subscribe: Posts | Comments

Barton Moss slow walk cases dropped

0 comments

Barton Moss, anti-fracking demonstration, cases droppedThe ‘dubious legality’ under which arrests were carried out ‘raises important questions’.

The final three cases of the hundreds of charges brought by the Crown in relation to the Barton Moss anti-fracking protests of 2013 and 2014 were heard at Manchester Magistrates Court on 27 April 2016 – and the judge delivered not guilty verdicts on the charges of aggravated trespass.

An overwhelming number of the charges relating to those protests were either dropped or quashed, and there is a growing call for a public inquiry into the policing and cost of the response to the Salford protests.

Women campaigners at Barton Moss in Salford told researchers they were groped and threatened by Greater Manchester Police officers.

And Barbara Keeley, MP for Worsley and Eccles South, has questioned the scale and cost of police force used at Barton Moss protest, saying: “The scale and cost of the police force being used at the protest at Barton Moss is an issue for tax-payers and I will continue to ask the question as to why the Chief Constable thinks that a force of this size is needed.”

As the Salford Star reported, this last case concerned Annabel Newfield, Stephen Jefferies and Laura Parkes.

They had participated in a ‘slow walk’ demonstration on 18 February 2014 at the IGas exploratory drilling site in Salford, and were pulled from the crowd and arrested.

The judge was shown footage, taken by both the police and an anti-fracking livestreamer, heard evidence from police officers present at the time and concluded that the prosecution case “contradicted the evidence” before him.

The 50-page ‘Keep Moving Report on the policing of the Barton Moss community protection camp’ by researchers at Liverpool John Moores and York Universities examined the operation by Greater Manchester Police at Barton Moss.

It concluded:

“The dubious legality under which arrests were carried out, evidenced by the readiness of the courts to challenge their legal basis, raises important questions about the extent to which the policing operation was driven by interests other than public order and crime prevention.”

The report also said mass arrest was a central part of the police operation.

“The tactic served to physically clear protesters from the site, to deter others from attending the camp and to reinforce the construction of protesters as violent criminals and thereby legitimise the intensity of the policing operation.”

Speaking outside the court after being not guilty, Stephen Jefferies said: “I’m pleased, but it’s tinged with a bit of annoyance that it’s actually taken this long, especially with the money it’s cost. It seems to me that there wasn’t much of a case against us, as was shown today.

“But they still relentlessly pursued it at public expense.”

“I think when David Cameron says that no expense will be spared in the pursuit of fracking, this is what he means, that he will pursue every single protester and take them through court to try and scare them off from doing it again.”

This issue was raised in the statement by Maina Kiai, the United Nations’ Special Rapporteur, on the rights to freedom of peaceful assembly and of association at the conclusion of his recent visit to the United Kingdom.

Kiai spoke of a number of specific areas of concern, which, he said, will be covered more comprehensively in his report to the Human Rights Council in June 2017:

‘In a number of instances, he said, the police have continued to use force against protestors in an excessive manner.

‘The Greater Manchester Police, for example, reportedly took violent action against anti-fracking protestors at the Barton Moss Camp from November 2013 to April 2014.

‘The College of Policing’s code of ethics, a laudable initiative which refers to the use of force, among other principles and standards of professional behaviour for the police, should be abided by.

‘I further urge them to read the joint report I presented to the UN Human Rights Council last month with Christof Heyns, Special Rapporteur on extrajudicial, summary or arbitrary executions.

‘The report, which is a compilation of practical recommendations for the proper management of assemblies, contains a number of recommendations that are of particular relevance to this situation.

‘I note with satisfaction that the protest liaison officers’ programme has been instrumental in ensuring the smooth running of many protests.

‘There is indeed great value in ensuring open and conducive dialogue between protestors and the police.

‘I remain concerned, however, about striking a balance between these liaison functions and the officers’ duty to gather intelligence on protests, which if not carefully managed, may erode trust.

‘My attention was also drawn to the alleged collusion between law enforcement authorities and private companies in the context of protests against businesses.

‘I was informed that protesters have been arrested, forced to provide their names and addresses, and then found their names as targets of injunctions by the companies against further protest activity. This was for instance the case in relation to the “no dash for gas” protest at a gas power station in 2014 and at some anti-fracking protests.

‘I find this alleged practice troubling, and fail to see its legal justification.

‘I also heard allegations that the police have continued to resort on several occasions to mass arrests and stop and search powers in the context of protests, most notably anti-fracking demonstrations, with a view to gathering intelligence on protestors.

‘I want to underscore the chilling effect of such practice among protestors.’

Annabel Newfield, the Salford Star reported, said: “It’s been two years and three months since we were arrested at Barton Moss and it just seems so ridiculous that we even got arrested in the first place.”

“I’m incredibly happy with this verdict, which is a just verdict, because we didn’t do anything wrong,” she said. “We just exercised our peaceful right to protest.”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *