Leading MSP’s comments on rape provoke outrage
Summary from Herald Scotland 13.2.11
A leading conservative member of the Scottish parliament (MSP) has caused outrage, following his response to a series of rapes in Glasgow.
Bill Aitken, shadow minister for community safety has been a district court judge, justice of the peace and is a deputy Lord Lieutenant of Glasgow. He is also convenor of the Scottish Parliament’s justice committee, which helps formulates rape laws.
In an interview with the Sunday Herald, Aitken was asked to comment on a series of attacks in which women have been dragged into lanes and raped.
Aitken argued that the most recent victim could not have been dragged from the city centre to Renfrew Lane, where the rape occurred.
He disputed the location of the rape, arguing that ‘Renfrew Lane is known as a place where things happen, put it that way’.
On being asked to clarify what he meant, Aitken said it was an area where ‘a lot of the hookers take their clients’. He noted that may not be the case, but continued by saying, ‘there’s always a lot more to these city-centre rapes than meets the eye.’
In the interview Aitken claimed that a lot of rape claims are falsely made by drunk women who then subsequently drop them.
He provided no evidence to back this up, then said, ‘I think there might be fear, if they are worried that somebody talks…and the word gets back to the boyfriend’.
After the interview was published, Aitken denied making these statements until he was shown a transcript of the conversation.
On being asked if he thought there was a difference between the rape of women who are prostitutes and those who are not, Aitken said, ‘well, the prostitute has possibly put herself in a position of some vulnerability.’
Aitken’s comments have been widely criticised and condemned by police officers, women’s organisations and other MSPs.
When commenting on his remarks, Aitken said he would regret his comments appearing to lessen the horror or severity of the law.
The International Union of Sex Workers (IUSW) have released a statement deploring what he said:
‘The idea that a woman’s consent to sex counts for less if she has sex for money is a common one,’ it states, ‘it is shared by those who campaign for criminalisation of sex workers’ clients.
‘One of the most ardently advocated feminist principles is that “no means no”. Ironically, according to some feminists, for sex workers, “yes” cannot mean “yes”. Until our consent is treated with the same respect as that of any other woman, attitudes like Bill Aitken’s will continue.’
The conclusion of the IUSW statement must be central to all and any change, be it reform or revolution, ‘policies that solve problems are based in reality and on evidence, not ideology.’
As soon as politicians and policymakers realise the bedrock of any conversation on sex needs to be consent, we may start getting somewhere.
















So he’s a liar as well as a bigot (needing to be shown a transcript of what he said to prove he had said it) … and he’s the head of justice??! No wonder Glasgow has such a problem with men’s behaviour …
This is OUTRAGEOUS!!!!!!!!! I live in Glasgow and I too am 38 years old. How can this man get away with these comments? How can we complain? Surely some action should be taken against him. I am shocked by the things that he has said.
Here you go, this is his email address. Bill.Aitken.msp@scottish.parliament.uk – I have emailed him too to say that it’s no wonder that Scottish rape victims get such short shrift in the Scottish justice system when a bigot like this in charge. What a ****ker!
Just to say, Vicki, that Kenny MacAskill is the Justice Secretary in Scotland, Tories aren’t in charge
Thanks, yes Bill Aitken made that point too, see below. I guess it’s just dangerous that anyone that is senior enough in the system makes these kind of comments – a because of the message they give off to victims and b because of the message it gives to perpetrators – that they will not be held accountable and the victim will take the blame.
Vicki, thank you for contacting Mr Aitken and making your feelings known. Also for reproducing his reply here, which I find quite extraordinary. He admits he made the remarks but defends them by saying that they he made them to get further information to make an “appropriate quote”!
Sadly these sorts of comments and the attitudes that underpin them are all too commonplace. When women complain of rape they are accused of bringing false claims against men, who are somehow turned into the victims of women’s spite, and on the few ocassions when women’s complaints are upheld, they are blamed for sexual assault and rape being perpetrated against them on the grounds that they were drunk, provocative etc. This MSPs comments reflect the whole patriarchal stystem which denigrates and punishes women who are raped, and he should be sacked immediately. But I am not holding my breath.
Reply from Bill Aitkin to my earlier complaint
Dear Ms Wharton
Thank you for your email.
Perhaps I can make the point first of all that I do not head up the Justice Ministry and I do feel that I also have been seriously misrepresented in this article.
When the reporter contacted me I felt that he had scant information and I most certainly do admit that I made the remarks reported. This however was in an attempt to get further information in order that I could have made the appropriate quote.
If the woman concerned had been a prostitute then clearly I would have been calling upon the police to take greater steps to protect such women and suggesting lines of inquiry that they might have made.
I very much regret that I placed myself in a position where there could have been an interpretation that I was either accusing this woman of being a prostitute or that I suggested that crimes against prostitutes were less serious. I twice in the course of the interview stressed that prostitutes were entitled to have the same protection as everyone else and it is regrettable that this quote was not included.
From your perspective I can well understand why you found the reported comments offensive and I regret this very much.
Yours sincerely
Bill Aitken
Dear Mr Aitken
Thank you for your response but I think you are missing the point. If, as you say, you did say the things you were quoted as saying whilst trying to gain further information in order to make the ‘appropriate’ quote – you have slandered the rape victim by inferring that she is a prostitute (rightly or wrongly a number of women might take that as offensive) and that women frequently make false rape accusations based on morning after regretted sex (where is your evidence for this apart from male paranoia). For your information, the number of false rape allegations according to Home Office reports is between 3 and 9% of reported rapes which at 15,400 equates to between 462 and 1386 per annum – I couldn’t find any data on how many of these false allegations actually result in a prosecution. The number of reported and unreported rapes per year, if you accept UK victim support agencies such as The Havens and Rape Crisis of 9 out of 10 rapes not being reported to anyone but themselves is 154,000 annually, with a conviction rate of 600 or 0.39%. I think, given the Justice systems appalling track record on gender violence, of which rape is but one component, you owe the victim a public apology and that you could do with counselling to unpick the facts as they stand from male paranoia at being held accountable for their own violence.
I will pass on your response to the website that posted the original article.
Hi Alison
Yes, his response is bizarre and appears in a complete state of disassociation between what he says or ‘appropriately quotes’ and what he feels and states directly as himself. That’s why I suggested the therapy as he doesn’t seem to understand his own baggage …!
Please join the Facebook Group campaigning to have Mr Aitken removed as Convener of the Justice Committee of the Scottish Parliament.
http://www.facebook.com/pages/Bill-Aitken-Must-Go-Campaign-for-a-New-Scottish-Justice-Convener/194959127189544