Liberty calls for support for privacy
Why shouldn’t the State obtain a warrant when it comes to our communications?
Surveillance powers can play an important role in preventing and detecting serious crime.
But the current framework fails to provide sufficient safeguards to ensure it is conducted in a necessary, proportionate and accountable way – online and offline.
The government’s Draft Investigatory Powers Bill is a once-in-a-generation opportunity to shape our laws for the better – however current proposals will make us less safe and less free.
That is why Liberty is asking you to add your voice to Liberty’s Safe and Sound campaign for a secure and private Britain.
The authorities do a vital job, but abuses can and have happened.
The Metropolitan police accessed journalists’ phone records, spied on a grieving Baroness Lawrence and her family and infiltrated social and environmental justice groups to the extent that women were tricked into serious relationships – one even having a child with an undercover officer.
GCHQ spied on a torture victim and his lawyers challenging MI6 complicity in his kidnap to Gaddafi’s Libya and unlawfully intercepted the communications of human rights organisations including Amnesty International.
We expect the State to obtain a warrant before entering our homes, never mind searching them and taking away our belongings. Why should it be any different when it comes to our communications?
As ever greater amounts of our lives are stored, shared and sent online, a detailed and intimate picture of you can be pieced together – revealing much more than any search through your bedside drawer.
Don’t we all deserve some basic protections?
These crime-fighting tools can be used in a way that both keeps us safe and respects our privacy – show your support by signing up to Liberty’s Safe and Sound 8 Point Plan today.
This is Liberty’s ‘Safe and Sound 8 Point Plan’ for a secure and private Britain:
1. Judicial sign-off
All surveillance requests must be authorised by a judge.
All surveillance requests (including interception, acquisition of communications data, use of Covert Human Intelligence Sources etc) must be subject to prior judicial authorisation.
There is growing consensus on the importance of prior judicial warrantry for intrusive practices which includes former heads of MI5, GCHQ, Association of Chief Police Officers, the former Met police director of intelligence, the Government’s reviewer of terror legislation as well as parliamentarians across the political spectrum.
A huge number of democratic countries make use of judges in signing off surveillance – including all the other countries involved in the Five Eyes Alliance; USA, Australia, Canada and New Zealand.
2. Respect our data
No new blanket powers forcing communications companies to store more – and more revealing types – of our data.
David Anderson has warned that the case for the “Snoopers’ Charter” has not been made.
The USA and other European and Commonwealth countries do not compel service providers to retain their customers’ weblogs for inspection by law enforcement and Australia recently passed legislation strictly prohibiting it.
Going down this road would put us in the company of Russia which requires service providers to routinely store the weblogs of all their customers.
The track record of internet companies to keep that data safe doesn’t fill us with confidence – for example see the recent hacking of TalkTalk – four people so far have been arrested including some under the age of 16.
3. Targeted surveillance – for a reason
Surveillance should only be conducted for a number of tightly defined reasons i.e preventing and detecting serious crime and preventing loss of life. Additional protection should be provided for privileged and confidential material.
A targeted approach to surveillance – requests and warrants must target individuals on the basis of suspicion in criminal activity.
Additional protection for privileged and confidential material.
Legislative safeguards providing additional protection for legally privileged communications, journalistic sources and parliamentarians’ correspondence should be enshrined in primary legislation.
4. Transparency and Redress
Surveillance powers should be publicly disclosed and safeguards set out in legislation. Improved redress and increased transparency for those who have been under unlawful surveillance or are no longer under suspicion.
Improved redress mechanisms for those subject to unlawful surveillance – the IPT should be overhauled and made more transparent with a right of appeal and an ability to make declarations of incompatibility under the Human Rights Act.
Once a criminal investigation involving surveillance has been completed, or once a person is no longer under any suspicion, he or she should be notified of the relevant surveillance unless there is an objectively justifiable reason for maintaining secrecy.
5. Use of intercept evidence in court
Intercepted communications should be admissible in criminal trials.
The bar on the admissibility of intercept evidence, if properly obtained via a judicial warrant, in criminal proceedings should be lifted. Why is this vital evidence not used to bring perpetrators to justice?
6. Fair and open international data sharing laws
The arrangements for intelligence sharing of surveillance data between the UK and other countries must be set out in law and available to the public.
7. Protect our encryption standards
8. Recognition of the unique threat hacking poses to our security
Hacking is a grave privacy intrusion – much more intrusive than “traditional” forms of state surveillance, including interception, and its capacity to undermine device, network and internet security can’t be overstated.
It carries unlimited and untested potential for Government to act against the security and economic interests of its own citizens, whether consciously or otherwise.
There must be an informed public and parliamentary debate over the circumstances in which hacking can ever be lawful and exceptional safeguards to govern its use.
You can help shape the law by signing up to Liberty’s Safe and Sound 8 Point Plan. The more of you Liberty has behind this campaign, the bigger our collective voice is.











