subscribe: Posts | Comments

Political bias, the BBC and sexism claims

0 comments

BBC, bias, petitions, moderate petitions, How it looks from here.

A recent petition set up on the 38 Degrees site complaining about the political bias of the BBC presenter on election night last week raised 35,000 signatures.

It was however taken down recently on the grounds that there were sexist or misogynist comments on it.

But people who asked to see these comments have not, to date, been shown them and when they were made public, possibly via a leak, they were once again hidden.

This has raised even more questions about BBC impartiality than it has either answered or quashed.

We have been watching for months now the Labour Party leader Jeremy Corbyn being picked to pieces in the press while under the current Conservative government child poverty increases, homelessness increases, disabled people and the poorly paid are ill-treated, women are tricked out of their pensions, face massive ill-effects of ideologically driven budgets and cuts to public spending, and in the face of questionable arms sales and questionable financial transactions.

But as far as the media is concerned, none of these issues mattered compared to whether one man in a crowd sings in a song.

And honestly, enough is enough.

Soon after Jeremy Corbyn’s election as leader of the Labour Party last September, the BBC was accused of an ‘anti Corbyn bias’ and challenged with a 61,000-strong petition demanding that they stop using the prefix ‘left-wing’ when reporting on events related to his leadership, former newspaper editor Nic Outterside wrote on his blog on the issue recently.

Even before he won a stunning 59.5 per cent of the vote, ensuring the largest democratic mandate of any Labour leader in modern history, Outterside continued, Corbyn was subject to what a source from his leadership campaign described as a ‘complete hatchet job’.

Former BBC political editor Nick Robinson even wrote to his colleagues over concerns about the Corporation’s bias against Corbyn, and Channel 4’s Michael Crick issued a stunning rebuke to broadcasters referring to non-left MPs as ‘moderates’.

Despite these protestations the BBC’s agenda – behaviour, reporting – did not change.

In January this year, Outterside pointed out, ‘Mr Corbyn’s so-called ‘revenge reshuffle’ led to the revelation that BBC political editor Laura Kuenssberg, Daily Politics presenter Andrew Neil and so-called ‘moderate’ Labour MP Stephen Doughty planned for Doughty to make a live resignation on their programme hours before it began.

‘Despite the fact that a live on-air resignation could be considered dramatic broadcasting, it beggars belief how it is the job of the BBC’s political editor to be of service to an evidently resentful shadow cabinet member intent on weakening the Labour leadership, Outterside pointed out.

‘A few hours later the producer of the programme bizarrely admitted in a BBC blog that Neil, Kuenssberg and himself manipulated the news to negatively impact Mr Corbyn during Prime Minister’s Questions that week’.

And, Outterside continued in the blog, ‘the producer – Andrew Alexander – admitted that the BBC team were not just reporting the day’s news but trying to influence it:

“We knew his resignation just before PMQs would be a dramatic moment with big political impact.

“We took a moment to watch the story ripple out across news outlets and social media. Within minutes we heard David Cameron refer to the resignation during his exchanges with Jeremy Corbyn.”

Matters moved up a gear this past week, Outterside continued, ‘when a 38 Degrees petition to sack Ms Kuenssberg, following her outlandishly politically biased reporting on the 5 May elections, was signed by more than 35,000 people in less than five days.

‘The fact that a very small number of people on social media used abusive and sexist language in calling for the BBC’s first female political editor to go, seemed at first like flotsam on the political wind.

‘Then suddenly, on Tuesday, 38 Degrees executive director David Babbs announced that the petition had been taken down with the agreement of the person who had posted it.

‘He [Babbs] said: “I am really concerned that a petition hosted on the 38 Degrees website has been hijacked, and used as a focal point for sexist and hateful abuse made towards Laura Kuenssberg on Twitter.

“That is totally unacceptable and, with the agreement of the petition starter, we’ve taken the petition down to prevent it being used in this way. There is no place in the 38 Degrees family for sexism or any form of discrimination or hate speech.”

People who both signed and endorsed the petition were taken aback by this, Outterside continued.

They had, as one does, read many of the comments on the 38 Degrees site, and of the scores of comments read through, only one was sexist. That one was quite unpleasant, but totally unrepresentative.

It seems astonishing that a tiny and unrepresentative number of people can get a petition scrapped which had been signed by many thousands of genuine people.

The only people who claim to have seen this widespread sexism is 38 Degrees, who have not produced any public evidence of this.

Laura Kuenssberg, Outterside said, ‘is the most openly biased journalist I have witnessed on the BBC over the past three decades’.

We here at WVoN have been shocked by the stance she has taken too.

The Canary reported that former UK ambassador Craig Murray had aired his suspicions that petition site 38 Degrees had removed its petition to fire BBC political editor Laura Kuenssberg for bias ‘under establishment pressure’.

Murray found and posted the comments connected to the petition on his blog.

He found only one abusive one, and remarked that ‘even if there are more nasty examples of abuse, that is not the fault of the 35,000 good people who signed the petition’.

And, he added, ‘there is a disconnect between two establishment narratives, both unproven. One is that Kuenssberg has been a victim of terrible misogynist abuse since appointment. The other is that the abuse was caused by the petition’.

The comments were then (once again) removed.

And, as Murray then asked, what does it say that having consistently been fed lies about these comments by David Cameron, Jess Phillips, 38 Degrees and the entire media, once the evidence is linked online it gets pulled at 4am in the morning?

Kay Green has now set up a petition asking 38 Degrees to moderate comments rather than down petitions.

Given that the rest of us moderate comments, this would seem logical.

In her petition letter to 38 Degrees’ Adam McNicholas, Green says:

‘More than 35,000 people signed the 38 degrees petition calling for the sacking of Laura Kuenssberg, due to the public losing patience with right-wing bias in BBC reporting – but then, say 38 degrees, it was taken down, because some people were making aggressive, sexist comments.

‘But anyone who uses social media regularly knows that just about anything gets its share of daft posts by ‘trolls’. Many people believe there are armies of paid trolls who set out to lower the tone on any social media site or activity their employer wishes to discredit.

‘That’s why moderators exist.

‘It should not be necessary to explain this: most public-access media have people who keep an eye on things, delete rude, aggressive or otherwise unacceptable posts, issue warnings and ban from site anyone who keeps coming back with abuse.

’38 degrees, please moderate your own sites, and if abusive comments elsewhere worry you, report them to the moderators of those sites.

‘There is no need to react by downing a petition people have signed.

‘In the strange political climate at this time, many people are very unsettled by 38 degrees’ odd decision.

‘If it happens again, people will begin to wonder what the motivation is.

’38 degrees, please protect the valuable service you give by changing your policy. Delete abusive comments, call out or report comments elsewhere, but don’t throw out petitions which, by their numbers of signatories, are clearly important to people.’

Which, from what we know, sums it up.

You can sign her petition here.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *