subscribe: Posts | Comments

Woman escapes prison for falsely retracting rape allegation with a criminal record and community sentence

1 comment

The most senior judge in England and Wales today freed a mother who had been jailed for retracting “truthful” allegations that she had been raped by her husband (see earlier WVoN story).

Overturning her eight-month sentence, Lord Judge, the lord chief justice, criticised the Crown Prosecution Service’s decision to prosecute the 28-year-old woman, who he accepted had been the victim of prolonged domestic abuse and been put under pressure by her husband to withdraw the allegations.

Judge said there should be “a broad measure of compassion for a woman who had already been victimised”.

It was, he said, “an extreme case” which he hoped would not be repeated. “We hope that it will be very exceptional for cases of this kind to be prosecuted to conviction in the crown court,” said Judge, who was sitting in London with Mr Justice Calvert-Smith and Mr Justice Griffith Williams.

The appeal judges ruled that the “appropriate” sentence was a community sentence with a two-year supervision order, and ordered her immediate release from Styal prison in Manchester.

After being released from jail, the woman now faces a battle over custody for her children from her estranged husband.

“The system has failed her and she knows it,” the woman’s older sister told the Guardian. “She is devastated. She can’t believe it ended this way.”

Campaigners described the ruling as a “turning point” but said it was wrong that the victim was the one left with a criminal record while her husband walked free.

To read the full story go to the Guardian.

  1. I cannot believe that in a society that is geared towards liberty and justice for all and we still cant bare to treat women with the same compassion and care as everyone else! It would take a child to tell you that the rapist should be locked away not the victim, plain and simple. I cannot believe that with intellectuals and judges who have been within the law for years and have completed degrees so on and so forth, that we still cannot do the just thing as a society.
    I am sure that yes, there are cases in which a woman my accuse a man of rape when in fact he didn’t do so, but in the MINORITY. Perverting the court of justice is much more complex in the case of emotional and physical abuse towards another person. They are driven to these things because of fear, desparation and abuse, not because they are nasty women! As a young 15 year old girl in society being able to plainly see all of this, it shocks and greatly appalls me that such highly educated people cannot.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *