Disgust over pay gaps leads to strike
Two-day strike at UK universities over pay, pay gaps, and insecure contracts.
The University and College Union’s planned two-day national strike at UK universities is going ahead – is going on now – as part of a now long-running dispute over various aspects of staff pay.
University and College Union (UCU) members in higher education will be walking out on both 25 May and 26 May.
Staff will also begin working to contract from 25 May, which means they will refuse to work overtime, set additional work or undertake any voluntary duties like covering timetabled classes for absent colleagues.
If no agreement is reached in the coming weeks, members have agreed to target further strike action in June and July, and are considering additional action in August to coincide with the release of A-level results.
The union is also beginning preparations for a boycott of the setting and marking of students’ work, to begin in the autumn if an acceptable offer has still not been made.
The dispute has arisen following a pay offer of 1.1 per cent from the employer’s body, the Universities and Colleges Employers’ Association (UCEA), which the union has described as ‘an insult’.
UCU said universities could afford to pay more and that the latest offer does little to address the real terms pay cut of 14.5 per cent suffered by higher education staff since 2009.
The squeeze on staff salaries comes at a time when pay and benefits for university leaders have increased, on average, by 3 per cent, with the average pay and pensions package for vice-chancellors standing at over £270,000.
A survey on higher education pay published on 19 May 2016 by Times Higher Education (THE) revealed that the average pay rise for the majority of academic staff was just 1.3 per cent while vice-chancellors received an average increase in their salary and benefits of 5.1 per cent. And once large pay-outs to departing vice-chancellors are included the figure is even higher – at 6.1 per cent.
The union branded the disparity a ‘disgrace’ and said universities need to consider how they would continue to attract the best academic staff while pay for the majority of staff was being held down.
English colleges’ reliance on insecure contracts, including zero-hours contracts, was laid bare in a report from UCU published in April 2016.
The report found that 34 per cent of the total teaching staff in 220 English further education colleges were employed on a range of insecure contracts.
Amongst non-lecturing staff who are delivering the curriculum, the proportion was even higher at 37 per cent.
And anecdotal evidence backed up by research has suggested that insecure contracts undermine teachers’ ability to do a good job as they often have poor access to facilities and training, can only get their job done by putting in unpaid hours, and are constantly stressed about future availability of work.
Insecure contracts in further education refer to ‘variable hours’ contracts, hourly-paid contracts, term-time only contracts and staff employed by agencies.
When looking at the subject in 2015, union pointed out that it was a myth that zero-hours contracts offered a fair and sensible deal for workers and employers. UCU said people who wanted the security of a proper contract should be given it.
The union said the extent of casualisation in colleges and universities would probably shock many students and parents. Research at that point showed that 61 per cent of colleges and 53 per cent of universities had teaching staff employed on zero-hours contracts.
And in March the UCU published a report highlighting the colleges and universities that pay female staff significantly less than men.
The report, ‘Holding Down Women’s Pay’, named and shamed the top 30 English further education colleges with the largest gender pay gaps amongst lecturing staff.
A further three league tables show the top 30 UK universities with the largest gender pay gaps amongst academic staff, professors and academic-related staff.
At nearly two-thirds (132 out of 203) of the English further education colleges that provided data to UCU, male lecturers are paid on average £1,000 more than women.
Kirklees College in Yorkshire topped the chart of English colleges, paying female lecturers an average £5,959 less than their male colleagues – a pay gap of 19.3 per cent.
In the ten worst offending colleges, the pay gap between the average pay for women and men is greater than 8 per cent.
In higher education, the average shortfall faced by female academics was £6,103 a year.
According to the union’s data, just eight higher education institutions paid women equally or more than men. At 154 institutions, women are paid less.
The higher education institution with the largest gender pay gap amongst academic staff was the University of Leicester, where women earn £9,793 less than men.
The institution with the largest gender pay gap amongst professors was City University in London, where female professors earned an average £15,992 less than their male colleagues – a pay gap of 16.4 per cent.
Bangor University in Wales had the most unequal pay amongst academic-related staff, with women earning an average £3,355 less than men – a pay gap of 7.9 per cent.
Remarking on this at the time, UCU general secretary Sally Hunt said: ‘These colleges and universities should not have allowed such shameful levels of pay inequality to persist.
“It’s nearly 50 years since the Equal Pay Act came into force and they’re still flying in the face of it.”
In January, the union wrote to 246 English colleges asking them to stop using zero-hours contracts and to work with UCU to review the use of all forms of non-permanent contracts.
Overall just 14 per cent (36) of those colleges said they were open to working with UCU to address the issue of precarious work.
Three fifths of the colleges (146) failed to respond to UCU’s letter. Thirty-five of the top 50 worst offenders ignored or responded negatively to UCU’s request.
Speaking about today’s strike action, UCU’s general secretary, Sally Hunt said: “Members in higher education have sent a clear message to employers that, after six years of real-terms pay cuts amounting to 14.5 per cent, they will not tolerate a continued squeeze on their income.
“Industrial action which impacts on students is never taken lightly, but staff feel that they have been left with no alternative.
“A 1.1 per cent offer is an insult to the hard work and dedication of higher education staff, particularly in light of the 3 per cent average pay rise enjoyed by vice-chancellors this year.
“The ball is now in UCEA’s court, but the employers need to come back to the table with a much improved offer if they wish to avoid significant disruption to students in the coming months.”











