subscribe: Posts | Comments

Thousands have multiple children in care

0 comments

Women need more support to break destructive cycles and get their children back

Destructive behaviour and children being taken into care a vicious cycle.

New data revealed by the BBC recently shows thousands of women in England have had more than one child taken into care.

The Nuffield Foundation-funded study, led by the University of Brunel and Manchester, examined English court records for the last seven years.

The results show that 7,143 mothers were involved in repeat care cases, losing custody of 22,790 children collectively.

Half the women involved in the cases were 24 years old or younger at the time of the first care application. The youngest mother was just 14.

Retired family court judge Nicholas Crichton was not surprised by the findings.

“The work of the family courts for years has been removing the second, the third, the fourth child from the same mother. Not infrequently the sixth, the seventh, the eighth,” he said.

“In one case I’ve removed the 14th and I know two judges that have removed the 15th child from the same mother.”

The research highlighted how destructive behaviour and children being taken into care can become a vicious cycle through the story of a young mother who had lost two children.

Sexually abused as a teenager, this young woman started taking heroin when she was 14 as a coping mechanism and found herself sofa surfing and living on the streets.

When she became pregnant at 16 her boyfriend left her, and she struggled to look after the baby alone – and turned again to heroin as a coping mechanism.

After having her first child taken into foster care she met another partner who supported her to try and give up heroin. But once she realised how unlikely it was she would get her child back, her drug use increased.

Following the birth of a second child, social services almost immediately issued care proceedings because of her history and continuing drug addiction, giving her little time to access rehabilitation and leaving her feeling suicidal.

Just 20 years old, the young woman told researchers she wanted help and a different life because she desperately wanted her children back.

Dr Karen Broadhurst of the University of Manchester, a lead author of the study, said that an important finding of the research was that infants are taken within a month of their birth in approximately 42 per cent of cases.

In 70 per cent of cases infants were subject to proceedings within the first year of life and there was an average gap of 17 months between the first time a mother appears in court with a child and the second time she appears with another child.

Broadhurst highlighted these figures to show how little time mothers have to focus on their own rehabilitation, turn their lives around or prove their capability.

She argues that the research shows the need for family courts to change their approach from purely focusing on the children’s welfare to also supporting women to change their behaviour, to access treatment or rehabilitation programmes and feasibly stand a chance of keeping their children.

Nicholas Crichton agreed that the new research underlines the need for the expansion of projects which help parents break the destructive cycle.

“The emotional cost to those families, and to their children, is immense but the financial cost to the taxpayer is immense as well and we really have to find a different way of dealing with these cases,” he said.

Two initiatives trying to encourage women to access support and rehabilitation services are the  Strengthening Families Project and the Family Drug and Alcohol Court.

The Strengthening Families Project, funded by Salford council and run by a specialist social worker and a community midwife, warns women of the risks of abusing drugs and alcohol – but it also provides positive support and advice.

The Family Drug and Alcohol Court has had encouraging results since its launch in 2008: it has helped 35 per cent of mothers reunite with their children, compared to a 19 per cent rate in ordinary family courts.

But these are isolated examples in a system which often has no adequate support systems for women who do want to fight to bring their children home.

Of course the welfare of children must always come first, but the welfare of children and the welfare of their mothers are far from mutually exclusive.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *