Lesbian mother’s ex-partner wins court case
Summary of story from news.com.au, 17.2.11.
A court in Australia has ruled that a mother must not move interstate with her four-year-old daughter, despite there being no biological link between the child and the mother’s lesbian ex-partner.
The 41-year-old mother had applied to the Family Court for sole parental responsibility for her biological daughter, who she gave birth to after conceiving via an anonymous sperm donor.
Despite the ex-partner not being listed as a parent on the child’s birth certificate, the judge ruled that the two women had ‘equal, shared responsibility’ for the child.
The four-year-old child was conceived during the couple’s six-year relationship.
The ex-partner had earlier given birth to another daughter, also via an anonymous sperm donor, and the judge also took into consideration the four-year-old’s relationship with that older sister.
In his ruling, Judge Justice Cronin referred to a 2008 amendment to the Family Law Act whereby if a woman conceives through artificial insemination and has a spouse or de facto partner at the time, then they are both legally considered to be the parent of the child, regardless of biology.
The law is applicable to both heterosexual and lesbian relationships.
The judge stated that a long distance move would not be in the girl’s best interests until she was old enough to understand and maintain her relationship with her non-biological mother and sister.
University of Sydney Law Professor Patrick Parkinson said the case was an example of “biology being irrelevant” when it came to Family Law.
“Where there isn’t a biological connection (between the child and the other parent) it’s very easy to say ‘this is my child, not ours’. There are no easy answers to these issues.”











