Mothers kill their children more often than we think
Summary of story from Yahoo! News, April 16, 2011.
It’s a headline story whenever a case emerges of a mother killing her children, as Lashanda Armstrong did when she piled her children into her minivan and drove straight into the frigid Hudson River.
Our shock at such stories is understandable. They seem to go against everything we intuitively feel about the mother-child bond.
But mothers kill their children in America much more often than most people would realize by simply reading the headlines. By conservative estimates it happens every few days, at least 100 times a year.
Experts say more mothers than fathers kill children under five years of age. And some say our reluctance as a society to believe mothers would be capable of killing their offspring is hindering our ability to recognize warning signs and prevent more tragedies.
“…with this phenomenon, we struggle,” says Jill Korbin, an anthropologist at Case Western Reserve University who has studied mothers who kill children. “The solution is not…readily apparent.”
How common is filicide, or killing one’s child, among mothers? Finding accurate records is nearly impossible, experts say.
One problem is classification. The legal disposition of these cases varies enormously. Also, many cases may go unreported or undetected.
“I’d say a mother kills a child in this country once every three days, and that’s a low estimate,” says Cheryl Meyer, co-author of “Mothers Who Kill Their Children.”
Several databases track such killings but do not separate mothers from fathers or stepfathers.
“The horrific stories make the headlines, so we believe it hardly ever happens,” says Meyer, a professor of psychology at Wright State University in Dayton, Ohio. “But it’s not a rare thing.”
Meyer and co-author Michelle Oberman interviewed women at the Ohio Reformatory for Women. They found that of 1,800 women at the prison, 80 were there for killing their children.
It’s also a phenomenon that defies neat patterns, as it cuts across boundaries of class, race and socio-economic status.
Different as the cases can be, there are some factors that link the poor teen mother who kills her baby in a bathroom with an older, wealthier mother, and one of them, experts say, is isolation.
“These women almost always feel alone, with a total lack of emotional support,” says Lita Linzer Schwartz, a professor emeritus of psychology and women’s studies at Penn State, and co-author of “Endangered Children.”
Schwartz says women are often not checked for mental illness after their crimes, and that is unfortunate.
“Women need better treatment not only before, but after,” she says. “They get tormented in prison, when often what they need is psychological care.”
Oberman, a law professor at Santa Clara University, says mental illness is not always obvious; sometimes depression is enough to send a woman over the edge.
“Almost all these women are not in their right minds (when they commit these acts),” she says. “The debate is whether they’re sick enough to be called insane.”
Besides isolation, another frequent similarity in the cases is a split with the father of the children. “So often there is an impending death or divorce or breakup,” Meyer says.
In the case of Armstrong, she had apparently argued with the father of three of her children just before driving into the river.
This was one of those cases where the mother was committing suicide and decided to take the kids with her. The logic of many of these mothers, experts say, is that they are protecting their children by taking them along.
“We see cases where the mother thinks the child would be better off in heaven than on this miserable earth,” for example with an abusive father, says Schwartz. “They think it’s a good deed, a blessing.”
A good deed — performed by a good mother. “It’s how the sick mother sees herself being a good mother,” says Oberman. “Once she decides she can’t bear the pain anymore, she thinks, ‘what would a good mother do?'”
Meyer, for one, is angry that the people around Armstrong didn’t take heed of the warning signs earlier.
“To me this is a textbook case,” she says. “This woman was completely overwhelmed. Almost always, you can find people who say, ‘I knew something was wrong.’ This did not come out of the blue. I say shame on the people who saw signs and didn’t do anything. This is your responsibility, too.”
But, she adds, it doesn’t help to gape at a few of the more shocking cases and then move on.
“People focus on the spectacular cases — and they are spectacular,” she says. “But that means another few kids will die over the next few days without much notice, and that is very sad.”











