Pakistan divided between the mullah and the model
Summary from IPS 09.02.11.
Veena Malik, a Pakistani actress, has been attacked by an Islamic leader after the actress’s appearance in the Indian version of “Big Brother”, “Big Boss”. Mufti Abdul Kawi called the actress “immoral” and accused her of shaming both Islam and Pakistan.
Since her return to Pakistan, Veena Malik has received flak both from the media and the clergy for working in a show in archrival India and for her supposed indiscretions during the show, including giving massages, and cuddling and hugging her male housemates.
She was also reprimanded for exposing herself in the way she dressed.
“I was who I am, I never pretended to be any different,” says Malik, undeterred. “I am an actress and an entertainer. I was not representing any Islamic group.” Those who found her offensive had the option, she says, to switch off the television channel.
Malik went further, saying she had tried to show the world a different side of Pakistani women, women who are “educated, liberal, independent”. The outside world, she says, has seen enough of women being thrashed in public. I can only agree with her there.
Malik is also clear that the criticism of her is due to the fact that she is a woman, saying, “I was a soft target because I am a woman. Had it been a Pakistani man in my place, he’d have returned a hero.”
She also attacked the “double standards with which we view and weigh a man and a woman” in Pakistan. “What is ok for a man is not ok for a woman, why?”
The criticism of Malik has exposed deep divisions in Pakistan between two very different sets of values.
She received widespread support from liberals and rights activists whilst on the show, but the reaction to her from religious leaders and the media illustrates that the space for liberal- minded people in Pakistan appears to be shrinking, with increased Islamic fundamentalism on the rise.
In December the liberal and outspoken governor of Punjab, Salman Taseer, was assassinated for supporting a Christian woman sentenced to death under the blasphemy law (see WVoN story).
Lawmaker and former information minister Sherry Rehman has been threatened she would “be silenced” for seeking amendments to the law.
Malik has been advised to step up her security following the row.











