‘Sleepwalking’ man cleared of raping teenage girl – Scotland
Summary of story – The Scotsman 15.1.11
We at WVoN aim to post ‘recent’ news, normally within 24 hours of reporting. On rare occasions we make an exception to post news a few days old.
The following story is not only shocking, but very worrying in relation to progress being made (or not) on rape convictions.
James Thomas who admitted having non-consensual sex with a teenage girl has walked free from court in Scotland after arguing he was sleepwalking at the time.
Campaigners last night warned that the not proven verdict handed down to him could open the floodgates for similar defences in future.
Support group Rape Crisis Scotland said the case would set a dangerous precedent and drive down Scotland’s already low rape conviction rate.
Speaking outside the court, the teenager’s furious mother described the verdict as “ridiculous”, saying it would give people a licence to commit crime.
Thomas had suffered episodes of “parasomnia” since childhood, the High Court in Edinburgh heard.
He said he had not been awake and in control of his actions when he had intercourse with the girl after drinking at the party.
The victim maintained Thomas had known what he was doing, but a jury returned a majority not proven verdict on the charge of rape.
The incident took place on 3 October 2009 at a flat in Balerno, on the outskirts of Edinburgh.
Thank you Rape Crisis Scotland and @CathElliott for bringing this story to our attention.
















I can’t believe this verdict – has the world gone mad???
Hi Lesley,
My heart went out to the victim and her family – putting her through a court case with this verdict as the end result! Yes, I think sometimes the world has gone mad.
The world has lost its ability to critically analyse men’s actions towards women is what it is – I remember another guy got away with this defence a couple of years ago – I wonder if they’d accept a man robbing a bank and then saying he was sleep walking … or stealing from a shop … or breaking and entering … must remember my pyjamas next time I’m planning on seriously assaulting someone.