Liberty and soldiers’ human rights
Liberty believes that the rights of service men and women are just as deserving of protection as civilians.
‘Military Justice’ is civil rights group Liberty’s campaign to protect and uphold the human rights of those serving in the UK’s Armed Forces.
And Liberty is currently representing the families of Anne-Marie Ellement, Cheryl James, Sean Benton and James Collinson – soldiers let down by the current system.
One is Anne-Marie Ellement. She had always wanted to join the Army. She loved her job as a military policewoman and believed in justice.
In 2009 she reported that she had been raped by two colleagues, also RMP officers. Other military police officers investigated but no charges were brought, a decision which devastated her. She was not believed.
She began to be bullied by other soldiers. They called her ‘skank’, ‘slag’, ‘liar’, ‘the girl who cried rape’.
She was transferred to a new unit but the bullying continued. In October 2011 Anne-Marie took her own life.
A very brief inquest was held which did not examine any of these matters in depth.
Following a judicial review brought by Liberty acting for Anne-Marie’s sisters Sharon Hardy and Khristina Swain, a fresh inquest was held in February 2014.
Liberty also asked that the rape investigation be re-opened because the first investigation had been severely lacking.
Most fundamentally, it was not independent – the RMP investigated the RMP. You don’t need to be a lawyer to understand the dangers of such a lack of impartiality.
Liberty, using the Human Rights Act, demanded that a fresh investigation be conducted with service police from another branch of the military together with civilian police specialising in sex crime.
The RAF Police have now begun a fresh investigation, with the assistance and expertise of Bedfordshire Police.
Then there is Deepcut.
Between 1995 and 2001 four young British Army recruits were undergoing initial training at Deepcut, Surrey.
They all died there, of gunshot wounds.
Questions about their deaths remain unanswered.
Liberty is representing the families of Sean Benton, Cheryl James and James Collinson. We have serious concerns regarding the circumstances surrounding their deaths and how they were investigated. We are now calling for fresh inquests into the deaths of Sean, Cheryl and James.
And what has this got to do with human rights?
Chapter 303, Halsbury’s Laws of England says: It is one of the cardinal features of the law of England that a person does not, by enlisting in or entering the Armed Forces, thereby cease to be a citizen, so as to deprive him of his rights or to exempt him from his liabilities under the ordinary law of the land.
As a human being you have human rights and under British law those rights are protected by the Human Rights Act.
If you are the victim of a crime, you have the right to a proper investigation and for those responsible to be held to account. That’s how it works.
Being a soldier doesn’t make you less human.
Those laws and those rights still apply.
Article 2 of the Human Rights Act – the right to life – requires that the state not only refrain from taking life but also take steps to protect it. In the event of a death where the state may be involved, it also requires an independent, prompt and open investigation.
Article 3 relates to inhuman and degrading treatment. Cases of rape, for example, must be investigated and those responsible held to account.
You can help us, by emailing your MP.
You could say something like this:
‘We want all service men and women to feel confident that if they are a victim of a crime, this will be properly investigated and appropriately addressed – and that if they don’t feel this has happened, they have somewhere else to turn to.
Our recommendations, set out below, address the problems that we have encountered in our legal work and largely concern military life away from the battlefield.
While we welcome the inclusion of a Service Complaints Bill in the Queen’s Speech we are now urging the Government to go further and create an ombudsman with full investigative powers and for their recommendations to be binding.
This is about protecting members of our Armed Forces at home and on barracks abroad:
1. Service police forces and local police forces should collect and publish annually anonymised statistics on the number of allegations of sexual assault and rape made by or against a member of the armed forces.
2. Parliament should amend Schedule 2 of the Armed Forces Act so that sexual assault, exposure and voyeurism are not excluded from the Act’s mandatory referrals process.
3. The parties to Circular 028/2008 should amend the protocol by adding rape and sexual assault to the category of “Very Serious Crimes” which must always be investigated by local police forces rather than service police forces.
4. Arrangements for the investigation of serious crimes committed abroad should be revisited so as to reflect the principle that an independent police force rather than the service police force should investigate them.
5. The three service police forces should be brought within the civilian system of police oversight.
6. The service complaints ombudsman should be strengthened to give the ombudsman’s office powers to investigate the merits of a complaint as well as claims of maladministration. The office must also retain absolute discretion as to whether to investigate a complaint. The ombudsman’s recommendations must be final and binding, with sanctions for non-compliance.’
To find your MP, click here.
And Liberty is asking for anyone with information in connection with the death of Cheryl James to please contact them in strictest confidence.
Thanks.











