Labour, Brexit and women’s rights
The Article 50 Bill: the start, not the end, of the Brexit process.
Theresa May has now published Article 50 legislation – the Bill to start the UK’s disentanglement from the European Union – in preparation for MPs’ votes.
MPs have been given just five days to debate it – and try to amend it.
The Bill, which is only eight lines long and contains just 130 words, was published this week after the Supreme Court ruled that MPs and peers must give their consent to invoking Article 50.
The government aims for the Bill to have cleared the House of Lords by early March.
Labour has tabled a number of targeted amendments to the Article 50 Bill (the European Union [Notification of Withdrawal] Bill).
Their amendments seek to improve the Brexit process, and ensure Parliament is able to hold the government to account throughout the negotiations.
Labour is also tabling an anti-tax haven amendment to ensure the Prime Minister does not use Brexit to weaken Britain’s laws concerning tax avoidance and evasion.
Labour will also support two amendments drafted by Melanie Onn MP which aim to protect workers’ rights and ensure there is no drop in employment protection after the UK leaves the European Union (EU).
Labour has said the amendments will:
i) Allow a meaningful vote in Parliament on the final Brexit deal. Labour’s amendment would ensure that the House of Commons has the first say on any proposed deal and that the consent of Parliament would be required before the deal is referred to the European Council and Parliament.
ii) Establish a number of key principles the government must seek to negotiate during the process, including protecting workers’ rights, securing full tariff and impediment free access to the Single Market.
iii) Ensure there is robust and regular Parliamentary scrutiny by requiring the Secretary of State to report to the House at least every two months on the progress being made on negotiations throughout the Brexit process.
iv) Guarantee legal rights for EU nationals living in the UK. Labour has repeatedly called for the government to take this step, and this amendment would ensure EU citizens’ rights are not part of the Brexit negotiations.
v) Require the government to consult regularly with the governments in Wales, Scotland and Northern Ireland throughout Brexit negotiations. Labour’s amendment would put the Joint Ministerial Committee (JMC) on a statutory footing and require the UK government to consult the JMC at least every two months.
vi) Require the government to publish impact assessments conducted since the referendum of any new proposed trading relationship with the EU. This amendment seeks to ensure there is much greater clarity on the likely impact of the government’s decision to exit the Single Market and seek a new relationship with the Customs Union.
vii) Ensure the government must seek to retain all existing EU tax avoidance and evasion measures post-Brexit.
Jeremy Corbyn, leader of the Labour Party, said: “Labour will seek to amend the Article 50 Bill to prevent the government using Brexit to turn Britain into a bargain basement tax haven off the coast of Europe. Our country can do much better than that.
“We respect the will of the British people, but not the will of this Tory government to impose fewer rights at work and worse public services, while the largest corporations pay even less tax.
“Labour will ensure that the British people, through Parliament, have genuine accountability and oversight over the Brexit negotiations because no one voted to give Prime Minister Theresa May a free hand over our future.”
The Shadow Secretary of State for Exiting the EU, Keir Starmer, said: “Now that Parliament has the right to trigger Article 50, we need to ensure there is proper grip and accountability built into the process.
“Labour’s amendments will also seek to ensure the Prime Minister secures the best deal for the whole country – including tariff and impediment free access to the Single Market and that there is no drop in workers’ rights.
“Labour’s amendments will significantly improve the government’s Bill – in particular by ensuring the House of Commons has the first say on the final Brexit deal and that there are regular opportunities to hold the government to account.
“Labour’s amendments will also seek to ensure the Prime Minister secures the best deal for the whole country – including tariff and impediment free access to the Single Market and that there is no drop in workers’ rights.
“We will also vigorously oppose any plans to reduce powers to tackle tax avoidance or evasion.
“The Article 50 Bill will be the start, not the end, of the Brexit process and Labour will hold the government to account all the way.”
And Melanie Onn MP, who has tabled two amendments, with Frontbench support, on workers’ rights, said: “The Tories can’t be allowed to use Brexit as an excuse to water-down people’s rights at work.
“That’s why I am introducing amendments to protect in British law all workers’ rights which originate from the EU, including maternity pay, equal rights for agency and part-time workers, and the working time directive.”
















From Tommy Cockerham:
So if you’ve been following this in the press you may be confused by what’s going on with Labour’s ‘three line whip’ on the Article 50 vote. This is because the media are banking on the fact that you don’t understand standard parliamentary process. A bill is voted on several times at various stages of it’s development before a final vote in parliament. You can vote for a bill at every stage and vote against it on the final vote. Ultimately its this last final vote that decides wether a bill becomes law, not the votes at the earlier stages. Votes at previous stages only have consequence on amendments and changes to it as it progresses, so these initial votes only really matter to the contents of the bill and not the final decision as to it becoming law or not.
What many people don’t realise, is that voting against a bill at the early stages, means that you rule yourself out of the process of tabling amendments, allowing the Tories to dicate all the terms of the deal. This is of course OK if the bill is dreadful and you don’t think there’s any way you can make it better under any circumstances. Then you may as well do this.
In the context of the fact that 52% of the country voted to leave the EU, it would appear massively undemocratic for labour to vote themselves out of the process at this stage.
If Labour try to kill this bill now, it not only sends a message to the 52%, but it allows the Daily Mail to write some interesting headlines about Corbyn being an unprincipled establishment stooge or something. So I think its prudent to allow the bill to progress to its final vote offering amendments and shaping it.
If the Tories vote Labour’s amendments down, the things that protect the NHS and workers rights etc, it’s easier to explain to working class leavers (who I believe have been duped by Boris, Gove and Farage) what leaving the EU under the tories actually means. At the final stage, it will be in black and white what a Tory brexit means. If it’s turns out to be the incredibly ropy deal I think it will be, you can vote against it at the final stage, with JUSTIFICATION to leavers, that the Tory’s are using Brexit to hurt their rights and their NHS.
Strategically it makes sense to vote this through so the that there is enough rope for the Tories to hang themselves with. They are desperate not to publically reveal the method and means of brexit for a reason. To an extent this forces a few key points of the deal and could play a part in the Tories undoing.
So it makes you wonder about the motives of those in the shadow cabinet (who you have to assume DO understand parliamentary process) who are resigning over this.
I could talk further about what I think happens next, but that would give the game away…”