Cornton Vale prison “in crisis” as women’s sentences double
Summary of story from The Scotsman, 15.3.11 and additional information by Lindsay Keith, WVoN co-editor
Following on from WVoN’s earlier story about the increasing number of women being imprisoned in Scottish jails, the report by the Scottish Centre for Crime and Justice Research said there was no suggestion that more women were committing crime.
Instead the growth in female imprisonment was “primarily a result of sentencers” increasing tendency to impose custodial sentences for specific categories of crime”, such as drug-related offences and breach of bail, as courts became “increasingly punitive”.
Almost all female prisoners in Scotland, convicted and remand, are held in Cornton Vale prison near Stirling.
It does not have an illustrious past – in a spate of suicides between 1996 and 2002 eleven women committed suicide while being held there. A 2009 report states that it has become even more seriously overcrowded since then, and that this has a negative effect on both staff and prisoners. It is, said the report “in crisis.”
Strategies were suggested in 1998 to limit the population to 100. A 2009 report puts the figures at 399. By its own admission the HM Scottish Prisons Inspectorate has requested a reduction in custodial sentencing, but, if heard, this request is clearly being overlooked by the judiciary.
Howard League Chairman John Scott, said: “We don’t want another spate of suicides like those at Cornton Vale, where women who were supposed to be in the care of the Scottish justice system killed themselves.
“The sentences they are receiving is a significant indicator that it is the judicial response which we need to be looking at. The judiciary need to be re-educated and reassess their approach.”
The Scottish government responded saying “Average sentence lengths for all types of crime are at their longest in a decade, and prison will always be the right place for serious criminals, however, we want to see low-level offenders paying their dues through community disposals because the evidence shows this is far more effective.”
WVoN co-editor comment: Given that its only dedicated holding facility for female prisoners is, by its own admission “in crisis” the Scottish government had better address the issue of the prison, or the sentencing, or preferably both, as a matter of urgency, before there are more deaths.











