subscribe: Posts | Comments

Muslim model defends Miss Universe contest bid

7 comments

Summary of story from BBC NewsBeat 29 March, 2011

A model bidding to become the first Muslim to represent the UK in the world final of Miss Universe has been defending her decision to enter (see WVoN story).

Shanna Bukhari, who is 24 and lives in Manchester, said she’s been sent racist and abusive messages since making it to the beauty contest’s UK final.

She believes Muslims in the UK should be allowed to have a western lifestyle, but Muslim groups have accused her of disrespecting Islam.

“[I get] comments like, ‘You’re not a Muslim because you’re doing this’ and it’s like, this competition does not make me a bad Muslim at all. So it does hurt me to think that people are thinking like that,” she said.

Some Muslims are upset because Bukhari would have to appear in swimwear in one round of the competition.

Mohammed Shafiq from the Ramadhan Foundation, a group that works with young Muslims in the UK, said:

“Islam is very clear that a woman should dress modestly and we do not believe that parading yourself in a bikini is appropriate…We are clear that we find what she’s doing distasteful. Lots of women find these [competitions] degrading”.

He accepts the right of Muslim women to wear whatever they choose, but that those living in western countries should still be respectful of Islam.

“We celebrate individual freedom but to suggest that someone who is opposed to something she’s doing needs to move off to another country is quite offensive,” he continued.

Bukhari said most people do support her, including her family in Pakistan and that she won’t be wearing a bikini but a one-piece and a sarong.

  1. Ayeesha says:

    I would like to take issue with some of the content in the article above. In particular something Shanna is quoted as believing: “She believes Muslims in the UK should be allowed to have a western lifestyle”. To non-Muslims this would sound a reasonable belief – after all, when in the west live as a westerner. (As an aside this is certainly a strategy adopted by sleeping terrorists who exist, undiscovered until they take action. Not that i am suggesting….) But to live a lifestyle that contradicts a belief system such as Islam is clearly not being a practising Muslim. The western lifestyle that (from the article) Shanna seeks to adopt is one where you enter beauty pageants and dress in a way that is totally against Islam. This is not just about leaving areas of your body uncovered as you parade in front of millions seeking approbation. Islam is also against adorning yourself in finery for the admiration of others – remember in the pageant entrants also dress up in great finery.

    Therefore it is an errant belief that Muslims should be allowed to have a western lifestyle – where such lifestyle conflicts with Islam. Remember too that muslims believe the Holy Quran to be the direct, unchanged, timeless word of Allah so it is not that Shanna conflicts with any man-made ‘rules’ but she is going directly against the instructions of Allah.

    These religious-based criticisms are not criticisms of Shanna the person but Shanna the Muslim. Were she to say ‘I am a committed vegetarian on ethical grounds but in the west I should be allowed to eat meat’ then the criticisms should be the same. Her ethics don’t change according to geography and neither does her religion.

    What the article does not say (presumably owing to space constraints) is that Shanna hopes to be a role model for other Muslim women. What that means is that she hopes other Muslim women will do as she has done i.e. go against her religion. That, to me, is worthy of far greater criticism than her actions by entering the competition but as role model and behaviour cannot be disentangled the criticisms thus gain greater force.

    Reading between the lines of the article above there is another criticism. Shanna often starts her sentences by reminding the interviewer that she is a muslim. indeed ths article would probably never have appeared were she not a Muslim as she would be the FIRST etc etc. Well, if you are going to use the fact you are a muslim as key part of your identity then you should behave as a Muslim – and, as she knows, she isn’t. therefore she is a hypocrite and is using her ‘Muslim identity’ to try and gain votes and certainly, to get publicity.

    That too is reprehensible.

    Ayeesha

    • Totally agree with you, Ayeesha. You can’t just pick and choose which bits of Islam suit you and ignore the rest. Shanna is more than welcome to pursue her western dreams and parade her scantily-clad body in front of millions, but she shouldn’t call herself a Muslim. As you say, she’s using religion to seek attention and court publicity, which seems to be working.

      • Jane Osmond says:

        Hmm…I am against beauty pageants on principle – whether the woman is Muslim or not, is irrelevant to the basic premise that women shouldn’t be judged on their looks. However, I do support her right to do so and call herself Muslim. In the West she has that right.

        • Yes she can do what she likes, call herself whatever she likes, it’s her right. But, by calling herself a Muslim and doing the beauty contest at the same time is a contradiction. She might consider herself as an English girl with western values, but the religion doesn’t change – pick one or the other.

  2. I support your right to disagree with Shanna Bukhari and I can see why you’re saying it.

    In my church recently we’ve been holding Muslims up as a good example to follow of people who bring God into their daily life (i.e. in daily decisions such as shopping, food, treatment of colleagues etc), which is something that Christians should be doing. I’m assuming that modest dress and not flaunting yourself are part of expressing your belief in God. That’s something I can understand.

    I would like to respectfully caution against saying that Shanna Bukhari can’t call herself a Muslim. People follow their religion with different degrees of commitment, have different levels of understanding and so on … But they are all children of God and all on a journey with God. I meet Christians who barely seem to understand Christianity. They deserve support and understanding, not condemnation.

    If you believe that she’s ill informed in her understanding of Islam or weak in her commitment to Islam, she deserves the sort of sympathy that you would give to an ill informed little sister. Not rejection.

    I’m not trying to offend anyone here by the way. So sorry if I’ve gotten up anybody’s nose.

    • I understand where you’re coming from Claire, but Shanna keeps on referring to Islam and that she’s a Muslim, yet she does the exact opposite. It’s like calling yourself a vegetarian and having a Sunday roast because it’s your ‘human right’ to eat whatever you like.

      Might sound like a cliché but it’s true actions speak louder than words, and her actions don’t match her words. If she feels like a true Muslim then the 24-year-old should’ve taken the effort to read Quran, which comes in English translation, and understand its teachings. I don’t think she’s after sympathy due to a lack of knowledge, she just wants the title of first ‘Muslim Miss Universe’.

  3. Ayeesha says:

    More importantly, as I have said, is her desire to get other Muslim women to behave unIslamically. I wrote a long article for a blog with her namem in the title (google it) so you can see the points substantiated.

    The point about ‘all on a journey with God’ – you must realise that Islam believes that Christians are going to Hell (for among other things, seeing Jesus as the Son of God and not just a prophet)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *