Congresswomen more effective than Congressmen
Summary of story from the Wall Street Journal, store April 14, 2011
Women may be more effective members of the US House of Representatives than men, a new study says.
Researchers at Stanford University and the University of Chicago began with the hypothesis that women who attain political office must overcome an obstacle men don’t – a bias against female politicians — which might mean that those women who do gain office are especially talented and hard-working.
To test that hypothesis, researchers examined how much money Congressmen and Congresswomen steered to their home districts as a means to measure political ability.
The researchers tracked where approximately $20.8 trillion in domestic spending went from 1984 to 2004.
The study found that the average Congresswoman brought 9% more money to her district than the average Congressman. For the typical district, that means electing a woman brought a bonus of $49 million.
The effect was strongest in conservative districts, suggesting that women who were elected in such places go through an especially tough crucible.
As a test of their thesis, the authors looked at the subset of women who achieved office by succeeding husbands who had died during their terms.
There would be no reason to think, a priori, that those women were especially talented. And, indeed, they didn’t bring home any more money than men.
















It’s really unfortunate that the only measure of “effectiveness” is how much money one can steer to one’s district. I’d rather see other benchmarks of success.