Trauma, women and prison
The traumatic personal experiences of criminalised people often go unnoticed. Their experiences are ignored, their needs minimised, their support and treatment an afterthought.
The Centre for Crime and Justice Studies has started providing a space for women’s voices to be heard by the publication of a series of short articles under the title ‘Breaking the Silence‘.
And Madeline Petrillo, a Senior Lecturer at the University of Portsmouth, has been helping the women to share their stories.
She has been using their own words where possible as recorded in a series of interviews for a project examining how women can find pathways to desisting from crime.
The names of the three women whose stories are outlined here – and other identifying information – have been changed.
Alice, for example, has paranoid schizophrenia she understands to have been triggered by having been raped.
‘I first got raped at 13. They went to my school but I didn’t tell the police. I don’t know. Maybe I was scared. And then I was raped again at 18, and I was raped again in January this year. I used to hate myself. I used to self-harm my face. I used to self-harm quite a lot but only on my face. I used to take a lot of drugs because of it. And I’ve got children and they’re not allowed to live with me because I’ve got paranoid schizophrenia now from being raped. Like, I used to think about it quite a lot and then it started to make my mind a bit unwell.’
This is Rosie’s experience:
‘My offence happened last year, but they didn’t put me in prison till last month. So I was starting to get my life back on track. Got a new home. Trying to sort myself out. Then they put me in jail…I didn’t think I’d done anything wrong.’
Rosie was imprisoned for an offence of criminal damage. A taxi driver had dropped her at the wrong place following a night out. ‘I didn’t know where I was so I went a bit hysterical. Because I’d been through domestic violence and stuff, I was just….at the time I was living in a safe house’.
Rosie initially refused to leave the taxi and then, once on the street, kicked the door a few times. She admits she was drunk at the time. ‘It was Christmas. I don’t really drink. When I have a drink it doesn’t agree with me. Everything was piling up on top of me. I just thought I’d have a few drinks and enjoy myself.’
Rosie was never asked about the things that were piling up on top of her during her journey through the criminal justice system. ‘The Judge just sent me straight to prison. No report. It didn’t look like he had any interest.’
This was her first conviction. She was sentenced to four weeks in custody.
If reports had been requested, and if Rosie had been given the chance to tell her story, what looks like a harsh but commensurate sentence in response to her crime would have been revealed to be cruel, unnecessary and harmful.
Lynne first had a drink at the age of seven. Her dad was an alcoholic and would bring beer home from the pub and encourage her to drink. ‘Even then, I wanted more. By 11, I’d get drunk. At secondary school I was smoking. I’d had a sexual relationship by then with a girl. We’d both been abused by men. I just hate men. It was very confusing. At 11 I was put on Valium by a doctor.’
Lynne went to the doctor when she was 11 because she was at breaking point. ‘All I knew was being beaten up as a child by my father. He never sexually abused me but neighbours, family friends, dad used to bring them home from the pub. I used to get paid for it. It went on till I was 11. Then I couldn’t take it no more.’
Lynne had not felt safe at any point in her life until she was imprisoned. Whilst this reflects positively on the opportunities afforded her in custody, it challenges us to question the legitimacy of punishing Lynne whilst remaining silent about all the harm inflicted on her; to question a system that only acknowledges some victims, leaving those like 11 year-old Lynne to develop coping strategies that later contribute to their involvement in the criminal justice system.
Commenting on the recent surprise announcement by the chancellor, George Osborne, of the imminent closure of Holloway prison, Rebecca Roberts and Claire Cain have called for a managed reduction in the prison population.
The women who end up in prison often have personal histories of poverty, trauma, neglect, abuse, mental health issues and violence – as is revealed in the Breaking the Silence comment series.
Most women in prison do not pose a risk to anyone but themselves, Roberts and Cain point out. Indeed, this year has seen the highest levels of self-inflicted deaths in the women’s prison system for seven years.
Why not, they suggest, simply reduce the number of places in the women’s estate by (at least) 500 next year, and continue to do so until we have fewer than 100 women in a significantly smaller and more humane custody system.
Baroness Corston’s recommendation for small custodial units should be given serious consideration.
Importantly, they continue, at the same time as reducing the numbers of people in prison, we also need to ensure that the wider services are available to support women in the community.
These services should not be run by criminal justice agencies.
Fixing the criminal justice system and fixing those people detained inside it has been a core concern of social reformers and lawmakers throughout the history of imprisonment.
But while reforms are often driven by humanitarian objectives, they can reinforce the legitimacy of imprisonment and punishment.
This sale means the government will be capitalising on prime real estate to cover shortfalls in public funds elsewhere. The benefit for prisoners or wider society is highly questionable.
A prison building programme will increase capacity in the system. Amid concerns about rising levels of self-harm and violence in prison, new institutions can include closer monitoring and tighter levels of supervision.
We can build cleaner and more high-tech and low-staff prisons but they will still be places of cruelty and desperation.
They will be just as isolating and painful and distressing – and do little to address the needs of people in prisons or address wider social problems.
Furthermore, by investing in the ‘corrections industry’, the foundations will be laid to continue expanding the infrastructure of punishment and control in net-widening interventions such as community-based punishment, electronic monitoring and satellite tracking.
It is, in short, as they say, time to abandon the already tested and failed systems of punishment and control that reinforce and compound trauma, inequality and harm.












