EU may rule gender discrimination is illegal in the insurance world
Summary of Guardian article 19.2.11
There have been rumblings in the media all week about a potential European Union (EU) ruling that may make it illegal to discriminate on gender when setting insurance rates.
At the moment, cheap the rumblings seem to focus on two examples to illustrate what may happen.
Firstly that young women may pay as much as young ‘boy racers’ for car insurance, ambulance and secondly that insurers could have to pay the same annuity rates to men and women, thus bringing down the average annuity pot as women get lower payments due to living longer.
What is interesting about this is the way it has been framed in the media. For example, the Guardian today used the headline ‘Paying the Price of Equality’, therefore not so subtly denoting a subtext of ‘another fine mess those pesky feminists have got us into’.
Another interesting point in the same article was this statement:
‘It is important to remember that most annuities are bought by men. That means many wives who depend on their husbands’ retirement incomes stand to lose out.’
Do women really not buy their own annuties?
The court in Luxembourg will deliver its verdict on a test case by a Belgian consumer body on 1 March. I think we can be assured that whatever the ruling, the insurance industry will make sure it doesn’t lose out, whatever the cost to the consumer.











