subscribe: Posts | Comments

‘Prove’ rape for third child tax credits

0 comments

tax credits, third child, rapeA government proposal requires women to prove they were raped.

The government wants to limit tax credits to the first two children in a family as part of its £12 billion welfare cuts.

From 2017, this will mean the loss of tax credits for a third child or any further children.

With a few token exemptions – including multiple births and ‘women who have a third child as a result of rape or other exceptional circumstances’.

This effectively means that women who have a third child as the result of rape will be forced to ‘prove’ to the Department of Work and Pensions (DWP) that the rape occurred and resulted in the birth of this third child.

SNP MP for Glasgow Central, Alison Thewliss, first drew attention to the clause on Twitter last week.

‘We think the policy on limiting tax credits is appalling anyway, and tantamount to social engineering, but putting a woman who has been raped – and her child – in that position is shocking,’ she has been quoted as saying.

“It is completely unfair to limit child tax credits to the first two children in a family; it is absolutely callous and inhumane however to ask a woman who has been a victim of rape to fill in some kind of form or to declare to a member of DWP staff that her child has been the product of rape,” Thewliss said in The National.

“It piles humiliation on top of trauma. Tory ministers cannot say whether a woman will have to prove this, whether it will depend on a conviction – we know that rates of conviction are still far too low.

“It puts a woman in a very vulnerable position, and risks stigmatising both mother and child.

“The government must rethink this offensive proposal as a matter of urgency,” she said.

Lisa Longstaff, from Women Against Rape, described the proposal as “disgusting”.

“Asking women to disclose very difficult information and expecting them to be able to prove it – in what is frankly a very hostile environment when the DWP is trying to take your money away – will have appalling consequences,” she said.

And Kirsten Oswald, SNP MP for East Renfrewshire, called on the government to dedicate time for a debate on the “incredibly distasteful” proposal.

However this was refused by the leader of the house, Chris Grayling, who in his response managed to combine patronising Oswald with toeing the Tory party line of scaremongering about benefit fraud .

Firstly he talked down to Oswald, saying she had already had the opportunity to raise this issue, and implied that she was overreacting, saying: “The Chancellor [of the Exchequer, George Osborne] was very clear yesterday that this provision will be designed in a way to handle difficult cases in the most sensitive possible way.”

Then he proceeded with the scaremongering, saying: “But she [Oswald] must also understand the necessity of putting in place a system of welfare that is grounded in common sense, that is designed to help people back into the workplace, and she will know that there have been many, many examples of people with very large families who are absolutely overt in their statements that they have had large families in order to take advantage of the welfare system.”

Oswald Tweeted afterwards that she was ‘appalled’ by Grayling’s response.

However the Treasury has yet to back down on the issue, saying vaguely that ‘details’ of the special protections received by mothers having a third child due to rape will be set out ‘in due course’.

The problem with the policy is that for all the ‘sensitivity’ in the world, the onus will still be on the women to claim she was raped in order to avoid being hit by the benefits and tax credits cuts, as Anoosh Chakelian pointed out in The New Statesman.

‘This would put women in the distressing position of having to tell the authorities about having been raped, and would also introduce another level of potentially damaging intrusion from government departments into the lives of welfare claimants,’ she wrote.

Sandy Brindley, a spokesperson for Rape Crisis Scotland, has pointed out that the policy “inherently unworkable”.

“How does a DWP worker prove someone has or hasn’t been raped?” she asked.

“I think many women would find explaining that situation extremely uncomfortable. Many don’t report to the police that they have been raped or go years without reporting it or speaking about it, so they cannot be expected to explain it to a DWP worker.

“And what training does a DWP worker have to deal with rape victims?” she asked.

“It’s an unrealistic, ill-thought out and unhelpful proposal.”

Roger Mullin, SNP MP for Kirkcaldy and Cowdenbeath, has gone further and doubted the plan’s morality.

“What on earth is moral about dragging women to have to talk about the fact that they may have been raped to get some decent treatment out of benefits in this society?” he asked.

“I would appeal to the Government… for goodness sake, you may seek savings in many other parts of welfare but don’t punish children and don’t force women who have gone through the trauma of rape to have to justify themselves to the taxman.”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *