subscribe: Posts | Comments

Love in a time of Cameron wanting change

0 comments

Love Letters to the Home Office, Change which could directly affect the ability of UK citizens to bring their non-EU family to the UK.

David Cameron’s negotiations with the EU have been all over the news these last few days, with a lot of focus on Donald Tusk’s response to Cameron’s key demand for a 4-year ban on in-work benefits for EU migrants.

Campaign group Love Letters to the Home Office, remarking on this, said:

While the European Council has proposed a compromise which many are calling a defeat for Cameron, there are other, less noticed, concessions in the proposed changes to the free movement laws, which could have a direct bearing on the ability of UK citizens to bring their non-EU family to the UK.

In short, the proposal seems specifically targeted at closing the option of moving to an EU country with less restrictive rules than the UK, getting married, and then applying for a family permit.

The second part of the proposal is I think even fuzzier, as there is no way to objectively quantify “sufficiently genuine.”

It goes beyond proving your relationship is “real” into forcing people to prove the underlying motivation of having moved abroad in the first place, and leaves the decision open to a completely subjective opinion.

Full information on the EU proposals is available here.

It is just a draft proposal, and it may yet change, but it is important that people know what is on the table.

As it stands it would appear that the Surinder Singh route would still be possible, but could be significantly harder.

It’s not clear how non-spouse family would be affected, and as Steven points out in the BritCits newsletter, these proposals raise more questions than they answer.

There is far more that we don’t know about what the impacts might be than what we do know right now.

There are some things you can do, right now, though:

As ever, write your MP (or MSP, or MEP) and express your opinion.

And if you are in London and/or can travel, consider attending the Supreme Court hearings in February, where appeals on two different important cases will be presented.

The outcome of these cases is likely to have a direct impact on what the government can and cannot mandate, and a large public presence will help illustrate to the court what a real, human cost there is to the Family Migration Rules.

The Supreme Court has agreed to hear appeals in not one but two important cases relating to the minimum income rules.

The case known as MM (Lebanon) is the one we were all watching keenly last year as the Home Office appealed an earlier ruling which declared the cuurent income rules in violation of EU Human Rights Law.

That appeal what disappointingly upheld – here is an in-depth analysis of the ruling – but the court has given permission to further appeal, with hearings before the court happening on 22-24 February 2016.

The court has also agreed to hear an appeal on a related second case,  SS (Congo) & Others at the same time.

Quoting 43templerow, the legal firm representing many of the plaintiffs:

“The case of MM deals with whether the rules are so harsh that they represent an inherently disproportionate interference in the right to a family life under Article 8 ECHR, or alternatively that they are lawful because the Secretary of State or a tribunal can allow cases on a discretionary basis even where the rules are not met.

“The case of SS looks at the width of that second stage – Theresa May arguing that consequences such as those identified […] by the Children’s Commissioner are simply not good enough to qualify as an exception.”

Either case could prove a vital turning point in the struggle for thousands of families affected by the minimum income rules.

As 43templerow said: “The decision of the Supreme Court is likely to be the most significant human rights cases it has decided in years: in legal terms the extent to which government policy can determine the outcome of assessments of proportionality in Article 8, and in human terms by the tens of thousands of people’s lives it will affect.”

Campaigners BritCits are inviting people who are able to go to the Supreme Court to attend the hearings as audience in the gallery.

The hearings are public, people are welcome to attend, and entrance is free.

BritCits said: “The more people who are seen in the gallery the more public interest this case will generate, and it also shows the judges the people directly affected by these rules – we’re not just Home Office statistics.

“For those who cannot attend the hearing should be broadcast live, but again, please do attend if you can – all three days or just part of one day.

“Your presence does make a difference.”

BritCits has created a Facebook event here.

The live broadcast should be availble to watch here.

And on Twitter you can follow the hashtag #mmcase.

You can also tweet Love Letters to the Home Office, like Love Letters to the Home Office on Facebook, and share your stories to help raise the voice of everyone affected by the rules.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *