Exams: issues with womens’ texts
There is no excuse for texts by women to be under-represented in GCSEs.
Earlier this year, significant education reforms were announced, including changes to make English Literature GCSEs place greater importance on ‘English literary heritage’.
As exam boards revise their qualification specifications to incorporate these changes, For Books’ Sake analysed the 2015 draft specifications (to be examined in 2017) for five major exam boards in England and Wales, and compared them with materials from previous years.
In the year of #readwomen2014, when we live in the most culturally rich society ever known, armed with an incredibly cognizant Children’s Laureate who continues to tackle pervading social concerns during her term, we should be moving forward.
We are in the best position we have ever been to offer children and teenagers a broad and multi-vocal literature curriculum that properly reflects the world they live in.
But the statistics indicate that representation of women is getting worse.
This is a disturbing trend that cannot be allowed to continue.
A snapshot of the data shows that in 2017, 69 per cent of the texts studied at GCSE English Literature will be by men, a 12 per cent increase in disparity from the 60/40 split in 2014 exams.
With over 500,000 GCSE students annually, this means more than half a million children are being presented with texts that fail to represent a society that is more diverse than ever before.
Crucially, reading lists are doing increasingly less justice to the brilliant women writers informing literary and cultural heritage.
While the results show that the gender breakdown of the set texts has never been even close to equal, the latest statistics are evidence it’s becoming more and more heavily skewed towards white men, a demographic with a long-standing tradition of dominance, to the exclusion of women writers.
For Books’ Sake is petitioning exam boards to commit to gender equality, and to better diversity in terms of race, class and sexuality.
We do not think it is acceptable that in a purportedly progressive society, young women and people of colour will struggle to find themselves represented in the books that they study.
We think this regressive, imbalanced approach to children’s education needs to be addressed.
A token Brontë novel does not excuse the omission of voices for a range of classes, races, sexualities or political movements, nor does it do justice to an English heritage that includes a vast amount of strong, outspoken and groundbreaking women writers.
There is no shortage of women writers.
Our archive – curated by a voluntary, unpaid team – features almost 2,000 reviews, interviews, features and news stories championing women writers from all backgrounds.
And there is no excuse for women writers to account for less than a third of those studied from 2015.
It’s time for action. It’s time to #BalanceTheBooks.
Over 500,000 young adults take GCSEs in England and Wales each year.
A commitment to gender equality by exam boards could mean more than half a million students annually reading more women writers, and accessing a more diverse range of voices;
Overall, students taking their exams in 2017 will study 38 per cent more texts written by men than texts written by women – that’s a 12 per cent increase in disparity from those who took exams in 2014.
For study period 2015-2017, AQA are proposing a specification with 74 per cent of its texts by men – a significant change from previous years where the split was 60/40.
Students sitting their GCSEs with WJEC consistently receive 48 per cent fewer texts by women to read than texts by men – that’s half the representation for women writers’ work.
In the proposed texts to be studied in the CIE drama module for the 2017 specification, there are currently no women whatsoever.
In total, there are only twelve texts by women writers proposed for 2017, and only three authors are women of colour.
Remarking on this, author and journalist Dr Brooke Magnanti (Belle du Jour) said: “Reading at school is one of the best opportunities to open people’s eyes to diverse experiences and to discuss works they might otherwise never have seen.
“Women’s writing is not only an important part of this experience, it’s an essential one: women from Austen to Angelou subvert and challenge what we think is default and acceptable in society, their words inspire readers and change lives.
“Accepting others for who they are starts with understanding, and what better way to understand someone than to read the words they write?”
“As a feminist teacher who works on designing and teaching inclusive curricula, it is critical that women’s voices be a part of literature classrooms.
“Students need to read the wide range of texts that have been written not only by men but also by women and the contributions they have made to literary history,” educator and activist Ileana Jiménez added.
To sign our petition, click here.











