Remarks on the rape porn ban questions
What about healthy human relationships and women’s rights?
Guest post by Heather Harvey of EAVES
Pornography is meant to be material that is sexually stimulating. I think it’s very simple and clear to say that simulated or real rape should not be promoted as “sexually stimulating” – that is like incitement to rape and certainly is a legitimisation, normalisation and glamorisation of it. Given that children are learning about sex from pornography and that women are already blamed for their own rape – do we really want to promote rape in this way?
What about freedom of expression?
Frankly I’m tired of this and the very idea is being devalued as it is used as a last refuge of scoundrels.. The libertarian response repeatedly fails because it does not account for pre-existing inequality, imbalance of power and discrimination in society. Consequently it just replicates and reinforces inequality and discrimination. Freedom of expression is not purely about men’s “right” or rather desire to perpetually view women as objects and in situations of violence, humiliation and degradation.
But what about the difference between fantasy and reality?
Well firstly it’s not equally applied. Men may be allowed to distinguish between fantasy and reality but women are not – not where sex is concerned. That is why we have myths like “a woman says no but means yes”, or a woman says yes but then “cries rape” despite CPS research to show how rare is a false allegation, (Levitt Q.C. March 2013).
A young woman on her facebook mentioned the fact that she had entertained the idea of group sex (note that is group sex not gang rape). She then arranged to meet a man with whom she says she was prepared to have sex but arriving found a group of men and claimed she suffered multiple rape from them. Judge Robert Brown ordered the jury to return a not guilty verdict as her “credibility was shot to pieces”. Similarly, the Prosecutor, having read the facebook fantasy she had mentioned, dropped the case as this “put the whole incident in a different light” and they could not entertain the idea of obtaining a prosecution.
Women have been taught that showing an interest or pleasure in sex will be seen as something to condemn in them – they will be viewed as sluts, easy, etc. Women are expected to “not like it or need it” as supposedly men do and certainly not to openly show pleasure in it. The exception to this is when they are in the act with their partner– then they are supposed to be screaming and writhing in delight to reassure him (usually) that he’s the best thing since sliced bread.
Consequently, women have a great deal of guilt and conflicting emotions about sex – a fantasy that can remove your sense of responsibility for sex is a useful way of navigating this discriminatory cultural legacy about women and sexuality. They are often therefore not being “turned on” by the rape but by the possibility to envisage having and enjoying sex without feeling guilty or responsible about it.
On the other hand men are being turned on by the rape – and frankly that scares, enrages and horrifies me. Not from a moralising point of view you understand but from the point of view of healthy human relationships and women’s rights.
What I don’t pretend to know, however, is enough about internet technology to be able to say if this is a workable proposal or not. I am not commenting on practicalities and logistics but I am supportive of the principle – I don’t want men and boys, or women for that matter, thinking it’s ok and normal to be turned on by watching a woman being raped.
















I think this blog itself it’s pretty sexist. And I am female.
You say that the idea of men being aroused by rape horrifies you.
It is, in fact possible for men to distinguish between fantasy and reality. What an ignorant thing to suggest.
Men and women are both capable of being responsible for themselves.
Why on Earth is it acceptable for a woman to enjoy a fantasy rape roleplay, but be detestable if a man entertains the fantasy?
Let’s remember, the key word is fantasy. The important word is consent. If a female consents, she is not being raped.
Why can’t a woman have rape fantasies because she likes the idea of objectification? She likes the submission?
Do you have any idea how many men are prepared to indulge in such taboo fantasies because their partner has expressed an interest to try it?
And among the people I associate with, woman enjoying sex are celebrated. It’s often very important to my male friends that they are satisfying their partners, and can suffer some insecurity issues panicking over whether they are sexually pleasing their wife/girlfriend or not.
Ridiculous blog. And patronising.
You are the one who is ridiculous. Rape porn is not between two loving, consenting partners, it’s quite usually between a number of men, camera men, producers and directors. Usually the only woman on set will be the ‘sex performer’.
Men consume it on their own and internalise its message.
Have you seem rape porn? The woman is often screaming, crying, begging, it is not about a female fantasy of submission and danger it’s about the male fantasy of power and domination. I bet you wouldn’t be able to stomach it.
I doubt many couples watch rape porn together, and I fully agree with the author, the thought if men being aroused by rape depresses and upsets me. It is not a double standard for the reasons I’ve posted above.
Porn is rarely between two loving partners in ANY genre, but you’re not bringing that up, are you?
The ‘rape’ porn that is a filmed roleplay between two consenting partners often involves men who fantasise about it as well as the women involved.
Obviously, any pornography of the non consenting variety shouldn’t be circulated.
Do you have any idea how many women DO entertain fantasies of the ‘force’ variety?
Most men are not stupid. Most can distinguish between what is acceptable and what is not. They know what it means to have sex with someone who does not consent, even if they DO commit the act of rape (which of course is disgusting), they know the difference.
It’s like saying Grand Theft Auto is responsible for teen murderers. Which is fallacious logic.
Post hoc ergo propter hoc.
Most youths know that violence is wrong and know the consequences if they commit it. They may ACT it out via simulation, where it is not real. Most of these people wouldn’t even think about committing violence in real life.
Has it ever occurred to you that some women LIKE to cry and beg?
You are also getting your terminology very wrong.
Most of these men are not getting aroused by rape. They are aroused by rape roleplay. And yes, it IS different.
For many men, the concept of actually raping a woman is horrifying.
One involves consent, the other does not.
Does the thought of women being aroused by rape depress and upset you too?
When a woman has a rape fantasy she is not fantasizing about committing a crime. When a man fantasizes about rape he is fantasizing about committing a violent horrific crime. There is no comparison.
Hmm I do understand some of your points, but it is perfectly possible for a woman to have rape fantasies and be aroused by the thought of being taken totally against their will, forced into it, even hurt, and actually get off on this. I speak from experience. Would I want it to happen for real? Of course not. He might have AIDS. Or smelly breath.
these are consensual adults you are talking about here.
you clearly have never heard of safe sane and consensual or risk aware consensual kink, or personal responsibility in consensual kink.
there is such a thing as consensual none consensual…thats why safe words exist.
i’m female. i find consensual rape play arousing..i find consensual screaming, crying, begging arousing…it is something that i do in my adult sex life with my partner quite often there is a fetish called damsel in distress which is quite common. being restrained, being gagged, being helpless, these are all by my choice and my decision as a fully grown consensual adult. there is a woman acting out on screen what i do in private, something that gives me an outlet of not having to be in control with somebody that i trust to only do what i want them to do or what i feel comfortable with and what makes me satisfied. giving somebody that control and authority is a very intense powerful thing and requires so much trust and vulnerability being so exposed like that, not many people would feel capable of giving over so much of themselves or be in a position like that, the adrenaline and security combined all in one. i doubt many couples do watch rape porn together…but it might be more couples and women than you think. for womens fantasies and expression to be oppressed and suppressed in this day and age and to have people go back to the dark ages and to try to make them feel ashamed of their own right to having sexual preferences is just appalling and an outrage i thought judgmentalism was a thing of the past. i am a masochist i enjoy consensual impact play, people striking me with implements and instruments…i ask people i trust to hit me with things now to the common or ignorant person that might just sound crazy, but to me its a release of physical and emotional tension, its an outlet, its a relief, the adrenaline and endorphin rush can be compared in a sense to those that achieve a similar experience through exercise or other forms of stimulation and i know a lot of people feel the same way of masochism but there are so many prudes and fascists that are now pidgeonholing and classing quite a lot of consensual kinky adults in with the murderers and peadophiles which is completely ridiculous whatever happened to womens rights in being able to choose their level of sexual preference whether that be making love or extreme consensual kink? or god forbid both?