subscribe: Posts | Comments

ADF sex abuse scandal – is masculinity a good enough excuse?

2 comments

Comment and summary of stories from Telegraph, April 6, 2011 and Sydney Morning Herald, April 7, 2011

This story has a trigger warning a mile-wide. Only slightly less disturbing is the odd image the Telegraph chose to run with it.

An 18 year old cadet in the Australian Defence Force has alleged that a colleague set up webcams to film them having sex, while six of his friends watched on a live Skype feed from a nearby room.

The cadet was only made aware of the film when defence investigators contacted her.

The Telegraph reports that the cadet, known only as ‘Kate’ stated that when she found out about the film “her world had come ‘crashing down’.

“‘They had to read the statements that the boys had to make and I actually threw up.'” she added.

As I would have.

Over at the Morning Herald, Elizabeth Broderick, federal Sexual Discrimination Commissioner (intriguing title) and advisor on women’s issues to the Australian Chief of the Defence Force (even more intriguing) attempts to shine a light on the culture behind an incident like this one.

“Research has found workplaces and communities that are heavily male conform to masculine norms that are emphasised to varying degrees.

“Men should always ”be a winner”. Men should be ”tough” both physically and emotionally. Men should never be seen to be in any way feminine or acknowledge their ”feminine side”. They should be ”a man’s man” – one of the boys.”

This explanation relies on a definition of masculinity that relies on being ‘not feminine’ at its essence. It requires a highly aggressive hatred of the feminine to rule out her humanity entirely. And don’t even get me started for what that means for sexual interaction.

The view of the world from the charming Mr Greg Platt, of the Sydney Morning Herald commentsphere (yes, I’m officially making that word up) also draws on a conception of the masculine character:

“What Ms Broderick is not considering is that the traditional “masculine” character is precisely that required of a soldier. If you’re willing to kill other people, you have to be able to cut yourself off from the “enemy”, to consider them as less than you.

“It is from this that the boorish & aggressive behaviour that prevails in the military emerges. And it is not for nothing that this behaviour emerges in a string of sexual scandals in recent years.

“Throughout history, at the end of the war the victors have raped the women of the vanquished society. It is simply the expression of the sexual ethics of men who are conditioned to kill”.

Woh, that stings. Did he just refer to the systematic use of rape in war as “simply the expression of the sexual ethics of men who are conditioned to kill?”

I’m not sure these men are ‘simply’ expressing their ‘masculinity’ through acts of hatred toward the feminine.

I think they’re expressing masculinity through a fundamental rejection of what it means to be a human being.

Maybe Greg is right, maybe that’s also what makes them fantastic killing machines. But at what cost?

And what are we as a society when we still need a military based on that model?

Comments boxes all over the webosphere (leave me alone, I’m on a roll) will doubtless be defining this as somehow a feminist issue, but to be honest, I’m not so sure.

With the backlash against women to be found in so much of our contemporary culture, I’m not even sure that this is just about the military either. To be honest, I wouldn’t have been surprised to have read about this story at a university, or a council estate.

I understand that we need to look for reasons as to why these things happen, but if we’re not careful, what sounds like a reason – and I think this can be seen in the comment by our friend Mr Platt – can actually become an excuse.

It’s not a million miles away from saying ‘that’s just the way things are.’

I don’t accept that. And neither should anyone else.

I know many men who would never do something like this. Don’t you?

Ask them how they feel about the behaviour of these men being defined in terms of their masculinity. Then let me know what they said.

No, seriously. Do. And then do.

Because those men – your friends and mine – are also implicated when we start to discuss these sorts of issues in terms as broad as ‘masculinity’.

And if I was a man – apart from the fact that I’d be Atticus Finch crossed with Mikael Blomkvist – that would be something that would offend and worry me in equal measure.

  1. Anne Powles says:

    The particular factor in this case that takes it one step away from any attempt to classiffy it as part of a particular culture is the premeditated nature of this act. There must have been plenty of time for each of those involved with the skyping and voyeurism to change his individual mind.

  2. Since when is raping a sexual ethic?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *