subscribe: Posts | Comments

Examining the PIP breast implant affair

0 comments

HiP, MMU, Dr Melanie Latham, body imagesAn academic looks at what was a ‘scare’ in the UK, and a ‘scandale’ in France.

On March 16, 2010, officials from the French Health Security Agency (AFSSAPS) made a preannounced visit in Southern France to a manufacturer of silicone breast implants called PIP (‘Poly Implants Prothese’).

On returning secretly to the site the following day, they found evidence that the manufacture of the implants, and the materials used to fill them carried out by PIP, was shoddy, inadequate, and fraudulent.

Material used in the manufacturing process contained the chemicals Baysilone, Silopren and Rhodorsil used elsewhere as a fuel additive or in the manufacture of industrial rubber tubing.

The company was immediately shut down.

This visit set in motion a chain of events across the world that was seen as a ‘scare’ in the UK, but a ‘scandale’ in France.

Tens of thousands of women have been affected in France and the UK alone.

Dr Melanie Latham’s paper ‘If it ain’t broke, don’t fix it?’: Scares, Scandals and Cosmetic Surgery Regulation in France and the UK’ examines the PIP breast implant affair.

She will be presenting it as part of the first-ever ‘Humanities in Public’ programme, taking place at Manchester Metropolitan University and running until 2 June.

At the time France already had in place strict regulatory controls of the cosmetic surgery sector and reacted quickly and forcibly to protect patients affected.

By contrast this salutary tale highlighted shortcomings of regulation in the UK sufficiently enough to lead to renewed calls for its reassessment and tightening.

Women cosmetic surgery patients have been left in pain, in fear and out of pocket.

Has the law let them down once again?

For several years Dr Melanie Latham has been interested in how regulators can enhance rather than diminish the autonomy of their citizens through legislation.

She worked originally in Political Science, moved on to Law and Society, and published ‘Regulating Reproduction: a century of conflict in Britain and France’, which looked at the influence of feminist, medical and religious interest groups on the development of reproductive rights in twentieth century Britain and France.

Her research interests have become delineated by ideas around autonomy, rights and gender and are focussed currently upon the regulation of cosmetic surgery and patient autonomy.

She is presenting her paper on 17 March at 5.30pm in the Geoffrey Manton Lecture Theatre 4 – after tea and coffee in Geoffrey Manton atrium from 5.00pm.

Humanities in Public (HiP) is a busy and colourful festival of topical events and activities hosted by the Institute of Humanities and Social Science Research (IHSSR) at Manchester Metropolitan University (MMU).

To see the full programme click here.

These talks are completely free events and everyone is very welcome, but you need a ticket. For tickets for Dr Melanie Latham’s talk, click here.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *