Kanye West is not a monster, he’s just a very boring boy
Hip hop and misogyny have a long lasting relationship and it’s just been brought up-to-date by American rapper Kanye West in his new video ‘Monster’.
There’s an online petition against the official release of the video, but you can already watch the pointless piece of trash (yes, I mean Kanye West) online if you’re interested in seeing gratituous images of dead women in your spare time.
At this point, I feel as though I should give you the pleasure of a pithy critique of why this video is so inappropriate and offensive to women.
How it contributes to a pop culture that is not only taking women’s freedom back a few decades, but is normalising ever increasing levels of violence, particularly sexual violence, towards women.
How this is particularly affecting our young women and girls, because they, and the young men who will grow up to abuse them, are the primary intended audiences for this track.
But I can’t help but feel the video itself is doing a better job of that than I ever could. And besides, you know it already.
The bottom line for me as I watch the video is that I simply don’t get it. At all. Any of it. I don’t even understand the lyrics, and I looked them up especially.
The fact is that the lyrics, like the video, just don’t make any sense, including, as they do such priceless lyrical gems as:
Have you ever had a sex with a pharoah?
Er, no, I was under the impression the Pharoahs died out along with the ancient Egyptians. Kanye, are you feeling ok?
I put the pussy in a sarcophagus
You put a cat in a coffin? Does this have anything to do with the Pharoah sex thing, or was that a rhetorical question?
Now she claiming I bruise her esophagus
Kanye, I can’t help thinking that all that talk about ancient Egyptians was really just a clumsy segueway into making a blowjob reference.
Head of the class and she just want a swallowship
Yes, I see what you did there. That’s very clever Kanye. You made ‘swallowship’ another reference to blowjobs, just in case we didn’t get the first one. Genius, Kanye, really, er, genius. Shouldn’t you be out building treehouses with the other boys?
I could go on, but what’s the point? The video was leaked late last month and has had good reviews from the Rolling Stone, which, along with other reviewers, compares the video to Michael Jackson’s ‘Thriller’.
We’re a long way down a dark road where these types of imagery are becoming commonplace. The proliferation and increasing violence of freely available online porn has been covered on WVoN many times before.
So has the accompanying movement of what used to be considered hardcore images like those in KW’s video into our popular culture – via our female artists, as much as our male artists.
And you can protest, sign the petition, make your disapproval clear. It sends a message to Universal that not everyone thinks a video needs a corpse to be edgy. But pay this kind of crap too much attention and maybe we’re edging too close to acting as Kanye’s publicist.
And maybe getting angry is giving this song, this artist, this genre too much power, too much of our time, time we could be devoting to changing the lives of women whose lives are affected by issues more serious than what they are being asked to play in a rap video.
As comedian Bill Hicks (himself a long way from a feminist) once said about the controversy over Basic Instinct:
“Quick capsule review: Piece of Shit. Don’t get caught up in that fevered hype phoney debate…Take a deep breath…look at it again..
‘Oh, it’s a Piece of Shit.’
Exactly. That’s all it is….Walk away.”
Or, signpost people to an alternative take on ‘Monster’, one that isn’t offensive to women. Who gets upset at the Muppets?
















Problem is, you can’t always walk away from the deranged boys that are viewing this and thinking this is the cool way of treating women – 1 in 2 girls in the UK are raped and I think the time for walking away is way done – the only way of dealing with bullies is to stand up to them, not walk away. Otherwise they just take that space that you have walked away from and then come right on after to you to take that space too. Walking away has given us lads mags, internet gonzo porn, 1 in 3 women beaten up by their partners, 1 in 2 raped … higher attempted suicide rates than men, twice the mental health issues than men, 90% more eating disorders – I don’t think where we have walked to is any good for us, it feels like a sewer to me …!
Thanks Vicki.
I can’t disagree with what you’re saying about the impact of current pop culture as reflected by these videos. The deranged boys you refer to are being created as they consume these images,and the rise of violence in images of women is something I think all of us here at WVoN oppose.
I’d be interested in hearing how you would, or do, respond to the Kanye West video in light of your comments. Do you think there’s a danger of us publicising the very images we oppose, of drawing more people to them when we really would prefer people not to be looking?
My point in the article is really centred on the fact that the video is pointless. It’s gratuitous violence for its own sake – and that’s all it is. There’s no artistic merit here, there’s no theme, no point. It seeks to draw controversy and I think it implicitly – and maybe consciously, or not – invites the feminist movement to assist in creating a media furore. I think the ‘leaking’ of the video could even be part of that deliberate publicity campaign.
I can’t help but feel that as well as highlighting – as I do in the article – the damage these sorts of representations do, we have to call Kanye West and his video out for what it is – a piece of shit. I wonder if we explicitly and implicitly express more power when we do that.
But that’s just my two cents, and I’m always happy to hear your views! Thanks again.
I think too many people that might oppose this type of hate violence either look away or aren’t even aware of it as they don’t look at what their sons are looking at etc. The more we can publicise this and our objection to it the more we put it into the public arena for debate. What I think we should do is join and financially support every women’s group objecting to this material, lobby our MPs, write letters counteracting violent chauvinist material, complain to supermarkets, complain at dinner parties and start challenging people to start joining up the dots between media violence towards women and male violence towards women. Monkey see monkey do is not a feminist concept and if ethnic minorities are protected against media incited violence then so should women be.