Pregnancy and discrimination in NI
This is not acceptable, forty years after the introduction of legislation in Northern Ireland.
Half of the women who responded to an Equality Commission investigation into the employment experiences of pregnant workers and mothers in Northern Ireland believe that their career opportunities have been negatively affected by their pregnancy or maternity leave.
That is one of the findings of ‘Expecting Equality: a Formal Investigation under the Sex Discrimination (Northern Ireland) Order 1976’, which the Equality Commission for Northern Irelandpresented at a conference in the Titanic Building in Belfast earlier this week.
The type of unfair treatment reported varied, including termination of employment, having their role changed against their wishes, and losing out on salary increases or bonus payments in comparison to their colleagues.
The Equality Commission for Northern Ireland began a formal investigation under the Sex Discrimination (Northern Ireland) Order 1976 (as amended) in January 2015 to examine the employment experiences of pregnant workers and mothers in Northern Ireland.
The investigation was deemed appropriate and necessary in light of the volume of inquiries received by the Commission regarding potential pregnancy and maternity discrimination and the growing body of research highlighting the persistence of potentially discriminatory treatment experienced by pregnant employees and mothers in workplaces throughout the United Kingdom.
More than 900 mothers working in the private and public sector, with children aged under five, took part in the research.
A significant percentage, 36 per cent, said they believed they had been treated unfairly or disadvantaged as a result of their pregnancy or maternity leave.
They believed that as a female employee they were expected to make a choice between parenthood and a rewarding career path.
Some women reported firms’ failure to consider the risks to health and safety of pregnant employees.
Others said they were overlooked for promotion; a dilution of work responsibilities; were denied training; had changes to working hours; experienced a reduction in bonus payments and were subjected to negative comments.
Of the employers surveyed in the investigation, the majority said that they provide support for pregnant employees and new mothers.
They referred to policies and practices they had in place including flexible working arrangements, childcare vouchers and return to work incentives such as phased return and bonus payments.
Some employers also identified challenges associated with managing pregnancy, maternity leave and return to work.
Difficulties in providing for staff absences were a concern to small businesses in particular.
The issues to be resolved, once summarised, are:
Personal attitudes and behaviours: attitudes held about pregnant employees and working mothers which are largely based on negative stereotypes;
Organisational policies and structures: organisational policies and structures may disadvantage pregnant employees and working mothers, or create an organisation which is unwilling or unable to be flexible and adapt to change;
Societal or cultural barriers: societal or cultural barriers refer to the norms which determine women’s roles in society and the devaluation of those roles; economic factors determining women’s participation in the labour market, and the lack of sufficient affordable, quality, childcare in Northern Ireland.
Dr Evelyn Collins, chief executive of Northern Ireland’s Equality Commission, said it was encouraging that almost half the women who responded to this investigation thought their employer had been supportive during their pregnancy and on their return to work.
And, she continued: “We know that there are many employers who want to do their best for their employees, who follow good practice, and have effective policies in place for pregnant members of staff.”
But, she said: “The results of this investigation highlight the need for an increased focus on ensuring that workplaces are fairer for, and more supportive, of pregnant employees and new mothers.”
“We have made a number of recommendations in the report, to improve access to advice and information for employers and for employees, to improve employers’ practices and to highlight the economic benefits of utilising and retaining the skills and experience of pregnant workers and new mothers.
“We also want to encourage employers across all sectors to show leadership at a senior level to gender equality and to building an organisational culture that promotes gender equality in the workplace.”
“Over one third of the women who talked to the Commission about their experiences said that they had been treated unfairly or disadvantaged because of their pregnancy or because they took maternity leave.
“They believe this affected their finances, their career opportunities, their status at work and their health.
“This is not acceptable, forty years after the introduction of legislation in Northern Ireland to provide protection from sex discrimination in employment.”











