Support new Amnesty motion on prostitution
Do not sanitise the true nature of prostitution: the commercialisation of sexual abuse.
On 26 May 2016, Amnesty International (AI) formally adopted a policy that called for the full decriminalisation of the sex trade.
While Amnesty International’s call for the full decriminalisation of all prostituted women, children, men and transgendered people, is welcomed, Nordic Model Now! very strongly disagrees with Amnesty’s call to decriminalise pimps, procurers and brothel owners and those who buy human beings for sex.
For under a veneer of concern for the human rights of the marginalised human beings who make up the vast majority of those in prostitution, Amnesty’s policy document is riddled with logical inconsistencies, omissions of key information and flawed reasoning.
The policy AI is supporting calls for laws that protect the health and safety of those in prostitution – as if prostitution can be made reasonably healthy and safe.
The dangers to women and girls’ health and safety do not stop at STIs and HIV (which would be bad enough) but include unwanted pregnancy, stabbings, broken bones, permanent damage to sphincters and internal organs, PTSD, anxiety, depression, suicide, and murder – all caused by the actions of pimps and punters and not by the stigma that the policy is so concerned with.
What legislation or regulations can protect against such damage when violence is inherent to prostitution itself?
Dr Anna Cleaves proposed a motion to Amnesty International UK (AIUK) asking the International Secretariat to re-evaluate its policy on prostitution. The resolution has been accepted, and it will be debated at the AIUK Conference in Nottingham on 8 and 9 April 2017.
This is not the first proposal from a national Amnesty section calling on the international organisation to reconsider its prostitution policy. A similar resolution was adopted by the French section.
Please pass on the word and encourage support for the motion. If you are a member of AIUK, please go to the AIUK Conference and vote for the motion.
Dr Anna Cleaves’ motion calls on AIUK to advocate to the international secretariat board to:
1 – Undertake balanced, rigorous research to make comparisons from recent findings between countries where prostitution is either decriminalised or legalised or which have adopted the Swedish legal framework (the latter being countries by which the UK is now practically surrounded);
2 – Use inclusive terminology to represent people in the sex trade rather than the term ‘sex worker’ and ‘sex work’, terms not representative of how most people in prostitution identify. The terms fail to include the vast majority of those in prostitution, 90 per cent of whom are women. A more inclusive term would be ‘prostituted persons’;
3 – Work with survivors of prostitution, to support their human rights and to recognise what survivor organisations are saying about the men who buy and pimp women; and
4 – Review the framework in which any policy on prostitution should sit. Alternative policy frameworks such as the elimination of all forms of discrimination against Women (CEDAW), prevention of torture and trauma or ending violence should be considered. To recognise that the Harm Reduction principle identified in AI’s policy is inappropriate in the context of prostitution.
Evaluating the decriminalisation of prostitution in 1999 in Denmark, in 2012 the Danish Social Agency reported an increase in the prevalence of prostitution.
The New Zealand Law Review Committee found, in 2008, that decriminalisation did not curb the high levels of violence that prostituted individuals experienced, demonstrating that prostitution is inherently violent and abusive, and the majority of prostituted persons are female whereas the majority of sex-buyers are male.
Empirical analysis for a cross-section of 150 countries showed that on average countries where prostitution is legal experience larger reported human trafficking inflows.
Research published in 2013 showed that none of the objectives – to destroy the stigma of prostitution; end trafficking; improving safety and generate tax revenues – of the legalisation introduced in Holland in 2000 had been achieved.
The Swedish Sexual Purchases Act (1999) in which buying sex became a criminal offence has now been adopted in France, Northern Ireland, Norway, Iceland, Canada, Lithuania and Israel and is supported by the European Parliament.
It holds that prostituted people are decriminalised, criminal records are wiped clean and Exit programmes are offered.
In Sweden, street prostitution has halved, and the number of murders of women in prostitution has dropped.
In evaluating the Swedish law, in 2010 Justice Skarhed submitted that on a gender equality and human rights perspective, shifting focus away from those who are exploited in prostitution to focussing on demand, i.e. traffickers, procurers and sex purchasers, the distinction between voluntary and non-voluntary prostitution is irrelevant.
The 1949 UN Convention on the Suppression of Trafficking in Persons, declared that prostitution and trafficking are exploitative and ‘incompatible with the dignity and worth of the human person and endanger the welfare of the individual, the family and the community’.
And the 2000 UN Palermo Protocol against Transnational Organised Crime said that any form of force, coercion, abduction, fraud, deception, abuse of power, or of a position of vulnerability or the giving or receiving of payments or benefits to achieve consent nullifies the apparent consent. Hence there is no such thing as ‘consensual prostitution’.
For, as survivor Rachel Moran has said: ‘To depict prostitution as chosen, with the prostitute in control, is to sanitise the true nature of prostitution: the commercialisation of sexual abuse.’











