subscribe: Posts | Comments

Royal Society to investigate imbalance

0 comments

Royal Society, women scientists, research fundingOf the 43 fellowships awarded in 2014, just two went to female scientists.

The Royal Society has promised a full investigation into the gender imbalance in its recently announced science fellowships.

There is a buzz around getting women into science at the moment – which is why the Royal Society’s announcement of their University Research Fellowships (URFs) last month came as a surprise to many.

After years of slow progress, 2010 saw one third of the Society’s fellowships secured by women.

But since then the percentage of fellowships received by women has been steadily declining, and of the 43 fellowships awarded in 2014, just two went to female scientists.

The prestigious fellowships provide five years of assured funding and the possibility of an extension to scientists in the early stages of their careers.

This gives researchers the stability and support they need to become potential leaders in their field.

‘This year women accounted for 19 per cent of the applications for the URF scheme but only accounted for 13 per cent of those shortlisted, 9 per cent of those interviewed and less than 5 per cent of those awarded.’

The President of the Royal Society, Sir Paul Nurse, wrote, in the Society’s In Verba blog; ‘Last year women accounted for roughly 20 per cent at all stages of the process.’

‘We do not know why the numbers this year are so different to previous years but I have asked for an investigation.

‘We need to find out what happened and if we identify problems in our systems we will correct them,’ he said.

While women have fared better in some of the other fellowship schemes the Royal Society operates, Nurse wrote that the gender imbalance in the URFs sends out the wrong message to young women looking to pursue a career in science.

He was nonetheless keen to point out that 21 per cent of the people on the committees which oversaw the URF process this year were women.

Nurse appears to believe the problem may lie in the calibre of the female applicants.

‘The Royal Society must focus on excellence and we will not compromise on that, but we are aware that too many talented individuals do not fulfil their scientific potential because of issues such as gender, ethnicity or disability,’ he wrote.

‘This is a problem across science, including at the Royal Society, and I hope that by investigating the problems we can better understand what needs to be done to improve the situation.’

A focus on excellence is all very well, but as one commentator on the In Verba blog rightly noted: ‘[A] selection based on excellence will not result in a gender disparity.’

The promise of an investigation and the transparency with which the Royal Society has displayed its diversity figures are to be applauded.

But the Royal Society has been criticised before for its selection processes.

Jonathan Eisen, an American evolutionary biologist at the University of California, reportedly called the Royal Society “a club of mostly older white men that every year picks more similar members to join their club”.

In addition, by implying that the URF gender imbalance could be down to the quality of the candidates and/or due to a sector-wide problem, Nurse appears to be trying to direct attention away from the Society’s responsibility to confront internal bias, no matter who was on the selection committee.

Let’s hope the investigation does not also try to deflect responsibility.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *