Pakistani woman scientist sent to US “hospital of horror”
Dr Aafia Siddiqui, a Pakistani scientist, was recently sentenced to 86 years in a US prison with a reputation for mistreating women (see WVoN stories here and here).
Though the judge believed Siddiqui was fit to stand trial he ensured that she was sent to the Federal Medical Facility in Carswell, Texas.
Tehran Times reports that over the last 10 years more than 100 women in the facility have died under questionable circumstances, and their families have been unable to obtain autopsy reports.
There have also been numerous cases of alleged sexual abuse as well as medical negligence. Forced use of psychotropic drugs on resistant patients is also suspected.
Siddiqui was arrested in Afghanistan on July 17, 2008 and was tried based on accusations that the on the following day she fired a gun at US personnel. Amnesty International reports that Siddiqui was the only person injured in the confrontation. She has since been sentenced to 86 years in Carswell.
A sentence at the women’s medical facility in Carswell has been described as a death sentence by one local paper since many women who go in do not make it out. There are numerous outstanding lawsuits from survivors and those who died in custody.
This turn of events places the Pakistani government in a difficult position as it promised Siddiqui’s family that she would be treated with respect no matter where she was sent.
The work to repatriate Siddiqui must “take on a new sense of urgency … before it’s too late,” said journalist Yvonne Ridley.
















In response to the federal court judge’s comment that Carswell had been good for her, Aafia had said that Carswell was no better or worse than other prisons. She said that the rumors she had been tortured were false and that the public should verify rumors before crediting them. She specifically noted that Yvonne Ridley should know that islam was a religion of mercy. Most of all, Yvonne Ridley should recognize that Aafia has personal knowledge of what Carswell was like and that Aafia expressly contradicts the claims she makes. The transcript is online available to Ms. Ridley and as someone who imagines herself a journalist should be representing what Aafia said on the precise issue of Carsell at sentencing. Here, the important “Woman’s view” on news is Aafia’s, not Yvonne’s.