subscribe: Posts | Comments

16-year old girl convicted of false rape allegation

29 comments

Summary of story from The Guardian, 25.1.11.

A 16-year old girl has been convicted of attempting to pervert the course of justice for making a false rape allegation when she was 15-years old.

The girl, who cannot be named for legal reasons, told police that a 14-year old boy had raped her in his bedroom. In her account, she said that she ‘froze’ and did not call out to friends.

After a three day trial at Cheltenham youth court, a judge ruled that consensual sex had taken place and that the girl had lied to police and court. She will be sentenced next month.

The prosecution, led by Julian Kesner, argued that the girl’s account was ‘riddled with lies’ and should not be believed because it had changed.

Kesner added that the girl and boy were seen holding hands the day after the alleged rape.

The judge’s verdict has been criticised by Lisa Longstaff, of the group Women Against Rape. ‘It is awful that a girl so young has been prosecuted in this way’, she said.

While false allegations can cause a great deal of damage to the lives of the accused and to their communities, there are elements of the prosecution in this case that stand out as suspicious.

The prosecution’s claim that consent must have been given, because the two were seen holding hands the next day, betrays a simplistic understanding of human behaviour. It assumes that rape cannot happen within a relationship and that women do not return to their abusers.

What is more, even if there was a passive sort of consent involved, it is hardly of the ‘enthusiastic’ sort advocated by sex-positive feminists such as Heather Corinna.

The outcome of this case sits worryingly with other stories about rape that have attracted attention over recent months, including the conviction of a 28-year old woman for similar allegations, and the Government’s proposal (now abandoned) to grant anonymity to rape defendants.

Such examples give the impression that to allege rape is worse than to commit it.

It hardly needs pointing out that this is a dangerous message to send about a crime that is still vastly underreported, and painfully under-convicted.

  1. I can’t believe people are siding with the young woman in this case. If her lie had been believed like she intended, this kid would have been tried as an adult, sent to jail and probably would have gotten raped himself. The girl in this case was actually 15, and the boy was 16. He would have been branded as a sexual predator for the rest of his life, having to tell his neighbors wherever he lived. He would have to note it on every job application he ever filled out. He would have lost his right to vote. She tried to destroy this 16 year old kid’s life with a vicious lie, and you think it’s “awful” that she is punished for it? Shame on you.

    • Hi Kyle, thanks for your comment.

      With regard to your point about the ages of the girl and boy: these were taken from The Guardian and confirmed in the Mail. If you have reason to believe this reporting is incorrect then I’m sure these papers would be keen to hear from you.

      I considered this story very carefully before posting because, as you say, a false rape allegation is not something to be taken lightly. Neither, of course, is rape – but this is what I concluded that the judge’s decision appeared to be doing in this case.

      Not having been in the courtroom – or indeed, the bedroom – we’re limited in what we can say about this specific conviction. In this article I chose to highlight some aspects of the prosecution that I felt were flimsy and based on outdated views about human motivation. I also noted the connection between this case and a general trend for women to be disbelieved when reporting rape.

      In a country where only 6% of reported rapes end in a conviction and most rapes are never reported, the tendency for women (and men) reporting rape to be met with increasing amounts of scepticism is very worrying. I don’t want to turn this into a game of victim oneupmanship, but it’s worth considering the numbers of people whose lives are affected in the ways you describe by false allegations, against the number of people whose lives have been devastated by rape. I think you’ll find the latter vastly outweighs the former, and this needs to be in our minds when we look at a case like this that is likely to put people (especially vulnerable young women) off reporting this crime.

      You seem to suggest that conviction of one or the other party in this case was the only option. I disagree – I don’t believe that the only way to protect the falsely accused is to bring charges against their accusers that may even lead to their imprisonment (as nearly happened in the case of the 28-year old Welsh woman that I mentioned in the article). I think what this case highlights is yet more serious problems in the way the British legal system handles rape.

      • False accusations of rape are one of the most heinous crimes that can be committed. If this is what the woman in question did, and it was proven in court, lock her up and throw away the key. She is a danger to civil society.

        • Er, I really don’t think ‘falsely’ accusing someone of rape is one the most heinous crimes that can be committed, it’s actually quite ridiculous that you think that.
          Just because an accusation doesn’t end up in a conviction does not necessarily mean that the accuser was lying.

        • Personally I would argue that rape is a far more heinous crime. It is troubling that there would be such a harsh response to a reportedly false allegation when so many genuine allegations of rape are taken so lightly by the judicial system.

      • I completely agree with Martha. Does it not occur to the rape crisis people that it is false allegations of rape that are primarily (although not exclusively) responsible for trivialising a serious crime? And the comment that we should be mindful of the fact that far fewer people are “affected by false allegations of rape” than those whose “lives have been devastated by rape” is simply absurd. As though that could ever be any consolation to those men whose lives and reputations are ruined by false allegations.

        • Jane has it right and I thank her. The others need to wake up, grow up and take a clearer view of the realities of sexual violence and realize that false accusations are their own acts of violence. At some point, you are either against sexual violence of all kinds or you are not. Trivializing the very real problem of false accusations only cheapens all acts of violence, cavalierly negates human rights, and puts all people at further risk.

          Chances are excellent that the young woman in question will re-offend. These types of people are often not curable, or even treatable. If anyone really cared about this woman, and did not want to simply excuse her or make apologies for her, they would see to it that she was engaged by professionals in a very thorough manner, perhaps through institutionalization. Unfortunately, the justice system seems unwilling to confront her, which puts everyone who encounters her, men and women alike, at risk, of false accusations of various kinds and other sorts of manipulative, self-centered, violent behaviors that show a complete lack of concern, or even awareness of the value and worth of the lives of other people, and absolutely no sense of values or conscience. Sadly, such people are all about us — rape and false accusations of rape are among the manifestations of their presence. Let’s stop being so tolerant of them.

          • “…false accusations are their own acts of violence. At some point, you are either against sexual violence of all kinds or you are not.”

            I may have misunderstood your point here, because I can’t make any sense of it. You seem to be conflating the genuine and serious issue of false accusations with sexual violence. Whatever your opinion on false accusations of rape, and in whatever way they may lead to cheapening human rights, I would use your own term and suggest that you are being very cavalier to say that an accusation of rape is a sexually violent act. False accusations and rape are both traumatic experiences and to assume that they are the same thing is to belittle the victims of both.

            No one here is seeking to trivialise false accusations. This website aims to report the stories that affect and are about women. In the mainstream media I am frequently surprised my how many “cry rape” stories I read, compared to stories about rape convictions. Other commenter have excellently pointed out the statistics, so I won’t repeat myself here.

            You also say that “chances are excellent that the woman will re-offend.” That’s a bold statement to make without offering any evidence other than your opinion she is beyond help and an entrenched liar. I work in the Criminal Justice sector and I can assure you that a far higher percentage of women rehabilitate and reform when they come into contact with the criminal system, than men do.

          • vicki wharton says:

            And further to Sarah’s comment I would say that as Martha is a counsellor , I find it strange that someone in the business of helping people to actively change their way of relating to and being in the world, has such a low opinion of this young woman’s ability to change – that seems to me a very prejudiced view that flies in direct opposition to the career you’ve chosen.

  2. vicki wharton says:

    According to the Home Office, around 3 – 9% of reports of rape are malicious which works out at best as 1200. Couldn’t find the number of these that went on to be prosecuted and convicted. The number of rapes in the UK from the HO is estimated at 100,000, of which 600 were convicted. That leaves 99,400 rapists unconvicted, as opposed to ? many victims of false allegations of rape. Whichever way you play the numbers, it appears way more men are lying when it comes to rape than women. Whilst I wouldn’t defend any person that makes a false allegation of rape, many very young victims withdraw allegations when they start being questioned when they realise the weight of prejudice they are up against from both legal council, the police and social services. I have been a victim of gender violence as a women of 44 and had to really fight my corner with all of the above against their prejudice and wish to make me responsible for the crime against me. It was only the fact that the physical evidence didn’t fit the man’s version that showed finally that I was telling the truth … and I had to point this out to the police as they didn’t seem to want to notice this. A 15 year old would be unlikely to challenge a uniformed police officer on sceptical questioning.

  3. Jane Osmond says:

    You know Jane and Martha I might take your points more seriously if you had been on our boards everyday being equally as appalled at the numerous rapes, sexual assaults and abuses of women that we at WVON fall over every day when looking for women in the news.

    • Sound like you are grasping at any chance to keep from taking us seriously.

      I would treat your views with more respect if you were appalled at all sexual violence, not just that which serves your interests.

      I have counseled rape victims and people who have been falsely accused, just came upon this website and am struck at the level of ignorance and self-righteousness. Don’t act like you are the only ones concerned with victim’s rights, and broaden your minds to see the complexities of the issues, the abundance of victim’s off all kinds, and the need to stand firm against sexual violence however, whenever and against whomever it occurs.

      • Martha,

        I can totally understand your point about false rape reporting – it is serious. No one here is disputing that in anyway – please let’s be clear about that. Women that report rape on false grounds do a massive injustice to the real victims of rape, as well as the ‘accused rapist’.

        Rape is also very serious and destroys lives. The figures quoted by Vikki are shocking. Every day we report on rape and violence towards women. Normally their deaths by a man they knew. On average 2 woman a week in the UK are killed by their partners or someone they know. Most rapes are carried out by someone the victims know. Most rapes go unreported and men walk free.

        The aim of our website is to voice the stories of women, and the bigger question (for me personally) is why would any 16 year old girl put themselves through a court case and claim they were raped by someone they knew? Why? What if the girl in question here was telling the truth? I am not saying she was, but just posing the question.

        Your comments (from someone who is claiming they counsel rape victims) “If this is what the woman in question did, and it was proven in court, lock her up and throw away the key. She is a danger to civil society”. I do find that very harsh and OTT. The girl in question is 16 years of age. Have you ever witnessed the way a court cross examines rape victims? Because I have, and let me tell I don’t know how any young teenage girl could cope with that and even put themselves through it. Not to mention the preparation of a court case, which can take months.

        To highlight the sort of stories we regularly report on, may I bring to to your attention a story posted last week – Sleepwalking’ man cleared of raping teenage girl – Scotland http://j.mp/eWF4LC I wonder how this victim and her family are feeling. There’s no key to throw away here.

        Please understand the work we do is vital to highlighting the lives and experiences of women around the world, and I can guarantee you that we are neither ‘ignorant or self-righteous’ as you suggested. I like to think that through all the stories posted daily we have a fair understanding of the complex circumstances around rape and sexual violence. I hope we are sensitive and considerate to the angle we take on the stories, especially rape, and the outcome of any trial.

      • vicki wharton says:

        Who is ‘us’ Martha? Are you really a counsellor? I have undergone four years of counselling training and wonder what kind of establishment has a client base of both rape victims and those that are falsely accused of rape? It would be hard to mix those two sets of people in a waiting room etc as you would have enormous conflict of interests and possible fights, trauma etc. As for false accusations, well, each time a man who has raped someone denies his actions, he is adding a second crime to his first, that of making the victim into a liar – with the attendant contempt and hatred that society (and apparently yourself) pour over the victim. I know, as I have been accused of making a false accusation of ‘abuse’ against my stepfather by his daughter and my brother simply because I chose to challenge my stepfather’s right to lie to and about my mother whom he hit numerous times. False accusations of all sorts of things happen all over the place – but being accused of making a false accusation of rape has meant the loss of nearly my entire family network whilst rape itself is now seen by most, due to its depiction in porn, as sexually titilating and exciting. We cannot make the world perfect, but we can try to address some of the largest injustices, and I still come back to the figures I quoted earlier on and think that in sexual and psychological violence, women are still coming off numerically, way worse than men.

        • Thanks for that, Vicki. I think what struck me about Martha’s comments was the level of anger she demonstrates. Just seems odd in someone who has counselled others.

          • vicki wharton says:

            Very odd indeed … and not in the interests of ‘her’ clients at all to have that level of unresolved anger around rape if that’s ‘her’ chosen field …

          • Yes, I think quite a few of us have been wondering about that for a while!

  4. Martha seems to have come in for a great deal of sniping here because she has put forward a valid view. May I say to her critics: don’t speculate about Martha’s motives, clients or “level of anger”. You reduce your own credibility by expressing yourselves in these terms, and it is, in turn, damaging to the interests of your own clients (and it cannot be assumed that they are preferable or better clients than Martha’s merely because they have been, or say they have been, raped). I am a lawyer. I do not work in criminal law, but I must make it absolutely clear to you that criminal trials are about fairness to both parties – the complainant and the accused. Numerous steps have been taken to protect the position of a woman who alleges rape. But you must remember that the person she accuses requires to be found guilty by a jury of his peers. Lack of consent is notoriously difficult to prove in the absence of injury or corroborative evidence as to the woman’s distress after the incident (consent is the usual defence even in the presence of these factors). The accused is entitled to the benefit of the doubt – which is to say that the jury must be satisfied beyond reasonable doubt that the accused did indeed have sexual intercourse with the complainant without her consent. I venture to suggest that this very high, but entirely proper, threshold, is why rape conviction rates are low. It is generally, almost by definition, a private crime. And I think it important to remember that juries are never all male. In fact in the one rape trial I did work on, when I was very new at the Bar, the jury was 75% female and they acquitted.

    • vicki wharton says:

      Non of us profess to have clients here so there is no oneupmanship about clients, nor are we sniping when we refer to Martha’s evident anger – it is apparent to all and not part of a counselling relationship – councellors have to undergo five years of personal therapy in order to separate, identify and deal with their own issues from that of their clients. A justice system that results in only 600 convictions for 100,000 rapes cannot by any means be deemed to be fair or even vaguely effective and prejudice against women that speak out about male violence is gender neutral – there are as many chauvinist women as there are men in the same way that there were a vast number of collaborators in France during Nazi occupation – it’s whats known as hunting with the hounds and is a protective defence in a patriarchal society. As for speculating about Martha’s motives, we weren’t, we were speculating on her gender – maybe you need to re read our comments as your lack of attention to detail is certainly reducing your own credibility and accuracy in my eyes.

    • I think, Jane, that you confuse “sniping” with disagreement. We simply disagree with the points Martha makes, are surprised at the anger that comes across in her posts and doubt whether she’s actually a woman at all. I would also take issue with your point about criminal trials being “about fairness to both parties”. It seems to me that they are nothing of the sort because they are not (and never have been) geared to finding out the truth. Instead they are about sticking to a set of rules that are now completely outdated (assuming they were ever of any use). And the fact that cross-examining barristers can harass and intimidate defendants is no credit to our system either. The reason for the low conviction of rape accusations are many and varied, but the rules of the criminal justice system certainly do not help.

      • Sorry, I wanted to add one point, as well as apologizing for the typos in my last post, done in some haste. Alison, I am trying not to be harsh with you, as I gather that is not the dynamic of this site, and I’m all for civility, but your views on the legal system are …. extreme. The law and the rules and dynamics of legal proceedings are one of the central legacies of human civilization; they are part of what has defined us as thinking people with a sense of reason and fairness. To say that the law has served no one, is outdated, etc., is foolish and rash. Adjustments are certainly needed, as to all things, but what is preferable to law in settling disputes that cannot be mediated in other ways (often due to the all-too-human stubbornness of the parties) and how else to decide in a fair manner when someone has truly violated our shared rules of conduct? It is also quite insensitive to Jane, who has given her life to law to say that it has no value. If you really believe this, I would suggest that you experience lawlessness for a time and see if it changes you. That said, I suspect the issue you want to raise is that “the system” as we know it may not be sensitive enough to victims, although I imagine those falsely accused, the subject of the day, would also find that the system does not always work for them, and that the machinations that ruin their lives even if legally exonerated go well beyond the court and into the other aspects of social life. Yet, it is not right or wise to abandon the principles and institutions that have defined civilized life. I suggest instead that we redefine our mindsets and processes of emotional intelligence.

        • Thanks, Martha. Your quip about cross dressing made me laugh, but no I’ve not been driven to that just yet! I think also you misunderstood the point I made about the criminal justice system which is by no means extreme. My point was simply this – that the rules of evidence that apply to criminal trials are outdated. I say this is not extreme is because when I did my training to become a solicitor many years ago (as I too would probably be considered an older woman), this was the view of my criminal law lecturer who was far from being a feminist (or indeed a leftie). Also, I’m pleased that you’ve felt that you’ve been heard on the site as we do welcome all views, as long as they are not crude or deliberately offensive which obviously yours weren’t.

        • vicki wharton says:

          Just wanted to add that the law around rape is clearly not working and therefore results in a virtual state of lawlessness in this aspect of our society. 600 convictions in 100,000 rapes is simply not acceptable in any society that values justice and I would welcome hearing Jane and Martha’s solution to this as simply to defend a system that clearly does not serve the victims of crime is clearly a traversy of justice, not the real deal at all.

          • I waited to see if Jane would respond to Vicki as I know she has greater expertise in legal matters. My own initial response is that you are asking me to solve a problem that you have brought up, not I. My point is that all sexual violence is unacceptable and we should take a united stand against it. However, I will comment a bit further as you have requested me to.

            Without facts in support of your statistics, I can’t say they have much meaning. What is meant by “rapes” in this instance?

            I suspect that sad as it seems, as anti-utopian or ill-liberal, we might do better regarding at least statistics and possibly justice if we were much clearer about what constitutes rape and what should be penalized as a criminal offense. In general, I believe in keeping the government out of people’s private lives. So often in these “he said, she said” cases I suspect a good mediator or counselor would help both parties understand what occurred and why each party sees it a certain way, and perhaps come to a middle ground where both parties have learned to be more mindful. In such cases, police action, prosecution, etc. is almost certainly going to lead not to a conviction, but to ruined reputations, bitterness by not only those directly involved but others who view the case from their own standpoints, etc. In general, my own opinion is to build solidarity among people while also understanding that there are going to be differences and that everyone will make mistakes, even some serious ones.

            That said, when people push things to a degree where a kind of sociopathology emerges, where only their viewpoint is real or matters, where others are fodder or to be run over on the path to some indulgent view of justice, which is in such cases really about power and violating others, I have come to the conclusion, which gives me no joy, that such people are often not willing or even able to learn except through very hard lessons, if at all. False accusers and actual rapists share this category. It would be a better world if we could assign them to another.

            So, my reform of the justice system, I am afraid, is remove the violent (don’t especialy care if they are “punished” as long as they are not around the rest of us) and leave the others largely out of the “system” and to more charitable devices.

  5. It’s interesting to me that when you have someone you disagree with, or are “sniping” (an accurate term of Jane’s) that person must be a MAN! Wrong, although I was educated in a tradition that allowed women to be more assertive and straightforward and raised by a single parent, a father, “the best of father’s,” as Montaigne used to say of his. So, Alison, you are incorrect, but am I wrong in thinking you are cross-dressing? Lovely. However, I must say the group(think) accurately, I am sad and even ashamed to say, diagnosed me as too angry for helping others. I retired because I could no longer separate and sort. And, I appreciate the consensus among the group that false accusations are a true problem, this shows an ability to understand some of the difficulties of the issues we are faced with, unfortunately. However, let me be clear that I am saying that false accusations are acts of sexual violence, I am saying that in my experience, which is considerable, the person in this particular instance is likely to re-offend, and I am not sure that the fact that she is young excuses her behaviors. Is a young man, woman, or other, who rapes to be excused? Are such things the trivial mistakes of the young? No, more often than not, much more often, they suggest deeper “issues” which must be confronted seriously by any who care to. I wish this were not true, but I have it to be so. To be again clear, this woman is now found by a legal process (which is the best way we now have to these declare such things) to be not a victim but a perpetrator. She callously attempted to ruin the life, the future, the family, the prospects, the emotional and physical wellbeing and end the freedom of another man/woman/rock, etc. Those are now the legal facts, subject to appeal. These are acts of violence and you would do well by first admitting it, before it is time to argue the “degrees” and do the statistical comparisons. Personally, and I wish you would take the word of an old person about this, we and I mean all of us on this site and well beyond would do matter to seek common ground and build from that. Start by saying, yes, these are acts of violence, whether rape, falsity, or another crime against human peace and dignity and say, together, no, we will not tolerate them. If we find our systems do not properly sort the good and the bad, then let us work on that with the common purpose in mind of ending violence, no matter who perpetrates it or how it occurs. Let’s not start by trivializing some acts to underscore others, it is completely unnecessary and only weakens all parts of what should be a united cause.

    I appreciated some of your responses a great deal.

  6. vicki wharton says:

    Hi Martha
    The meaning of the word rape is when one person has vaginal penetrative sex with another person without their willing consent – this can be because they have been drugged (via alcohol or another drug), psychologically or physically intimidated, blackmailed, are asleep or are too young or mentally ill to give consent. Some other European countries also include rape to encompass when a person witholds a piece of information about their health such as they are HIV positive in order to get another’s consent to sex where the other party might not give it if they knew the other person’s status. I would suggest that most of the fuzzy boundaries that surround this subject come largely from men’s use of porn sites to inform their understanding of sexual behaviour. Porn is constantly pushing the boundaries of ‘consent’ whilst hiding from its responsibilities of the ‘monkey see, monkey do’ effect on its audience. As such, it is the only media that claims to have no effect on its audience’s behaviour without offering the slightest bit of research to underpin this statement which flies in the face of every other known media demonstrable and proven experience.

    • so, men cannot be raped. That would be most surprising to those who have been.

      • vicki wharton says:

        No Martha, I was talking about the definition of rape where it concerns women, which is what we have been talking about. I don’t think anyone here to date has been talking about men making false rape accusations. You keep putting 2 and 2 together and making 5 and then acting as if those are my thoughts – why are you doing that? Why do you keep making out that people are being a lot more confrontational than they are – and why make quips about people cross dressing? I don’t think your contributions here are about genuine engagement with the subject, they seem to be more about trying to have an argument which I don’t think is very constructive, so I am going to leave this here.

        • Vicki, If you recall, I was not the one who called myself a man. I think I’ll leave it here, too. I would not say my posts here were perfectly received, but a few of you engaged them and I appreciate that. I’d encourage others to at least consider them over time, but of course it is up to you whether you do so.

          Again, my point, which no one but Jane has embraced, is that we should be against all forms of sexual violence and not defend the perpetrators. A secondary point, only glancingly mentioned, is that we need to try our utmost to carefully delineate matters of purposeful violence (rape against whomever, false allegations by whomever, domestic abuse, etc.) from the common sloppiness of human relations. I personally find these views more rational, just and non-confrontational than most of the logic I hear from others these days. But I wish you all well.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *