subscribe: Posts | Comments

Looking at how young people see forced marriage

0 comments

Eaves, asking young people about forced marriageSome of the research results were as you might expect, some were surprising.

EAVES has just released a new report which looks at young people’s views on forced marriage and its gendered differentials.

The research, which was partially funded by the UK’s Foreign and Commonwealth Office (FCO), involved interviews with 11 young people (male and female) and a survey with 101 respondents, and sought to look at young people’s views on forced marriage, on the government’s responses to it – notably criminalisation –  on their understanding of the gendered nature of the issue, and on what they see as the causes and motivations for the practice and what they would like to recommend as solutions.

Some of the findings were as you might expect:

There is a recognition that it is hard for boys to ask for help for this issue due to feeling embarrassed as a male to come forward as a victim and due to the fact that most services are targeted at women;

That some of the harm to women is more far-reaching than for men, including rape, abuse of sexual and reproductive rights, and a contraction or cessation of social, personal, professional and educational options;

That the mental health impacts for men and for women are probably equally as traumatising;

That the pressure brought to bear is mainly emotional;

That while the theoretical distinction of choice and consent between forced and arranged marriage is well known, the reality of it is very much harder to discern for young people, particularly where there is emotional pressure.

Some of the findings make sense but might be less obvious:

For example, 85 per cent of survey respondents either agreed or partially agreed that boys may find it hard to resist a forced marriage because they are expected to be enforcers for their siblings – this really highlights the role of young men both as perpetrators and as victims.

Parents’ strategies to persuade a male or female child differ and reflect gender stereotypes such as appealing to a man’s sense of adulthood, respect and power as a married man and as a standard setter for the family and highlighting that a young woman is being selfish and hurting her parents if she does not comply.

Males are more likely to go through with the marriage and still live their own chosen life on the side or to feel more confident about being able to get a divorce.

That there is a near unanimous support for the principle of criminalisation but a huge lack of confidence as to how helpful it will be in practice and a recognition that the issue is nuanced and needs suitably nuanced responses.

The culture of respect for one’s elders and the belief that those elders know what is right and do the best for you is powerful and makes it difficult for young people to challenge the practice.

Some results were more surprising:

Young women were much more likely to perceive their parent’s motives as benign, which could be an additional factor in their susceptibility to emotional pressure;

Young women showed extremely high empathy with male victims, in some cases considering it worse for men;

Young women had much higher tolerance or expectation that women will experience abuse and violence as “part of their lot”;

Males are much less likely to expect or want third party intervention seeing it as a family matter and seeing the responsibility being on the victim to resist the pressure;

Despite being able to see that the impacts for women are often more far-reaching, very few participants addressed the issue as a matter of gender discrimination and inequality.

To see the full report, click here.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *