Savita Halappanavar inquest verdict out
A tragic state, with an ‘unclear legal situation’ and ‘lapses in the standards of care’.
The jury in the inquest into the death of Savita Halappanavar, who died in University Hospital Galway in Ireland on 28 October 2012 four days after suffering a miscarriage, has given a verdict of ‘medical misadventure’.
The legal definition of medical misadventure indicates personal injury resulting from medical error or medical mishap, or an unintended outcome of an intended action.
The inquest heard the cause of her death was septic shock, E coli and a miscarriage.
Media from around the world has been gathering in Galway as people struggled to understand how the 31 year-old dentist, an otherwise healthy, pregnant young woman, could be admitted to hospital with little prospect of her child’s survival, and yet be refused a termination.
And Ms Halappanavar’s death, a week after her admission to the University Hospital in Galway, has once again focused international attention on the Republic of Ireland’s abortion laws.
Irish law prevents an abortion unless there is a risk to the life, as distinct from the health, of the mother.
This has been the case since a Supreme Court ruling in 1992, known as the X case: abortion has been constitutionally available in the Republic where a woman’s life, as distinct from her health, is at risk from the continued pregnancy.
Dr Peter Boylan, the former master of the National Maternity Hospital in Dublin, told the inquest that Ms Halappanavar would probably still be alive today if she had had a termination in the first three days of her stay in the hospital, but that under Irish law an abortion would have been illegal because there was “not a real and substantial risk to her life at that stage”.
And by the time her life was at risk, it was too late to save her with a termination.
A report by the Health Service Executive has concluded, according to the Irish Times, that there was “an overemphasis by hospital staff on the welfare of Ms Halappanavar’s unviable foetus and an underemphasis on her deteriorating health.”
The chief operating officer at the Galway Roscommon Hospital Group, Tony Canavan, acknowledged there were lapses in the standards of care provided to Ms Halappanavar.
The inquest heard of communication failures between medical and nursing staff; evidence was also given of blood test results not being followed up and of pulse rates not taken.
Canavan said that all of the nine recommendations made by the coroner Dr Ciaran MacLoughlin and endorsed by the inquest jury would be taken on board.
Ireland’s current Fine Gael-Labour coalition government has promised a new law on abortion in the country, and to provide greater guidance for doctors by the summer.
The problem is that what constitutes a “life-threatening” condition in various medical situations, including failing pregnancies, and how much time exists for medical professionals to intervene, is very often not clear-cut.
Until now, the Irish government has apparently given no guidance to hospitals as to how to proceed in such cases and doctors are fearful of prosecution.
Marianne Mollman of Amnesty International wrote of her own investigation of this problem: ‘In 2010 I saw that the European Court on Human Rights berated the Irish government for not regulating access to life-saving abortion clearly, creating insecurity for medical providers and patients alike.
‘In 2011 the United Nations Human Rights Council issued various recommendations to the same effect…My research taught me that many medical providers in Ireland want clarity on when they can intervene and when they cannot.’
Ireland’s coalition government is expected to publish within the next fortnight the general principles that it hopes will become law by July.
Any legislation is expected to be very restrictive by international standards.
Victims of rape, sexual abuse and incest will almost certainly not be entitled to a termination unless their life is at risk.
Opponents have also expressed unease about the proposal to legislate for ‘the credible threat of suicide’ as grounds for termination of a pregnancy.
These could mean Irish women will be unable to make personal health decisions. The consequences of such an approach, as has been illustrated here, are grave.
And according to a World Health Organization report, about 47,000 women die each year around the world from unsafe abortions. This accounts for about 13 per cent of all maternal deaths.
Gerard O’Donnell, solicitor for Ms Halappanavar’s widower Praveen Halappanavar, said the evidence demonstrated a serious and shocking mismanagement of the case at Galway University Hospital and that Ms Halappanavar was denied her constitutional right to life and was the victim of a significant breach of human rights.
Minister for Health James Reilly said that “as the verdict had just been issued…to garner the lessons to be learned from it, it would not be appropriate…to take questions on it right now.”
The Galway coroner’s inquest is the first of a series of probes into this case and findings will be announced in the coming weeks and months.
















Medical misadventure my arse! Discriminating against a women’s right to life by favouring the rights of a dead or dying foetus is a self fulfilling prophecy. By waiting until there is a risk to life by which time it is too late to intervene without killing the mother is effectively murdering her by default. Killing someone by wilfully choosing not to act in their interests is treated as murder in many countries – the fact that the Irish Government think such an attitude is acceptable towards half its population of tax payers shows how badly most male run governments serve their female citizens.