Women refused right to have early medical abortions at home
Summary of story from
the Daily Mail, 14.02.11
A bid to relax the law on early abortions by allowing women to take some of their pills at home was rejected by the High Court in London today.
British Pregnancy Advisory Service (BPAS) argued that scientific advances meant that women should now be allowed to to take the second dose of tablets for early medical abortion (EMA) at home.
BPAS’ lawyers claimed that at present, women suffer unnecessary distress about miscarrying on the journey home from the clinic, especially when using public transport.
The judge ruled that section 1(3) of the Abortion Act – ‘any treatment for the termination of pregnancy’ – extended to include both the prescription and administration of the drugs used in abortion.
However, he did make it clear that it was within the Health Secretary’s power to approve such treatment to take place at home.
BPAS responded by saying they were disappointed with the verdict, but happy with the judge’s acknowledgement that the Home Secretary had the power to change the existing situation.
“This would put an end to women making multiple, medically unnecessary visits to clinics and eliminate the risk of abortion symptoms beginning – and in some cases the miscarriage itself occurring – as they travelled home after taking the tablets.”
Health Secretary Andrew Lansley opposed the case, arguing that the 1967 Abortion Act required women to take first and second doses under supervision and on medical premises.
















This is an unfortunate decision. Lansley may have argued on the basis of the 1967 Abortion Act, but the clue that his claim is outdated is in the title: 1967. I have no doubt that the inaccurate press reporting of this case prejudiced his argument. I bashed my head against the breakfast table the first time I read the phrase ‘home abortions’ in my parents’ Telegraph!