Looking at Page Three and breast cancer
The Sun lent Tuesday’s Page Three to support breast cancer awareness charity CoppaFeel.
One of the most talked-about recent stories. A divisive decision. Here I recall some of the week’s best analysis.
One of the most fiercely critical responses this week came from Fay Schopen, writing for the Guardian, who described the campaign as “nothing but a self-interested and cynical ploy by the newspaper, a childish way of hitting back at the growing chorus of anti-Page 3 voices”.
As a survivor of cancer herself, she was unconvinced by the argument that it could help encourage more women, particularly young women, to check their breasts.
Conversely, someone who did think the campaign might have a positive impact in this way was Gaby Hinsliff, also writing for the Guardian.
She argued “there’s no ducking the fact that by asking millions of readers to check regularly for the warning signs of breast cancer, this campaign will probably save lives”.
However, she remained scathing about Page Three in general, calling it “dated, seedy, juvenile at best and demeaning at worst.”
Over at the Independent, Felicity Morse agreed that the campaign could encourage more women to check their breasts, but was dismayed by the cynicism shown by the Sun’s editors.
She wrote, “Taking people’s traumatic experiences of cancer and twisting them to foster support for a sexist, outdated institution is low, even by tabloid standards.”
She questioned the warped logic inherent in suggesting that those anti-Page Three were somehow pro-cancer, and the ‘making sexy’ of a disease so potentially devastating as cancer.
She ended with the moving refrain, “Don’t tell me to respect my body on Tuesday, when you disrespect it every other day of the week.”
Likewise, writing for the Huffington Post, Johanna Sartori was not convinced by the Sun’s apparent benevolence, and had been left pondering why the campaign left her so cold.
She concluded: “[the campaign was] sneaky and manipulative; it’s a way of getting page 3 onto the front cover by pretending to care about female health, but more than that, the linking of a life threatening disease with cheap titillation is horrible.”
Like Felicity Morse, she was clear in her argument that cancer is in no way a ‘sexy’ disease.
She reflected on the underlying message and motive behind the campaign: “What I understand from The Sun today is that women should check their breasts to keep them safe for exploitation; that actually breast cancer is worth fighting so that there are more breasts available to objectify. Once you understand that, the front page makes perfect sense.”
As with all the other commentators summarised above, Sarah Ditum, for the New Statesmen, was disgusted by the cynicism shown by the Sun, citing the growing support for the ‘No More Page Three’ campaign, who also released a statement on the matter, as something the newspaper must now be viewing as a real threat.
However, she added to the analysis a critique of what, in her view, amounts to “single-organ fetishism”.
Describing how “it can be extraordinarily traumatic to lose a breast when you live in a culture that thinks a woman only exists if she’s got the wherewithal to fill a bra”, she asked of the Sun’s editor, David Dinsmore, “Did he realise that the Sun’s breast fixation might be an insult to these survivors?”.
For the Telegraph, Women’s Editor, Emma Barnett agreed that the campaign patently did not genuinely have the best interests of women at heart: “Page 3 was designed by men for men… this campaign exists in a space dominated by women, but not for women.”











