Redressing the historic absence of women scientists
During the 350th anniversary year of the Royal Society, Richard Holmes has investigated the glaring absence of historical women members, as reported in yesterday’s Observer.
Looking through the archives, Holmes discovered that there was a much broader relationship between women and the Royal Society than first expected. So much so, that he proposes the need for a revision of history.
In Victorian Britain, the size of the female brain was considered to be a barrier to the possibility of growth in both stature and knowledge, as it was thought too small to cope with maths and science (interestingly an echo of this pernicious idea still seems to exist today in some biologically deterministic thought).
Women were permitted to study the sciences of botany and geology but little else. However, those who studied botany were considered to be walking on morally perilous ground as an element of the discipline was the naming of sexual parts.
In a paragraph of the article which deserves to be quoted in full, Holmes cites a letter between Thomas Henry Huxley (known as ‘Darwin’s Bulldog’) and the geologist Charles Lyell (both fellows of the society) in which Huxley wrote: “Five-sixths of women will stop in the doll stage of evolution, to be the stronghold of parsonism, the drag on civilisation, the degradation of every important pursuit in which they mix themselves – intrigues in politics and friponnes in science.”
This excerpt is paramount in illustrating the contempt in which women were held by the scientific establishment.
This considered, the light cast on the archives by Holmes has revealed that women often worked as colleagues and assistants in investigations (although only acknowledged as wives, sisters or daughters).
Most importantly, it was women more so than their male counterparts, who were able to imagine the human impact of scientific discovery by exploring and questioning it.
Perhaps then it is not surprising that what is considered to be the first ever science fiction story was written by a woman – The blazing world (1666) by Margaret Cavendish – a work which resulted in the nickname ‘Mad Madge’.
There is more than just a hint of feminism within women writing science fiction. By exploring worlds from different perspectives, where what is othered, uncanny or seemingly impossible in reality is posited as reality in fictitious worlds, we are able to imagine possibilities in quantum. This is a reflexive and empowering political exercise.
From this first work of science fiction we can leap over to Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein (1818) which was praised for raising the question of responsible scientific practice. The term ‘Frankenstein’s monster’ is still used today as a potential warning against any scientific endeavour which is thought to hold a threat within itself.
The importance of science fiction cannot be overstated. Holmes’ focus of the article is not only on literature but on other theoretical and practical work which had huge, fundamental impact.
Caroline Herschel (1750-1848) for example, was an astronomer who discovered several comets, Ada Lovelace (1815-1852), a mathematician who, arguably, began developing the first computer programme and Mary Somerville (1780-1872), who translated physics texts into accessible works.
These contributions to science are, at best, critically downplayed if not outright disregarded. These are just three out of many.
I urge you to read the article in full (here) as my paraphrasing does not do justice to the remarkable efforts and achievements of the women who have been kept in their place, relegated to a relationship status in the archives of the Royal Society.
Needless to say I am immensely looking forward to Holmes’ forthcoming book on this subject, to be entitled The lost women of Victorian science. It is high time the brilliance of the women Holmes writes about is fully appreciated and that scientific history is appropriately righted.











