Women ‘making it to Cambridge by mistake’
A senior Cambridge University academic thinks that young women are so sexualised and image-conscious that they lack intellectual confidence and is blaming the ‘ladette culture’ for its emphasis on looks and the way it frowns on educational achievement.
Dame Patricia Hodgson, treat no rx principal of all-girls Newnham College, told a conference that girls believe that they are less intelligent than boys and thinks that women are now less confident and less capable of seizing equal opportunities than they were 40 years ago.
Speaking at the Girls’ Schools Association annual conference, in Manchester, she said: ‘Young women may now assume that equal pay is assured and that they can balance life and work on a pretty level playing field. But at Newnham young women strike me as less confident than we had been 40 years ago…they may be streetwise but they are not intellectually confident. One does wonder if the equal opportunity which we have been led to believe is there, is really there.’
Dame Patricia said a number of students approached her during this year’s Freshers’ Week to say they thought they ‘had made it to Cambridge by mistake’, and thinks that the problem might lie in today’s celebrity culture.
‘From their early teens on, girls suffer from a culture that judges them on their looks. For young girls in a mixed environment it’s looks alone that determine the pecking order; academic achievement is frowned upon. But academic achievement is something that will remain with them for ever.’
Dame Patricia, who was a founding member of the distance learning team at Open University, said young women lacked good role models. She cited as an example a recent survey to determine the future 100 most powerful women.
‘It only included seven or eight senior businesswomen and a handful of academics and politicians,’ she said. ‘The overwhelming majority were fashion models and celebrities.’
She told the conference that the solution was to give young women positive role models and teach them confidence in an environment free from Facebook and X Factor.
Quite.
Read the full story in the Mail.
















This title is disingenuous. Hodgson did not claim that women are “making it to Cambridge by mistake”; rather, she has had this reported to her from first year female students who are, for a variety of reasons, feeling overwhelmed by their experiences. (I went to Oxford so I know what that feeling is all about.)
Stating the title as it is here is giving a very different message about women and their “place” in Oxbridge.
Hi tenderhooligan
Ah – I used the title because I completely understand the feeling of being overwhelmed – I was a mature student, and felt I had somehow ‘arrived’ there, rather than recognised that I deserved to be there. Maybe the title is too subtle, and therefore could be misread?
Hi Jane
I think the title is anything but subtle, but it is very misleading. My first thought on reading it was that your/ a point was that women should not be going to Cambridge, which is not the point of this piece or the Mail’s article (and far be it from me to defend the Mail).
Not sure if it’s helpful for me to wade in here, but I just wanted to say that I understood the title as ironic. That somehow women did feel they were at Cambridge “by mistake”. When I read that the principal had been told this by girls themselves, I thought it all made sense. The worrying thing of course is that they do feel they’re there “by mistake” and don’t have the confidence they should have in their intellectual abilities. Or have I misunderstood the story?
No, you haven’t misunderstood the story Alison (and it is concerning that women feel that way about Cambridge) but, as I said to Jane below, I was worried that internet readers (who often only read titles and first paragraphs) may have been getting the wrong impression from the title. I should, arguably, have made that clearer. I also should be paying more attention to my grammar in these comments and should not be using so many parentheses in one sentence!
Annie
Ah I see your point now. As Jane said, we’re writing with a particular audience in mind and expect/hope they’re not taken out of context. However, food for thought and I’ll take this onboard with my own headline writing.
Yes, and re-reading the story I should have put the quote re ‘being there by mistake’ in the first paragraph and hung everything on that. Perhaps not enough coffee for me either 🙂
Hi tenderhooligan
In no universe would I ever make a point that women should not be going to Cambridge as I am sure you accept; but I do also accept that taken out of context, the headline could be misconstrued.
However, when I am writing I do so with my audience in mind, which in this case will be people who believe in equality for all and I would therefore not expect WVON headlines and/or stories to be taken out of context, or indeed in this case, read too literally.
Whereas if I was writing for the Daily Mail (again, not in this universe) I would NEVER use such a headline for the very reasons you point out.
Hi Jane
Indeed, knew that we were likely to be on the same page in any case. My concern came about from knowing that Internet readers (and I’m guilty of this myself) very often read only the title and the first paragraph (if even) of a piece before they decide what it’s about. As such, I worried what could be concluded from the title of this piece and the kind of message that might be taken away. I absolutely know that that’s not a point you would ever try to make.
Annie
Alison, I should have been clearer. I’m blaming not enough coffee and having to clean a unkempt house this morning! 🙂
Aside from the debate over the merits of the headline, it’s a really important point that Patricia Hodgson is making, and something that definitely chimed with my experience of university. I’m a graduate of Nottingham and York, but even in those ‘lesser’ universities (it’s annoying how many articles focus on Oxbridge, oh well) there’s a marked difference in the way that women and men behave in seminars. I found that male students tended to dominate the conversation in a way that women rarely did when in a mixed group – annoying for both men and women, in that women are expected to wait their turn, but also, can get away with contributing a lot less. It seems that even in universities, women moderate their behaviour to defer to men in the same way that we’ve always done. Not me though, self-confessed bigmouth here!
This also seems like a good place to mention a comment made by a female student in one of the last lectures of my undergrad. In a discussion about how university had changed us, I said that encountering feminist ideas had changed my identity, specifically how I refer to myself – I’ll always be a ‘Ms’ now. A girl responded, saying that all the feminist writing that had been ‘forced’ on her made her determined to not be a feminist. Even my lecturer – not entirely exempt from the charge of misogyny, or at least criminal forgetfulness, for setting us a reading list entirely made up of the works of white men – was left bashing his head against the desk.
In my experience Hannah most young women position themselves against feminism because they buy into the hairy armpit, dungaree wearing strident female image perpetuated by the (white male) media. However, they soon change their minds if they have children. Then they realise just how marginalised they are when they are mothers with little money and can’t actually go anywhere with a baby because even getting on the bus or in and out of shops is a nightmare, then there is all the shopping, cooking, washing up and hang on a minute – how did this happen? Even if they go back to a well-paid job they end up running around doing everything for everybody and suddenly feminism begins to make a whole lot of sense.