subscribe: Posts | Comments

Benefits and the third child: consultation

0 comments

third child, consultation, benefits, two children, rape, exemptionsThe government is keen to hear views from all parties with relevant knowledge or experience.

The government is holding a public consultation regarding its idea that there should be some kind of penalty for people receiving benefits who have more than two children.

Or rather, a public consultation regarding the exemptions from the penalty.

It has proposed some exceptions to this limit, and has started a consultation regarding these exemptions headed ‘Exceptions to the limiting of the individual Child Element of Child Tax Credit and the Child Element of Universal Credit to a maximum of two children’.

The Welfare Reform and Work Act 2016 restricts the number of children or qualifying young persons in respect of whom the Child Element in Universal Credit and the Child Element in Child Tax Credit is payable to a maximum of two.

The Chancellor, at the time George Osborne, announced the policy at the presentation of the Summer Budget 2015 and during the passage of the legislation through Parliament four exceptions to this policy were announced.

There was a huge outcry at the time, with questions raised about stepchildren in re-marriages, new children on a second marriage, religious teachings on contraception, accidental pregnancy, an employment crisis and a pregnancy, and then the issue of a third child born to a women or girl who was raped.

Issues.

There is also the problem of sex education in our schools – or lack of – and the government apparently having no idea that far too many young couples have no idea whatsoever about conception or its prevention.

However, as the consultation says, the government is keen to hear views from all parties with relevant knowledge or experience, including charities and support groups, medical, health, social work and education professionals and affected individuals.

The consultation seeks views and evidence in relation to the detailed design and implementation of the exceptions to the policy to limit the Individual Child Element of Child Tax Credit and the Child Element of Universal Credit to a maximum of two children.

It is not a consultation on the policy itself.

The exceptions being consulted upon in this document apply to both Child Tax Credit and Universal Credit.

Universal Credit extends across Great Britain and Child Tax Credit across the United Kingdom.

Currently, benefit entitlement adjusts automatically to family size, whilst families supporting themselves solely through work do not see their incomes rise in the same way when they have more children.

Households will need to think carefully about whether they are financially prepared to support a new child without relying on the tax credits or means-tested benefit systems.

The government has recognised, however, that some parents or carers for children are not in the same position to make choices about the number of children in their family as others are.

In acknowledgement of this, the government announced the following exceptions to the policy in respect of a third or subsequent child who is:

part of a multiple birth where there were previously fewer than two children in the household (Chapter 3);

living long term with family or friends because they are unable to live with their parents and could otherwise be at risk of entering the care system (Chapter 4);

born as a result of rape (Chapter 5); or

part of a sibling group adoption where there were previously fewer than two children in the household.

However, as part of the Children and Social Work Bill, the government has given further consideration to the position of children who are being adopted from Local Authority care and will be extending the announced exception to all third and subsequent children in these circumstances. This change will support families that care for our most vulnerable children and will be provided for, along with the other exceptions, in regulations.

Here is a summary of the consultation questions.

Multiple births:

Q1. Do you have any views on the proposed model (set out in Chapter 3) for implementing the multiple birth exception?

Children living long term with family or friends:

Q2. Are there any other formal arrangements not covered in Chapter 4 for caring for the children of friends and family?

Q3. Where a formal order does not exist, do you agree that evidence from a social worker is the best approach to providing the necessary evidence of the need for an informal family and friends care arrangement?

Q4. Are there circumstances where a professional, other than a social worker, may be able to provide such evidence?

Q5. Are there any further considerations we should make in relation to exempting grandchildren/new children (where the parent is under 16 and the grandchild/new child is on the claimant’s/grandparent’s Child Tax Credit or Universal Credit claim)?

Children likely to have been conceived as a result of rape:

Q6. Do you have views on using a third party evidence model?

Q7. Do you have any views on whether the list of professional third parties mentioned in paragraph 34 is the right list, or whether there are other professionals and bodies that should be added?

Q8. Do you have any views about any considerations we should take account of as part of the process of providing evidence for the exception. In particular, if there are any issues which might make it more difficult for a third party to assess a claim for exception, including non-recent cases.

Q9. Are there other considerations we should take into account in respect of the requirement to not be living with the alleged perpetrator?

Q10. Do you agree that where there is a successful conviction or award of compensation from the Criminal Injuries Compensation Authority for rape occurring at or around the time of the child’s conception, the exception will apply?

The full questions – and space to answer them – are on this link.

You can respond by email or by writing to: DWP Universal Credit Policy Team, Department for Work and Pensions, 3rd Floor, Caxton House, London SW1H 9NA.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *