Exiting prostitution: erase criminal records
Remove barriers for women exiting prostitution and trying to build a new life.
Why we are supporting the call for the erasure of prostitution–specific criminal records for those who have been prostituted.
Wherever you stand on the prostitution debate, one shared ground is that those selling themselves or being sold for sex should not be criminalised and their records should not be disclosed.
Criminal records are widely recognised to be a bar to the reintegration of those affected by the criminal justice system.
However, prostitution-specific records are an additional set of barriers for women exiting prostitution and trying to build a new life.
Not only to they have to account for the years they spent as prostitutes at interviews or when talking to colleagues, they may also have criminal records from that time period.
Nia, a London-based charity supporting women, girls and children who have suffered sexual and domestic violence, has published a report looking into the call for the erasure of prostitution–specific criminal records for those who have been prostituted.
This report, ‘I’m no criminal’ Examining the impact of prostitution-specific criminal records on women seeking to exit prostitution’, arose out of an earlier research project conducted jointly by Eaves and London South Bank University which examined women’s experiences in prostitution and, specifically, their experiences in trying to exit prostitution.
That research found there were nine common barriers to exit, one of which was criminal records.
In the course of that research, the team found that here was a considerable body of evidence that examined the limiting impact of criminal records on the rehabilitation and reintegration of ex-offenders generally but little which examined the impact of prostitution-specific records on women’s experiences of building a new life.
And so the team made a more detailed study of this effect.
This report presents the findings of that research and argues that prostitution-specific criminal records are uniquely discriminatory, arbitrary, irrational and disproportionate for women involved, or formerly involved, in prostitution.
The women interviewed expressed relative equanimity about the disclosure of other offences that may have arisen as part of a life in prostitution, such as drug offences, theft, shoplifting and anti-social behaviour.
They were extremely anxious, however, that their prostitution-specific records should not be disclosed – indeed to such an extent that the prospect of disclosure was enough to deter women from even applying for education courses or employment, irrespective of how an institution or employer might respond to such records.
If women cannot exit prostitution and build viable alternatives, they are condemned to remain in it – and at risk of continued and increased criminalisation.
Which makes the effect of prostitution-specific criminal records uniquely discriminatory and disproportionate to women who are, or were formerly, involved.
It is also irrational and runs counter to government policy which states that it seeks to facilitate the rehabilitation of offenders, reduce re-offending and specifically reduce the number of women in custody.
If it is accepted that prostitution is a form of exploitation, discrimination and violence, and that much of prostitution could fall within a definition of trafficking, then the current policy may be in breach of international human rights standards – agreements which the UK has ratified.
The findings move on to examine the interlinkages between prostitution offences and other offences, and the way in which the criminal record barrier intersects with other barriers to exiting.
These barriers exacerbate and reinforce each other, entrenching women in both the criminal justice system and in prostitution.
Among the women participating in the research, there was agreement that women selling or being sold for sex should not be criminalised, their records should not be disclosed, and that there were high levels of abuse and distress involved in many women’s routes into prostitution.
One woman said: “It’s not right, it’s unfair.”
Another said: “Most women in prostitution aren’t there because they want to be, for a start.
“They are there because they need to be for like financial reasons, drug or alcohol, or someone’s making them do it…
“I just feel like, once again, we are being punished…”











