of the amount earned by a man in a comparable position.

Research from the Center for American Progress Action Fund found that the accumulation of those lost earnings reaches, on average, 434,000 dollars over the course of a woman’s career, and rises to a staggering 713,000 dollars for women who have achieved college degrees.

‘Women in all occupations suffer from the career wage gap, but women with the most education lose the most in earnings’ the report says, and continues; ‘the larger a woman’s earning potential, the more she may lose in terms of real dollars over a lifetime of work.’

It is not, however, just the highest earners who benefit from pay equity.

As Dina Bakst, co-founder and co-president of A Better Balance, rightly points out: “More than ever, New York families are relying on the salaries of working mothers to make ends meet.

“Combating workplace discrimination – including pay equity – is imperative for women, families and overall economic growth.”

Women are more likely to live in poverty and less likely to make savings towards their retirement and, as the Fawcett Society has revealed, women in the UK face similarly deep-rooted economic inequalities.

A first glance at the 2012 figures issued by the Office for National Statistics (ONS) may give grounds for optimism, showing that the gender pay gap in the UK has fallen under 10 per cent for the first time since the Equal Pay Act became law in the 1970s.

However, upon further scrutiny, this statistic seems to be little more than a misleading sound bite to reassure us that the battle for pay equity is moving in the right direction.

Little more than propaganda, giving the government reason to deny there is a need for public policy which addresses the issue that, even after 40 years, women are still not getting equal pay for equal work.

Based on data from the Annual Survey of Hours and Earnings (ASHE), the gender pay gap is calculated as ‘the difference between men’s and women’s median hourly pay excluding overtime for full-time employees.’

Note ‘overtime’ and ‘full-time’.

That a disproportionate number of women occupy part-time positions means that they are not even represented by this figure.

The burden of caring for their family often forces women into part-time employment.

And not only are rates of pay for part-time work often lower than those for full-time hours, but career progression and access to training are limited.

Already undervalued – and underpaid = by working part-time, this economic inequality is compounded by society’s devaluation of those industries dominated by women.

You need only compare the rates of pay between those in Early Years education and those in skilled trades.

Therefore, if we afford those women working part-time the representation they deserve in assessing the gender pay gap, then the headline grabbing, single-figure percentage more than doubles to a median gender pay gap of 19.7 per cent.

In real terms, for every 1 pound a man in the UK earns, a woman earns just 83.5 pence; or, as WVoN reported earlier from November 7 until the end of 2012, women in the UK were effectively working for free.

This figure, however, is still not an accurate reflection of the problem.

A study commissioned by the Equality and Human Rights Commission found that weekly overtime payments were three times higher for men than for women.

So while the ONS claims that their measures are not sophisticated enough to take account of overtime as a representation of the different working patterns of men and women, by excluding overtime from the calculation entirely, how can we scrutinise how much money is actually received by men and women to determine whether women really are getting equal pay for equal work?

The answer is, quite simply, we can’t.

What we can do, however, is view statistics relating to the gender pay gap in the UK with caution.

The government’s commitment to reducing inequality in the workplace is, arguably, best exemplified by its objection to EU quotas for women on boards, as well as its decision to abandon compulsory gender pay audits.

And this is why we absolutely must support groups – like the Fawcett Society – which lobby the UK government to get it to show the same commitment to pay equity as Andrew Cuomo has shown in New York.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *