We are fighting for your children, we are fighting for your jobs
Laurie Penny reports on her experience of Thursday’s demonstration in London against rising tuition fees over at the New Statesman.
“They came to protest against the tuition fees bill that was hauled through the house yesterday by a fractured and divided coalition government.
“They believe that parliamentary democracy has failed them, that the state has set its face against them. When they arrived at Parliament Square, they found themselves facing a solid wall of metal cages guarded by armed police.
“Then the crackdown began, and it was worse than we feared. As I write, a young man called Alfie is in hospital after a police beating which left him bleeding into his brain, and all the press can talk about is the fact that a middle-aged couple – one of whom happens to be the heir to the throne – escaped entirely uninjured from some minor damage done to their motorcade.
“The government will no doubt be able to find the money to repair the Royal Rolls Royce, but yesterday it declared itself unable to afford to repair the damage done to these young people’s future.”
I’ve already learned, as Laurie has from her own comments box, that public opinion is incredibly divided about the events that unfolded on our TV screens last Thursday.
Yesterday, I aroused a room of otherwise reasonable people into outraged shouting when I expressed support for the students – and those were just some of my friends…
But I do support the students, and the schoolchildren, and the lecturers, teachers, parents and members of the public who attended the demonstration.
I don’t condone or support violence – from demonstrators or from the police, who are tasked with “the protection of life and property”, in that order.
It is often hard for us to view our own governments, our police, or events like Thursday’s march from the outside.
On Thursday, CNN was reporting the march as a demonstration in London, during which there were ‘violent clashes on both sides’ – albeit with some bemusement as to why paying for education is seen as so controversial. It is important to recognise that there was violence on both sides, regardless of whether or not you agree with the rise in tuition fees.
In protests, as elsewhere in life, there is always an imbalance of power between demonstrators and the police.
Police violence – like kettling, or like charging on horseback into a crowd of civilians – can always be justified by the police on the grounds of necessary policy for controlling an unruly crowd.
There is no such justification for violence from protesters, protesters who may be reacting out of a combination of fury and fear.
But the real human face of such confrontations between state and governed population is more complex. Interactions between police and demonstrators, taking place as they do in a context of loud shouting, chanting and other obvious signs of political and social anger, can lead police to feel threatened.
Defensive actions they take as a result inflame the crowd, violence begins to unfold, and once begun, cannot easily be stopped.
I don’t have answers to preventing the violent clashes we saw on Thursday. The protests will continue and the police will be at every one.
What I think is important is that we begin to ask the right questions about the violence that we saw on Thursday: to ask how such scenarios happen and how they can be prevented.
A generation who has not protested before is taking to the streets, armed with anger, outrage and the desire to change their world. I am proud to stand with them, but I will not raise my fists on their behalf.
I think we also each need to think about our own anger, our own inner violence, because this inner fury is the real cause of Thursday’s violence.
There is a certain irony in finding yourself at the wrong end of a roomful of people expressing their contempt at student violence by shouting, furious gesticulation, swearing and making threats, which is what I saw yesterday in a roomful of friends.
As part of a move towards truly democratic protests, I think the protesting left needs to begin to discuss the mechanics and power of peaceful protest as a leading priority in their actions.
For me, this isn’t just about preventing violence, but also about creating more effective protests.
In the meantime – although I think this is probably less likely after watching the shameful analysis of Thursday’s events delivered by Supt Julia Pendry of the Met – I think the police need to radically rethink their current policy of extreme defensiveness in dealing with protesters – particularly when those protesters are also fighting for the jobs and the children of police officers.
Alison Clarke added:
By way of underpinning what Sarah has written above, read this disturbing account on the BBC website of a young woman’s experience on the demo.
















Scenes reminiscent of the miner’s strike in 1984: I was a trade union rep at the time and was exposed to the conventional media reports and also the miner’s media reports and the gap between both narratives was glaringly obvious. I find it sad that conventional media reporting has not changed – despite decades of education that has produced graduates who work in the media, the ‘establishment good/ protestors bad’ discourse is still alive and kicking.
Also to address Sarah’s point about her friends’ reactions: during the miner’s strike I was tasked with collecting for the miner’s wives and children who were slowly starving and was shocked as the ferocity of the refusal to give from colleagues that, up until that time, I had liked.
I can honestly say that that strike was the beginning of my political and media education and i suspect this will be true of the student protestors. The government needs to beware – pissing of the potential future leaders of the country is not a good idea at all. However, it may be the best thing that has ever happened to this ‘the market rules’ economy: finally things may change as a result of the experiences of these students.
Thanks Jane. It’s been a real eye opener to me that so many of my friends, who seem so liberal in other ways, are really right wing in their viewpoint on this and, I’m discovering, other political issues. It’s a real challenge to me though, to engage with how to grow and maintain a dialogue with viewpoints I find myself disagreeing with so entirely!
You’re certainly not the only person I’ve met recently who has made the comparison between the current situation and the miners’ strikes of the 80’s. I was at the recent Coalition of Resistance meeting in London and just caught Tony Benn’s speech – he was saying exactly the same thing.