Family rights: time for change
The public purse is under no risk from the arrival of spouses and non-British children.
Family reunion campaigners have renewed their commitment to press for change.
Three years since the rules on family migration were changed campaigners are being proven correct in their predictions on the perverse outcomes the measures have led to. Here are some ideas on what needs to be done to continue pressure for change.
The events organised last week to mark the third anniversary of family migration rules which hugely increased the income level required from people sponsoring the admission of family members was rewarding for all involved in the sense of solidarity and mutual aid which passed between participants.
Despite the fact that the rules remain firmly in place supporters of the campaign who have been going through the experience of trying to bring in spouses and children reported very welcome success in a number of cases getting over the obstacles which the Home Office has put in place to make reunification with loved ones an immensely difficult task.
The information which passes between supporters and the groups involved in the campaign, notably BritCits, JCWI, the Family Immigration Alliance, and of course, Migrants’ Rights Network (MRN), is proving to be of some help in getting a result at the end of long months of battling with the Home Office.
But it is the case that early hopes that the rules would be quickly overturned by a successful legal challenge on human rights grounds have been disappointed.
The case of ‘MM’ versus Secretary of State for the Home Department will be coming up for consideration by the Supreme Court only in February next year.
Lawyers acting for the families involved are working hard to ensure that the judges understand the full magnitude of the harm that these immigration rules are inflicting on people.
Discussions at the anniversary events made it clear that the campaign should not be putting all its eggs in the single basket of the legal challenge however, and that renewed efforts need to be made to get the issues back on the political agenda.
Three years after the introduction of the rules we now see that the worst predictions that the rules would have draconian impacts on families have become a reality for thousands.
This is even more true for those living outside of London and the South East, women, young people at an early stage of their career, people from certain ethnic minorities, and sponsors living with disabilities.
The briefing on the extent of this discrimination published by the Oxford University-based Migration Observatory in November last year sets out the facts on how this discrimination has become entrenched in the policies of the Home Office.
Yet it seems to be the case that the extent of the unfairness that now exists in this area is still only poorly understood even by Members of Parliament.
Campaign supporters reported how their contact with local MPs revealed the common belief that the policy was acting to safeguard the public purse from additional expenditure arising from the admission of dependent members of low income families.
The point that the public purse was in any event under no risk from the arrival of spouses and non-British children owing to the imposition of long-standing ‘no recourse to public funds’ conditions on with limited leave to enter and remain, is still not widely acknowledged by the people who are responsible for drafting and overseeing the implementation of rules and regulations.
The government’s line that the measure will save the British taxpayer £660 million over the space of ten years has been challenged by a review of the effects of the policy conducted by experts at Middlesex University.
Their work sets out the compelling counter-argument that, by failing to take into account the wider benefits of the economic activity of migrant partners UK taxpayers are likely to have to bear a cost of £850 million over the same period of ten years.
The reluctance of legislators in Parliament to address the evidence emerging from the implementation during these past three years needs to be addressed with a renewed effort to explain the true position to them.
The opportunity to do this might be present in the fact that the Parliament elected in May contains over 180 new MPs who have not participated in the discussions which led up to the introduction of the measures back in July 2012.
The campaign will be playing a useful role in ensuring that Parliamentarians receive a fresh briefing on all these issues, tailored as far as possible to include a report on what the implications of the provisions of the rules are for people living in their own constituencies.
The report prepared by MRN back in June 2014 on the differential impact of the income requirement on people living in regions and Parliamentary constituencies needs to be looked at again and presented to the new Parliament.
Other strands of work that will need to be taken up and supported include the inquiry initiated by the Children’s Commissioner on the impact of the rules on children needs to be taken up and supported.
The Commissioner for England, Anne Longfield, spoke at the anniversary event in Parliament and called on people affected by the issue who have children in their family to provide evidence through the on-line survey form on their website.
The issue of the wider impact of tougher rules in family reunion on the participation of migrants as full members of society also has to be reconsidered in the light of the findings of the Migration Integration Policy Index which has seen the UK falling out of the top ten countries which are generally seen as having the best outcomes in this area, largely as a consequence of the changes in family reunion policy.
Any campaign will have to make sure that MPs and others fully understand this fact, and are up to the task of taking the action needed to remedy the situation.
Events of last week have underscored the fact that this remains a live issue which is continuing to generate injustice for large numbers of people who have a right to fair consideration of their wish to enjoy a family life in this country.
As the evidence continues to mount of perverse and unjust outcomes for so many people we will be renewing our efforts to press for substantial change to the rules, and for this to happen sooner rather than later.
A version of this article by Don Flynn, the director of the Migrants Rights Network, appeared on the Migrant’s Rights Network blog on 13 July 2015.











